Twitter Debate About Where A Centaurs Heart Would Be Located

Author image for AmyBrown
AmyBrown
Jan 3, 2020 1:30 PM EST

Good question. 

Would the centaurs heart be located in the human half or the horse half? 

Can't say the thought has ever crossed our minds but now we have to know! 

Thank you @FredWuMD for bringing this raising this question. 

Advertisement
  • 01
    Text - Fred Wu, MD @FredWuMD Serious question for #medtwitter: If you show up at a code, and the patient is a centaur who had a cardiac arrest, ignoring the joules question, where do you think the defib pads should go? A, assuming the heart is in the human part, or B, assuming the heart is in the horse part? в
    via @FredWuMD
  • 02
    Text - K @emergency_CNS Jul 27, 2018 Replying to @FredWuMD Ya reckon their lungs are in the horse or human? I started seeing it more like a giraffe Fred Wu, MD @FredWuMD It doesn't seem like human-size lungs would have enough capacity for 2/3 of a human AND 2/3 of a horse. I still tend to think the heart and lungs would be mainly in the horse part and maybe some accessory heart/lungs in the human part.
    via @FredWuMD
  • 03
    Text - efunkem @efunkEM Jul 27, 2018 Replying to @FredWuMD Assuming 2 hearts I would suspect the human heart supplies the brain, therefore l'd prioritize that one. If the horse part goes completely ischemic and has to be amputated, so be it. Fred Wu, MD @FredWuMD You don't think that if the human heart arrests, the horse heart would be able to maintain adequate cerebral perfusion by itself? I honestly don't know. I've been thinking about this all week. 558 10:04 PM - Jul 27, 2018
    via @FredWuMD
  • 04
    Text - efunkem @efunkEM Jul 27, 2018 Replying to @FredWuMD If the horse heart is sufficient alone, then evolution would have caused the disappearance of the human heart by this point, in which case you should def defib location B first. A fascinating mental exercise. Fred Wu, MD @FredWuMD Not necessarily. The hagfish has several "accessory" or "auxiliary" hearts, and an octopus has a syst mic heart that circulates throughout the body and two branchial hearts that circulate it through the gills.
    via @FredWuMD
  • 05
    Text - K @emergency_CNS Jul 27, 2018 Replying to @FredWuMD Maybe it's a double heart kinda set up. One in each, obvs the horse heart is the main pump. If the horse heart stops, the human one not far behind. Compress human heart to maintain neuro blood flow. Attach the auto compression device to the horse chest. Zap em both. Fred Wu, MD @FredWuMD Commercial defibrillators only go up to 360J/200J. Seems like wishful thinking to hope that will get through the horse chest (is saying that offensive t
    via @FredWuMD
  • 06
    Text - K @emergency_CNS Jul 27, 2018 Replying to @FredWuMD Okay, zap human while the thumper continues on horse chest. If first zap unsuccessful - get out the internal defibbers, chop the horse open and find its heart. Zap Welcome back- zip em back up. Fred Wu, MD @FredWuMD I like that: Early thoracotomy in cases of centaur cardiac arrest!
    via @FredWuMD
  • 07
    Text - efunkem @efunkEM Jul 27, 2018 Replying to @FredWuMD Start with A, if that doesn't work, try B with as many pads as you can find turned up as high as they'll go Fred Wu, MD @FredWuMD It seems doubtful a human-sized heart could maintain adequate circulation for a centaur body. My money would be on the heart being in the horse chest. Although maybe the human chest contains an accessory heart. Like in a hagfish. O 1,149 9:53 PM - Jul 27, 2018
    via @FredWuMD

Tags

twitter heart debate interesting tweets
Scroll Down For The Next Article