'She told me I was "erasing" her son's identity': New mom demands that everyone call newborn by his elaborate full name, considers limiting contact with 30-year-old brother for using nickname

Advertisement
  • 01

    AITA for refusing to call my sister's baby by his 'full name'?

    Mom holding her baby
  • 02
    So, my (27M) sister (30F) recently had a baby, and she and her husband chose a very elaborate name for him—think something like Maximilian Octavius Peregrine (not the actual name, but close in vibe).
  • 03
    It's a mouthful, and while it's cool and unique, everyone in the family has naturally started calling him "Max" for short.
  • 04
    Name tags including hael Oliver than Liam William
  • 05
    Well, my sister is furious about this. She insists that he should always be addressed by his full name because they "carefully curated" it, and shortening it is "disrespecting their vision." I thought she was joking at first, but she has actually started correcting people mid-conversation:
  • 06
    Me: "Aw, look at little Max!" Her: "It's Maximilian Octavius Peregrine, please."
  • 07
    At first, I tried to humour her, but it's getting exhausting. I told her that while I respect her choice, nicknames are a natural thing, and I don't think it's
  • 08
    fair to police how everyone speaks-especially when everyone is defaulting to Max anyway. She told me I was being dismissive and "erasing" her son's identity.
  • 09
    Now she's making a big deal about how I refuse to "honour" her son's name, and apparently, she's even considering limiting contact between me and my nephew if I "can't respect" her wishes. My
  • 10
    Dad napping while holding baby
  • 11
    parents think she's overreacting, but some of her friends have sided with her, saying that parents deserve to have their child's name used as intended. So... AITA for refusing to use my nephew's full name all the time?
  • 12
    judgejudyxecutionr OMG! "Carefully curated" their child's name and you're "disrespecting their vision." What a pretentious AH. He's a human being, not an art exhibit.
  • 13
    She's in for a world of frustration when peers and teachers start using a nickname for him. Your sister is not doing her kid any favors, and I feel bad for your nephew for the many years ahead of this kind of ridiculous nonsense.
  • 14
    Basic Rabbit4 Pretentious is being kind. Imagine the kid being in kindergarten having to write out his full name every time bc its his mom's vision. I'm calling it now, at 18 this one's going no contact.
  • 15
    Whiteroses7252012 He's going to be called "Max" by every kid in his class. That's just how kids are. They're not going to give a cr p about his mom's "carefully curated" name.
  • 16
    Budddydings44 OP Yeah it's kind of been like this for a while. She did the same thing with a cat we had as children
  • 17
    Calm_Initial Or when the kid themselves hates their full name. My child declared at 3 that she didn't like "Arabella" and had to be called "Bella" (close example but not real name) at 18 that hasn't changed she's never gone by her full first name.
  • 18
    ProfessorDistinct835 NTA. Kindergarten is gonna be lit!
  • 19
    Man-o-Bronze I'd love to be in that first parent-teacher conference when the teacher calls him "Max."
  • 20
    Young boy hiding under desk in classroom
  • 21
    Spare-Possession-490 That kid isn't going to be able to write his own name until he's about eight. I hope he doesn't have a surname like Ponsonby-Smitherington- Tiddlywinks to match
  • 22
    Snugglebunny1983 NTA. She needs to realize that as he grows up and starts going to school, he's going to want a shorter name.
  • 23
    PonchoPerez Nta. But you should start adding more to his name each time to show her how ridiculous it sounds. Maximilian Octavius Peregrine First of his name, taker of naps and filler of diapers, Lord of shrieking cries, and Waker of Parents
  • 24
    1pinksquirrel1scotch This is it OP. Instead of shortening it, you go the other way and make a grand production out of his name every. single. time. This is one of those cases where you can get your point across, and get one over on your sister, by doing exactly what she wants.
  • 25
    Dry_Bowler_2837 It's fine if she wants you to use Maximilian. I think you should respect that. But all three is just ridiculous. No.
  • 26
    threebecomeone Came to say this! I'm reading all the comments because I'm this mom! I was very clear my children got called by their proper first name! Not the full 3 or 4 names!! But I wanted them to have the power to not be stuck with a silly little kid name like Sammy or Jimmy or Becky. Let them or their friends give them a nickname. But I also chose 2 syllable names
  • 27
    Advanced_Lime_7414 That's what isn't clear about this. Creating a nickname isn't the same thing as not using all 3 names so I want OP to clarify which is actually being asked of them
  • 28
    elliedesirable NTA. Seriously, she's been watching too many period pieces if she thinks people are going to say three full names every time they talk to her son. In today's world, nicknames are the norm, and expecting everyone to follow her very specific vision is out of touch. She's definitely taking this way too far.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article