I wish I could tell you that your favorite Christmas movie says a lot about you, but unfortunately, it does not. Your favorite Christmas movie is probably just what was constantly playing on TV when you were a kid or which VHS tapes you had. If it weren't for television reruns, It's a Wonderful Life, and A Christmas Story would not have the iconic reputation they've developed. In fact, they'd probably be largely forgotten.
Even though our favorite Christmas movies are more based on when we were born than their quality, they still mean a lot to us. Most everyone who celebrates Christmas has a favorite Christmas movie, and I am no exception. I know that the Hallmark classic Eloise At Christmastime is not an objectively great movie, but that won't stop me from watching it every single year without fail. The people of Reddit came together to debate which Christmas movie is #1, and I can't help but stan so many entries on this list.