10 Mind-Bending Fan Theories That Could Actually Be True

• 01

  Star Wars - Jar Jar Binks is a Sith Lord

  

  This theory suggests that the clumsy and comical Jar Jar Binks was actually a Sith Lord, secretly manipulating events throughout the prequel trilogy. His seemingly foolish actions may have been a facade to hide his true intentions and masterful control over the Force. Fans point out moments where Jar Jar appears to be using the Force to save himself and others, as well as instances where he influences important decisions. This theory even suggests that Jar Jar may have been working with Emperor Palpatine to bring about the fall of the Jedi Order and the rise of the Empire.

  Via Culture Slate
• Advertisement
• 02

  Harry Potter - Draco Malfoy is a werewolf

  

  Some fans believe Draco Malfoy was bitten by a werewolf, explaining his increasingly hostile behavior and the emphasis on his relationship with Fenrir Greyback in the later books. This theory argues that Draco's transformation was meant to parallel Remus Lupin's story, showing the darker side of lycanthropy and the impact it has on the individual and their family. It also posits that Draco's mission to kill Dumbledore was actually a punishment for his father's failure to retrieve the prophecy in the Department of Mysteries.

  Via Book Bub
• 03

  The Matrix - Agent Smith is actually the One

  

  This theory posits that Agent Smith, not Neo, is the true savior of the Matrix. As the ultimate anomaly, Smith forces the Matrix to reboot, fulfilling the prophecy and balancing the system. In doing so, Smith becomes an unlikely hero. Proponents of this theory argue that Smith's actions lead to the end of the war between humans and machines, as well as the eventual peace between the two factions. They also point to the fact that Neo's abilities seem limited in comparison to Smith's near-omnipotence within the Matrix.

  Via Screenrant
• 04

  Marvel Cinematic Universe - Stan Lee's cameos are all the same character

  

  Fans theorize that Stan Lee's numerous cameos throughout the MCU are actually the same character, Uatu the Watcher, an omnipresent being who observes important events in the Marvel Universe. This theory was confirmed in "Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2" when Stan Lee is shown conversing with other Watchers, recounting his various appearances in the films. This interconnected cameo storyline adds a fun and whimsical layer to the sprawling MCU narrative.

  Via looper
• Advertisement
• 05

  Batman - The Joker is actually the hero in The Dark Knight

  

  Some argue that the Joker is the true hero of "The Dark Knight," as his actions ultimately lead to the destruction of organized crime in Gotham City. By pushing Batman to his limits, the Joker forces Batman to make difficult choices that result in a safer city. The Joker's plan to expose the corrupt nature of Gotham's institutions and force Batman to question his own morality is a twisted form of heroism. This theory paints the Joker as a necessary evil, a catalyst for change that ultimately benefits the people of Gotham.

  Via Sunny Skyz
• 06

  The Lord of the Rings - Gandalf planned to use eagles all along

  

  This theory suggests that Gandalf intended to use the eagles to fly the Fellowship to Mordor but was prevented from sharing his plan due to Saruman's interference. His last words, "Fly, you fools," may have been a hint to the remaining members of the Fellowship. Fans argue that using the eagles would have been a more efficient and safer method of transportation, avoiding the many dangers encountered on their journey. However, this plan would have also made their mission more noticeable, potentially alerting Sauron to their intentions.

  Via New Line Cinema
• 07

  Inception - Cobb's totem isn't the spinning top

  

  Fans speculate that Cobb's real totem in "Inception" is his wedding ring, not the spinning top. The ring appears only in his dreams, suggesting that if he wears the ring, he is in a dream; if he isn't wearing it, he's in reality. This theory argues that the spinning top is actually Mal's totem and that Cobb only uses it to remind himself of her. Proponents of this theory point out scenes where Cobb's ring is visible or absent, corresponding to whether he is dreaming or awake. This interpretation adds another layer of complexity to the film's exploration of dreams and reality.

  Via Screenrant
• Advertisement
• 08

  Game of Thrones - Tyrion Lannister is a Targaryen

  

  This theory posits that Tyrion Lannister is not Tywin's son, but rather the illegitimate child of the Mad King Aerys Targaryen and Tywin's wife, Joanna Lannister. Fans argue that Tyrion's intelligence, fascination with dragons, and strained relationship with Tywin are all evidence of his true parentage. This theory would make Tyrion the third head of the dragon, alongside Jon Snow and Daenerys Targaryen, adding another layer to the prophecy of the Prince That Was Promised.

  Via Nerdist
• 09

  Back to the Future - Marty McFly dies multiple times

  

  Some fans believe that Marty McFly dies multiple times in "Back to the Future Part II" and "Part III," with Doc Brown repeatedly traveling back in time to save him. Proponents of this theory point to the improbability of Marty's many near-death experiences and the fact that Doc Brown seems to be conveniently present to rescue him. They argue that Doc's knowledge of time travel would allow him to manipulate events and ensure Marty's survival, although this would also risk altering the timeline and creating unforeseen consequences.

  Via Screenrant
• 10

  The Shining - Stanley Kubrick's Apollo 11 confession

  

  This fan theory suggests that Stanley Kubrick's "The Shining" is actually an elaborate confession that he helped the United States government fake the Apollo 11 moon landing. Proponents of this theory point to several perceived clues hidden within the film, such as Danny wearing an Apollo 11 sweater and the repeated use of the number 237 (the moon is approximately 237,000 miles from Earth). They argue that Kubrick intentionally incorporated these symbols and references to hint at his involvement in the alleged moon landing hoax, although this theory remains purely speculative and has been debunked by many experts.

  Via The Indian Express

Tags