Top 5 Fan-Requested Additions for The Lord of the Rings' Second Extended Edition

The Lord of the Rings trilogy has already been blessed with extended editions, but in the immortal words of Peregrin Took, "What about second extended editions?" As amazing as Peter Jackson's extended editions are, there were still scenes that didn't make the cut. Now, fans of Middle-earth are clamoring for a second helping of their favorite epic. Here are the top 5 scenes fans want to see added to The Lord of the Rings' second extended edition, from unseen character moments to thrilling adventures that were left on the cutting room floor.

The Lord of the Rings fans are nothing if not passionate, and their desire for a second extended edition proves their love for the epic tale is everlasting. It remains to be seen whether their wish will be granted, but one thing is certain – the appetite for more Middle-earth adventures is as insatiable as a Hobbit's hunger.

Posted by Nimrod Aldea

1
Extended Prologue: The Battle Against Sauron's Army

Fans are eager to witness more of the intense battle against Sauron's forces in the prologue. These additional scenes would highlight the valiant efforts of the armies of Middle-earth and provide greater context to the struggle for the One Ring.

Via Tolkien Answers
Advertisement
2
Aragorn and Arwen's First Meeting

The first encounter between Aragorn and Arwen would offer a deeper insight into their connection and love story. This longed-for scene would allow fans to appreciate the characters' romance from the very beginning of their relationship.

Via Tolkien Answers
3
Eowyn vs. Uruk-Hai

An action-packed scene featuring Eowyn battling a fearsome Uruk-Hai would not only showcase her bravery and combat skills, but also further establish her as a powerful and inspiring character in the story.

Via Tolkien Answer
4
Sauron's Showdown with Aragorn

The final battle could have been even more epic, with the Dark Lord Sauron himself making an appearance and clashing with Aragorn. This thrilling confrontation would have raised the stakes and added another level of excitement to the trilogy's climax.

Via Tolkien Answers
Advertisement
5
Eowyn and Faramir's Wedding

A glimpse into Eowyn and Faramir's wedding would provide a heartwarming conclusion to their characters' arcs, as they find love and happiness after facing unimaginable hardships throughout the story.

Via The One Ring
6
Legolas and Gimli's Epilogue Adventure

Fans can't get enough of the beloved duo, Legolas and Gimli, and would be thrilled to see more of their adventures as they travel together in the epilogue. This scene would serve as a fitting tribute to their enduring friendship and the unbreakable bonds formed throughout their journey.

Via Tolkien Answers
7
You can help make it happen (Maybe)

Remember, these aren't just wishful thinking; there are actual scenes that were filmed but didn't make it into the final cut. And if you want to maybe one day see these deleted scenes brought to life, you can support Don Marshall by buying his "What about second extended edition" merch. He plans to use some of the money he makes from selling the merch to buy ads so Warner Brothers Studios knows we want this.

Via Donmarshall72