20 Half-Baked Cookie Cutter Shapes That Still Pass the Vibe Check

It's the holiday season! Grab your cookie sheets, your shortbread dough, and the frosting bags, because it's time to dig up granny's old cookie cutters to bake up some holiday cheer! Except, when you look at granny's cookie-cutter shapes, it's hard to decipher what they're even supposed to be. Is that a deformed Christmas tree? Or some kind of obscure Pokemon? Is this a dreidel? Or just a lumpy arrowhead? 

It's tough to say who even thinks up the strange shapes over there at the cookie-cutter factory, but hilariously, it's very common to incorrectly identify your cookie shapes. Although with the context of the packaging, it may seem obvious that your cookie-cutter is shaped like a turkey with a cowboy hat. But once years have gone by with those metal cut-outs sitting in the drawer, it can be tricky to piece together what you're even looking at anymore… 

So if you'd like to enjoy some of the silliest, most unidentifiable cookie-cutter shapes, scroll onward for these half-baked ideas!

Author image for Jesse Kessenheimer Jesse Kessenheimer
Advertisement

Stay entertained and up to date by following us on Facebook and Instagram!

Tags

christmas hilarious whats my cookie cutter recent family fun silliest christmas special Christmas cookies lol cookie decorating silly trending reddit thread half baked decorated cookies Reddit holidays cookies
Scroll down for the next article

Also From Memebase

Trending Now

Mom of a 6-year-old with 1 on the way begs her husband not to invite her mother-in-law on their vacation after mother-in-law moved into their 2 bedroom home with her 4 dogs: 'I really just wanted a trip away from her before this baby comes'

Mom of a 6-year-old with 1 on the way begs her husband not to invite her mother-in-law on their vacation after mother-in-law moved into their 2 bedroom home with her 4 dogs: 'I really just wanted a trip away from her before this baby comes'

01
Restaurant worker quits after 4 shifts when owner shouts at them during service: 'Finished the shift in silence and handed my notice in today'

Restaurant worker quits after 4 shifts when owner shouts at them during service: 'Finished the shift in silence and handed my notice in today'

02
‘She sent me to the ER the first time they visited. She is not allowed in our house’: Disrespectful houseguests keep smuggling dairy into sister-in-law's allergy-safe home, forcing homeowner to demand TSA-style baggage checks - Update

‘She sent me to the ER the first time they visited. She is not allowed in our house’: Disrespectful houseguests keep smuggling dairy into sister-in-law's allergy-safe home, forcing homeowner to demand TSA-style baggage checks - Update

03
Friendship group falls apart before a big vacation, leading one friend to cancel everyone's hotel rooms without a word: ‘I do not want to stay at the same hotel as them’

Friendship group falls apart before a big vacation, leading one friend to cancel everyone's hotel rooms without a word: ‘I do not want to stay at the same hotel as them’

04
25+ of the Best Gaming Memes of the Week (April 23, 2025)

25+ of the Best Gaming Memes of the Week (April 23, 2025)

05
Entitled wife repeatedly leaves her husband to fend for himself with 3 kids, guilt-tripping him into staying behind so she can live her life: ‘She went on 3 trips abroad without me’

Entitled wife repeatedly leaves her husband to fend for himself with 3 kids, guilt-tripping him into staying behind so she can live her life: ‘She went on 3 trips abroad without me’

06
Advertisement