Woman Evicts Her Sister-in-law After Children Destroy Her Prized Artwork, the Whole Family Gets Involved

Advertisement
  • 01
    r/AITAH • 1 day ago PepperHunter1 AITA for evicting my sister and her kids after they damaged a special room in our house?
  • 02
    Hi Reddit, i recently had some trouble with close relatives and i need your thoughts regarding this. (names are ofc changed).
  • 03
    I (35M) live with my wife, Julie (33F), and our two children. We have a special room in our house, a studio where Julie, who is an artist, works on her artwork. It's a very important space for her, not only for her work, but also as a personal sanctuary where she finds solace.
  • 04
    My sister, Emma (38F), and her two children (7M and 5F) recently had financial problems and lost their home. Julie and I decided to take them in temporarily until they could get back on their feet. We explained the importance of the workshop and asked Emma to make sure the children stayed
  • 05
    to make sure the children stayed out.
  • 06
    Everything was going well until last week. Julie was working on a very important commission, a piece for a prestigious gallery. One afternoon, while we were out running errands, Emma's children managed to get into the studio. They used Julie's paints to draw on her canvases and damaged
  • 07
    several works in progress. When we returned and saw the disaster, Julie was in tears.
  • 08
    I confronted Emma, but she downplayed the incident, saying they were just kids and didn't understand the importance of what they'd done. She added that she found it hard to watch them all the time because of her own stress. Furious and seeing how devastated Julie was, I asked
  • 09
    Emma to leave our house. She tried to apologize, but by then I was too angry to listen.
  • 10
    Emma and her children left and took refuge with a friend. Now my family blames me for being too harsh and not showing compassion to Emma and her troubled children. Julie supports me, but I can't help feeling guilty. They are, after all, family, and I know the kids meant no harm.
  • 11
    AITA ? (im not an english native so i used an auto translator, sorry in advance for poor synthax)
  • 12
    Flimsy-Car-7926 • 1d ago NTA. They aren't toddlers. They are old enough to understand. It just sounds like their mother is one of those "oh they're just kids" because she doesn't supervise them or give consequences for bad
  • 13
    behaviour. If I were your wife I'd be devastated too. Your sister obviously doesn't respect you or your space. That has consequences. She is now dealing with them.
  • 14
    Edited to add: don't let your family bully you into taking her back.
  • 15
    PepperHunter1 OP 1d ago Thanks for your support guys. I now can hold up against my family and stand my ground with a peace of mind
  • 16
    yellow_roseee • 1d ago Your sister may have been going through a tough time, but she was disrespectful of your home and your wife's work. It's understandable that you were upset. NTA.
  • 17
    AbigailThomas38 • 1d ago NTA. Your home isn't a playground, and your wife's studio isn't a toy box. It's not just about the kids being kids; it's about your sister's responsibility as a parent to teach them respect for other people's
  • 18
    property. You made a kind gesture by opening your home, and instead of gratitude, you got chaos. and disrespect. It's not unreasonable to expect guests family or not - to - treat your space with care. By not addressing this
  • 19
    behavior, you'd essentially be telling your wife that her work doesn't matter. Good on you for standing your ground. Remember, you can love and support your sister and her kids without enabling destructive behavior.
  • 20
    • G... 1d ago • Edited 22h ago NTA Calmly and firmly inform your family that they now owe you $XXXXX for the destruction of your wife's work, because that's how much she's either been paid or is due to receive that amount including a form of
  • 21
    tax, as well as replacement of paints, canvases and other materials, including a decent lock for the door, and that money is due by the end of this week.
  • 22
    Then inform your family that until that money is paid back your not interested in what happens to your sister and her children because she's the one who chose to not supervise her children. and once her kids destroy their property then they'll
  • 23
    their property then they'll understand, because your sister is now finding out that her lack of supervision has consequences that she doesn't like.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article