First-time homeowner stands up to her overbearing mother-in-law after she rudely tries to redecorate her ’boring' minimalist house: ‘She said I was being ungrateful'

Advertisement
  • Cheezburger Image 10452390656
  • Advertisement
  • "AITA for not letting my mother-in-law redecorate my living room?"

    I (29F) recently moved into a new house with my husband (31M). We've been working hard to furnish and decorate it the way we like-modern and minimalistic. My mother-in-law, Susan (58F), has a very different taste. She's all about bold colors, heavy curtains, and what she calls "statement pieces."
  • Advertisement
  • We've been working hard to furnish and decorate it the way we like-modern and minimalistic. My mother-in-law, Susan (58F), has a very different taste. She's all about bold colors, heavy curtains, and what she calls "statement pieces."
  • Π
  • Last weekend, Susan came over for the first time since we finished decorating. As soon as she walked in, she made a face and said, "Well, this is... very plain." She then spent the next hour pointing out things she thought could "use some flair,”
  • Advertisement
  • like adding a floral wallpaper, swapping out our simple light fixtures for elaborate chandeliers, and replacing our neutral couch with something "more exciting." I laughed it off at first, but then Susan offered to "fix it" for us.
  • She said she'd bring over some items she had in storage and make the space "pop." I politely declined, saying we're happy with how it looks. She insisted, saying, "You'll thank me when it doesn't feel so cold in here."
  • When I refused again, she got huffy and said I was being ungrateful. Now she's been telling my husband that I'm too controlling and won't let her "help." My husband is on my side, but he's also feeling awkward because his mom is making such a big deal out of it.
  • Advertisement
  • A few family members have chimed in, saying I should just let her bring over a couple of things to "make her feel involved," but I don't think I should have to compromise my home to avoid hurting her feelings. So, Am I The J for refusing to let my mother-in-law redecorate my living room?
  • pretty_jesica Definitely NTA. Your home is your sanctuary, and you've worked hard to make it reflect your style and preferences. It's nice that your MIL wants to help, but there's a big difference between offering input and taking over. Standing your ground is absolutely the right thing to do-it's your living room, not hers!
  • shy_sofiaa This is our home, and it reflects our style, not hers. Standing firm on this feels crucial because letting her 'win' would set a precedent for future oversteps.
  • Advertisement
  • boundaries4546 Family members who say "she wants to feel involved" can sit the h l down. MIL 100% shouldn't feel involved in what you do in your home. I would text them and let them know that you will inform MIL that they are open to having her spruce up their home.
  • DevilPup55 Your house your style. Make sure she doesn't have a key. Stop her at the door if she tries barging in. If she does try something, just tell her that as soon as she leaves, it will go in the trash. Tell the flying monkeys to mind their own business.
  • tclynn No woman wants another woman coming in trying to take over her domain. You have a husband problem. People who criticize you, your choices OR your decision regarding anything of YOURS,
  • Advertisement
  • needs to step back, sit down or be cut off at the ankles. Best wishes your husband steps up and starts properly husbanding!
  • Butterfly Wings71 The relatives saying [she] should let her decorate need to let MIL decorate their living room. What an obnoxious demand and hope [she] gets some respect and peace.
  • Fickle Toe1724 Your mother-in-law has no right to try to redecorate your home. Stand your ground. Just tell her no. Every time she starts on the advice, tell her NO, we have decorated our home the way we like it. It is our home. If she says another word about it, show her the door and tell her to leave.
  • Advertisement
  • If you let her take over on this, it will never end. She will try to be involved in every decision. Including your children.
  • shy_sofiaa Exactly! Thank you for putting it so clearly. This feels like a boundary I have to set now, or it could snowball into other parts of our lives. I'll stick to my 'no' and make sure she knows this is our home and our decisions. Hopefully, it sends a clear message without needing to escalate further.

Tags

Scroll down for the next article

Also From CheezCake