‘It feels gross having to "prove" I am a good tenant every 30 days’: Landlord demands timestamped monthly photo reports from an always-early, perfect tenant

Advertisement
  • Woman reading a notebook in a softly lit kitchen, wearing a cozy cardigan and focused on the page.
  • My landlord now requires monthly "inspection reports" with photos of every room and I'm losing my mind

    I've been renting this apartment for about two years and everything was fine until my landlord decided to add
  • a new clause to my lease renewal last month. He calls it a "Tenant Property Maintenance Accountability Protocol"
  • which is honestly the most corporate sounding name for something so invasive I've ever seen. Basically I
  • now have to submit a photo report of every single room in my apartment on the last day of each month.
  • Kitchen, bathroom, bedroom, living room, even the hallway. Timestamped. Through his property management app.
  • Woman reading a book in warm-lit kitchen, wearing cozy cardigan and standing indoors in soft evening light.
  • I asked him what exactly he's looking for and he said "general upkeep and to ensure no
  • unreported damage is occurring". Which, okay, but I've never once damaged anything in two years. My security
  • deposit is sitting there untouched. I pay rent three days early every single month. There has been zero reason for this level of surveillance.
  • The worst part is the app he chose sends the photos directly to him and apparently he can
  • Curly-haired woman with glasses sits curled in chair, wearing earphones and adjusting sleeve in cozy indoor setting.
  • zoom in and comment on them. Last week I submitted my first report and two days later I got a message
  • saying my stovetop looked like it "may have grease buildup" and that I should "address this before next months
  • submission". I had cooked pasta the night before and wiped it down right after. The stove was fine.
  • I feel like I'm being managed like some kind of problem tenant when I've given him absolutely no reason to treat me
  • this way. My friend who is a paralegal said this kind of monthly photo surveillance requirement might actually not be
  • enforceable depending on the state but I havent had a chance to look into it properly yet. Has
  • anyone else dealt with something like this? At what point does "property maintenance" become just straight up harassment.
  • Tirno93 It's a difficult area because there's no set standard for inspections. Typically they happen 1-4 times a year, which imho is still pretty invasive. But a monthly self report is definitely excessive.
  • And the landlord's micromanaging approach definitely pushes it to the limit. Unfortunately the inherent power imbalance makes the situation very difficult.
  • Something that is worth noting is that while the RRA restricts reasons tenants can be evicted, not taking care of the property properly is one reason. It's likely that this landlord thinks he's being smart by creating a paper trail that shows this. Not to
  • say he's planning to evict you, but when a business is built on exploiting a power imbalance, the person at the top will always want to maintain that position of power.
  • We're currently dealing with a similar situation with our agency changing their inspection policies to be much more opaque and arbitrarily offering "fails" with nothing to back them up. I've pushed back via the
  • complaints process and their response so far has been pure DARVO and the next step is the ombudsman. It's bound to result in retaliation, but there's a point where you have to decide what's more important.
  • ComradeSasquatch It's harassment. Period. There is no reasonable cause to implement such a requirement. This LL has the mindset of wanting people to give them money to live in their rental without actually living in it.
  • What you're doing is giving the LL free labor. If they want you to comply with this, they should at least being paying for you time (though, they shouldn't be doing it all) or they can find the time for themselves to make the monthly inspections. You're being compelled to do it to subsidize their labor costs.
  • I have never had a LL inspection. I've had inspections from the housing authority to ensure the unit is complying with local codes, but never a LL inspection. I would get the h I away from this LL fast.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article