Homeowner installs $21K in solar panels, demands that their neighbor remove the Redwood tree in their yard because it shades the panels for 90 minutes per day: 'Your tree is costing me $37 of electricity every month.'

Advertisement
A building with solar panels
My neighbor and I have lived next to each other for 15 years. The redwood in my backyard corner was planted by the previous owner in 1987. It's 38 years old, healthy, and the reason my back patio is usable in August.
Cheezburger Image 10660366080
Eight months ago, my neighbor put a $21,000 solar array on his roof. Nice panels. He was proud of the 30% federal credit and showed me the app that tracks his production.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
A few months after the installation, he leaned over the fence and mentioned that my tree "catches" his panels in the afternoon. I said something like "that's the sun's fault, not mine" and thought we were done.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
Later, he brought his phone to my porch with the production graph pulled up. Between roughly 3:40 and 5:10 pm, November through February, my redwood's shadow crosses the lower left corner of his array.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
Ninety minutes a day, maybe 6% of his output. He had done the math and estimated it was costing him about $37 a month, around $444 a year, and said it affected his payback period.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
A few weeks later, he sent me a certified letter with an actual removal estimate attached. He said he expected me to cover the $8,200 removal and stump grinding cost. The letter said if I preferred, "a remediation trim" was acceptable, and included a quote for $2,900.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
A tree service he hired later looked at my tree and gave him their estimate. Then he texted that he'd "hate to escalate to small claims over a tree," but he'd documented everything, including his estimated lost production to date.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
I spent $150 on my own arborist. She confirmed the redwood is healthy, that the $2,900 "remediation trim" would remove about a third of the canopy and could seriously damage the tree or shorten its lifespan, and that removing it would change
via u/Educational_Sink8355
the drainage in both our yards. She also mentioned that in many places, solar shade laws consider factors like whether the tree existed before the solar installation. When I told my neighbor that, he said:
via u/Educational_Sink8355
"Trees can wait. Solar can't. Your tree is costing me $37 of electricity every month, and I shouldn't have to finance your shade."
via u/Educational_Sink8355
Man sitting on steps of a wooden a frame house
My wife thinks I should just pay for the trim. She says it's "a tree, not a family member," and my neighbor texts me production graphs at 7am now. Another neighbor suggested splitting the removal cost, because the tree "bothers him more
via u/Educational_Sink8355
than it benefits us" and we still live next to these people. A) Pay for the trim (or split the removal). It's $2,900 to end this, and a redwood isn't worth a small claims war with someone whose entire identity is now a production app.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
B) The tree stays. It was standing for 37 years before his panels existed. He bought a $21,000 system with a 38-year-old redwood in plain sight, and his payback math doesn't turn my backyard into his easement.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
Sewing-Mama Tree stays. Post this in the tree law subreddit. To start, take pictures and videos of your tree immediately, including measurements of the circumference. Keep the documentation from your arborist. That was money well spent.
via u/Sewing-Mama
Natural_War1261 And, to add to this great advice, install cameras that will notify your phone when your neighbour decides to take matters into his own hands.
via u/Natural_War1261
Sewing-Mama Oh yes! OP also save all communication from your neighbor about his desire to take down the tree. Communicate with neighbors if you are friends, and have them keep an eye on things or notify you if a tree removal service shows up.
via u/Sewing-Mama
Educational Sink8355 OP The arborist report already made me feel better about my decision. I was worried I was being stubborn, but seeing the actual condition of the tree changed how I looked at it.
via u/Educational_Sink8355
AccomplishedQuail841 i would also suggest contacting the arborist he talked to and informing them in no uncertain terms, that the tree is on YOUR property, and you do NOT wish it to be trimmed or removed. Keep records of this contact.
via u/AccomplishedQuail841
tkkana Also advise them you did not give permission for them to be on your property
via u/tkkana
Love Lobster With "No Trespassing" posted, and photos of them on the day you post them. Just to cover all your bases.
via u/Love_Lobster
carmelfan He knew the tree was there. He's being stupid.
via u/carmelfan
boganvegan And the solar company would have been able to factor in the shade from the tree when calculating production and payback period.
via u/boganvegan

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article