After posting an anonymous Glassdoor review about a toxic workplace, former employee receives legal warning demanding its removal and threat of an industry blacklist

Author image for Etai Eshet
Etai Eshet • Editor
Sep 9, 2026 8:00 AM EDT

If it wasn't this toxic, it would be almost touching about a company that treats a Glassdoor review as its greatest legal emergency, like a former employee describing screaming managers and high turnover is not a warning sign but an act of treason. 

Instead of asking why someone left after a month and felt compelled to tell future applicants what the place was like, the business chose a classic management solution: send a threatening email, demand silence within 24 hours, and hope fear performs the work. Instead of, say, decent leadership.


Companies like this one seem to believe they have discovered a brilliant loophole in reality. The review did not name names, except the company's of course, but it turns out it was detailed enough that the people could recognize themselves, which is awkward because that is generally how criticism works. If a person reads a description of their own workplace culture and immediately thinks, "This is definitely us," the issue is most likely NOT that an anonymous former employee wrote it.

Advertisement

  • Got a legal threat from my old company over a glassdoor review. Is this even real?

    Man with glasses looks at his phone with overlaying quote: text: “Everything I said is 100% true”
    via Hugo Delauney

    Employee reading an email from his former company

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • I left my last job about a month ago because the environment was just straight up toxic. Like, managers screaming in meetings
    via SyrsonScope
  • and constant gaslighting kind of toxic. Anyway i left a pretty detailed review on glassdoor because i felt like people should
    via SyrsonScope
  • know what they're getting into before signing an offer. I didn't lie about anything just shared my actual experience. Today i got a
    via SyrsonScope
  • formal looking email from thier "legal department" demanding i take it down within 24 hours. They are claiming defamation and
    via SyrsonScope
  • saying theyll blacklist me from the industry if i dont comply immediately.
    via SyrsonScope

  • The blacklisting threat deserves a very, v e r y slow blink. It has the same energy as a restaurant owner threatening to ban someone from eating any and all food forever because they left a one-star review. An employer can be angry, petty, and equipped with a letterhead, but none of that turns every unfavorable account of working conditions into defamation. Calling a former worker “disloyal” is cheaper than addressing why managers scream in meetings, why people leave quickly, or why a business needs intimidation to protect its reputation.

  • The funny thing is the review didnt even mention any specific names. It just talked about the high turnover and how the
    via SyrsonScope
  • Black and white photo of a man wearing glasses, reading something on his phone with a discontented look on his face, like his reading something he doesn't understand or agree with
    via Hugo Delauney

    Man looks discontented while reading on his phone.

    Representative only.

  • leadership treats people like robots. Now im actually kinda nervous though even though i know i'm right. Can they actually
    via SyrsonScope
  • do anything or is this just a scare tactic?? I live in an at-will state if that matters. Getting a formal letter like that is definitely unnerving and i really dont want
    via SyrsonScope
  • this drama following me or affecting my new job. I've already started somewhere else and just want to move on with my life but this feels so petty.
    via SyrsonScope

  • Still, a formal-looking message can make anyone nervous, especially when there is a new job to protect and no appetite for paying a lawyer to argue with a former boss who has decided criticism is a personal insult. The sensible move is not to panic or trade accusations over email. Save the original review, the threat, employment records, messages, and anything that supports the factual statements made, while checking whether the sender is actually counsel or simply someone in the company using a dramatic signature block.

  • Has anyone actually been sued for this before? I thought glassdoor was supposed to be anonymous but i guess they
    via SyrsonScope
  • figured it out because of the timing and some specific details | mentioned about the department. I really dont want to take it down because everything i
    via SyrsonScope
  • said is 100% true but i also dont have money for a lawyer to fight some petty owner who has nothing better to do. Its honestly
    via SyrsonScope
  • insane how far some companies will go to hide the fact that they're a terrible place to work.
    via SyrsonScope

  • The irony is that the company may have created the most convincing evidence of its culture after the employee already left. A workplace accused of being toxic responds to criticism with an ultimatum and a blacklist threat, then wonders why people think the review might be accurate.

  • dragpk247 you might as well just ignore it like how they ignore their incoming applications.
    via dragpk247
  • fredfoooooo How about you go back on glass door and copy and paste their threatening letter to you? Any downsides?
    via fredfoooooo
  • Common-Ad6470 If your review was totally factual then there is little they can do. Sure they can start legals but if it's factual then it's going no where except to make them look like a complete bunch of
    via Common-Ad6470
  • WalterCanFindToes Committing blackmail to take down a bad review?? Sounds like a wonderful place to be formerly employed at.
    via WalterCanFindToes
  • Dependent-Interview2 They might be fishing. Your response will prove their suspicion. Ignore, do not respond, do not post their letter on your review.
    via Dependent-Interview2
  • Harbinger_Kyleran Make them prove it was you.
    via Harbinger_Kyleran
  • natewOw You need to be talking to a lawyer about this. But if you're not going to do that, at least post this in a legal subreddit.
    via natewOw
  • Substantial-Tea-3125 My response would be "good luck"
    via Substantial-Tea-3125
  • AAron27265 You could always reply with "NeW eMail who Dis?"
    via AAron27265
  • Idlewild_33 Definitely save the email threatening to blacklist you. From what I remember, the glassdoor reviews will list the type of job the reviewer held, but not their name.
    via Idlewild_33

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

management workplace discussion employment issues boss workplace-stories hr coworkers colleague Horrible Bosses
Scroll Down For The Next Article