Neighbor wants extra money for private driveway snow removal after failing to secure the original contract.
A heavy-duty snowplow pushes through deep drifts on a road.
Photo is a representation of story scenes.
This homeowner says that they and several neighbors share a private driveway, with the only point of access to the driveway and, thus, the other properties being through the homeowner's own property.
I live in a neighborhood where several houses share a private driveway. Each homeowner owns the section behind their property, but the only entrance to the entire driveway crosses my property.
The homeowner stated in their post that there is no "recorded" easement for this access or any other type of written agreement regarding the access or maintenance of the driveway.
Really, it seems that the entire thing has relied on "good vibes": That is, a strong rapport and trust between the neighbors.
You can already see where this is going…
The homeowner goes on to write that each household pays "roughly" $2,000 annually for ongoing landscaping and maintenance of the properties, including lawn care and winter snow removal.
Posted by Jaded_Elderberry_957 in r/homeowners
Snowplow clearing snow from a rural road.
Still frame for contextual reference.
The homeowner goes on to explain that a single neighbor organizes this and collects the payment once a year. The neighbor had collected the money, which included an amount to cover increasing snow removal costs. It's no surprise that these services would have increased in value, especially given the current rising cost of fuel, which has had knock-on effects on just about every service.
This past spring, the neighbor collected the annual money, including an additional amount for increased snow removal costs. Everyone understood that both services were covered.
Snowplow clearing snow from a rural road in front of a house.
Provided to illustrate events of the source.
However, the homeowner claims that 8 months later, the neighbor said they had not been able to secure an ongoing contract with the existing snow removal service.
Eight months later, the neighbor disclosed that the original snow removal company had stopped offering the service, so they never actually secured a contract.
The homeowner says they, instead, used the rest of the money to prepay lawn maintenance costs for the following year to come… Without conferring with the other neighbors.
Instead, roughly half the collected money was used to prepay lawn maintenance for the following year.
The homeowner says that the neighbor claimed to have found another snow removal company, but that this new service was going to cost an additional $500 each over the next 6 months.
Now you're probably wondering, like I was at this point, whether this was $500 "over" 6 months with $500 being the total cost or $500 per month for 6 months.
Well, in the comments, the homeowner clarified that this $500 was per month per house, and not for the entire block. This puts the total bill at a whopping $3,000 in additional costs. That, on top of the $2,000 contribution that was already paid for in the spring.
Now, next spring's lawn care is already paid for, which I presume was a cost of $ 1,000 per homeowner per year. Two years covered (with next year prepaid): $2,000 paid each.
So, that's about $83 a month for lawn care for each homeowner.
In a quick search, I found lawn care to have an estimated cost of $100 to $400 per month for a single property.
Of course, this is a rough estimate with a load of variables, including where in the US you live, the size of the property, and the service and maintenance required.
So that's pretty cheap and seems to be above board.
However, that means that they had been paying $1000 for winter snow-clearing services, which puts the new rate at a ballooning cost.
A large snowplow pushes through a deep accumulation of snow
The picture does not depict real parties.
The homeowner says that they objected to this new cost, and that they weren't paying an excessive price for a service that they thought they had already paid for.
I pushed back, explaining that the original money was collected under the impression snow removal was covered, that the new pricing is excessive, and that I expect to be included in future decisions involving shared expenses.
This is where the homeowner says that they stated that they were withdrawing from the current arrangement.
They would still, however, allow the driveway to be cleared and for their neighbors to continue to use the driveway as access.
I also said I no longer wish to participate in these voluntary arrangements. I'm perfectly fine with a contractor clearing the entrance and the section of driveway on my property so everyone else can access their homes. I just don't agree to paying for a service I haven't authorized.
But the neighbor stated they were "obligated" to pay, the homeowner claims.
The neighbor insists I'm obligated to pay because the contractor needs to clear my section to reach the other properties.
So, now, the homeowner has appealed to readers of this homeowners community to see whether or not they are in the wrong for no longer wanting to pay.
This was how they finished their post, posing their questions to the readers.
AITAH? Am I obligated to contribute to snow removal simply because everyone else's access crosses my property, despite there being no recorded easement or maintenance agreement? And is it reasonable to refuse payment while still allowing the contractor to clear the driveway?
And this was a TLDR (Too long, didn't read) summary they gave of their post.
TLDR: Neighbor collected annual maintenance fees, never secured the snow removal contract, redirected some of the money toward next year's lawn service, and now wants everyone to pay thousands more for a replacement contractor.
I own the entrance to the private driveway, have no recorded easement or maintenance agreement, and am willing to let the contractor clear my section for everyone else's access but don't want to participate financially. Is the neighbor entitled to demand payment?
Gravel driveway flanked by fences and woods.
Recreated scenario included to enhance reader understanding.
So? What's the verdict? Is the neighbor entitled to the payment? And are they ethically in the wrong to withdraw their own contribution?
While this is not an exploration of the legal issues at play here (I want to keep well clear of that complicated issue), it stands to reason that in a lot of US states, an implied easement can be created by conduct and exist when a single piece of property was divided up and sold.
Obviously, in these circumstances, access to the parcels that are, say, set back from the road becomes an issue.
This is probably what is going on here, so the homeowner may be “obligated” to participate.
Still, in some states, like Texas, the property owner whose land the access is crossing is required to permit access but is not required to pay to maintain the road/driveway for those neighbors.
So, yeah, it's complicated. At any rate, the homeowner shouldn’t block access or stop paying without checking with a real estate attorney.
But that's not legal advice, by any stretch, just good common sense.
Easements can be tricky
Easements can be a tricky thing, even when they are in writing. They often involve some kind of shared contribution with another neighboring party and, when not handled with good intentions, can become a bit of a nightmare.
One house we were looking at had an easement that gave the neighbor the right to access our backyard to access the utility curb box, as the water and sewer passed through the backyard out to the street. The lot had been subdivided, and that's how they had decided to do it, I guess. I was a bit concerned about it and decided to have a chat with the neighbor about it and see if it would be an issue.
So, I got the number from the agent who had been assured by the homeowners that the neighbor was friendly. Well, I don't know if he just didn't like the sound of my voice or what, but the person who answered the phone was just about the most confrontational and unfriendly person I have ever spoken to in my life. Go figure.
Anyway, that was the end of that; I wasn't going to deal with that guy having access to my backyard whenever he pleased.
But that's probably for the best. You should never buy a house based on the current neighbors; rather, consider the privacy of the property in a worst-case scenario. It's incredibly likely that they could sell up and move, and you might end up with some nightmare of a neighbor next door.
There's a reason why that old saying “Good fences make good neighbors” is a thing.
Easements are extremely common everywhere. However, shared access across a neighboring property is extremely common in rural areas owing to the fact that there's usually one private driveway for multiple properties going out to a publicly maintained road.
There are all sorts of easements for different things, and it's not necessarily a bad thing to have them on a property you're looking at purchasing. But you would do well to understand where and what they are before locking yourself into an agreement and putting that final pen to paper on a property purchase.
You don't have to be an expert on property and real estate to know that having shared access or a shared driveway that runs through your property without a proper easement is going to be a nightmare at some point or another... For both you and your neighbors.
So what did responders have to say?
On the whole, responders seemed to be pretty flabbergasted by the costs that were being proposed.
Many suggested that there might be something else going on, and that the neighbor might be embezzling the money.
The following was the top-voted response in the original thread:
There was a response to this top-voted comment that I think was particularly relevant, but I forgot to grab it at first pass.
The responder, MehX73, says they work for a landscaping company and have repeatedly seen disagreements between neighbors over what the costs are to maintain their shared driveways.
They say that they "always have issues" with this and frequently deal with customers where the neighbor responsible for collecting the money tells the other neighbors that the cost is more than it is, so that their own portion is covered and they don't have to pay.
This was their comment they added in response to the above:
I agree with this. I work at a landscaping company and always have issues with the neighbors of shared drives. We have 1 person who misrepresented our costs so they themselves don't actually have to pay.
There another neighbor who calls to complain about the cost and to get a reduction but they want the full reduction applied to just their portion.
We have 1 alley where houses in the middle don't want to be included in the share because they don't drive, but the neighbors don't think they should have to cover that portion despite us needing to plow that portion to get to their house. We fire customers who can't agree all the time.
I am really curious how OP has a shared drive across their property but no easement. Regardless, if I were in their shoes, I would problably hire a show removal contractor to just do the part of the drive on their property and let everyone else figure it out themselves.
Here is where the homeowner clarified that it was $500 per house per month.
The homeowner also responded here to clarify that where they live gets frequent snowfall.
This commenter asked specifically what it was that the homeowner was objecting to. Here the homeowner also replied.
One user gave this advice, however, this may not be possible in the case of the implied easement I mentioned earlier.
The homeowner states here in a reply that this was their intention, but neighbors "became heated" at the suggestion.
This was one user's suggestion, though what leg does the homeowner really have to stand on here? There was no service directly paid for.
This long response was very skeptical of the entire thing
So, what do you think? Do you live somewhere where it snows frequently, and have you dealt with this yourself? Let us know.
Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.