Bold Claim That ‘Italian Food Is Just the Same Five Ingredients’ Causes Twitter Uproar

In an evocative parallel scene from a Sopranos episode entitled, "The Strong, Silent Type," mob boss Tony Soprano and his loyal associate Furio cook dinner for themselves, alone in their respective kitchens. The scene starts out with Tony walking into the kitchen of his New Jersey McMansion. He calls out his wife Carmella's name before finding a note on the counter that reads, "Rigatoni in the fridge." Meanwhile, Furio (a native Neapolitan), tends to sizzling pots and pans in a humid, dimly-lit kitchen. Bottles of olive oil and fresh herbs are visible in the background. Tony sticks some frozen rigatoni into the microwave and it lights up and whirs as he lets out a weary sigh. Furio carefully grates fresh parmesan over his steaming pasta and pours himself a glass of red wine. Tony pours himself a tall glass of milk and eats his meal straight out of the casserole dish at the kitchen counter. The intercut scene shows two Italians preparing pasta in very different ways—the American way, and the Italian way.

Often when Americans make bold assumptions and mocking jokes about Italian cuisine on the internet, they're referring to the Italian food of America, where pineapple on pizza is permitted and garlic bread served with spaghetti is the norm. It's no wonder people like @va_dickens believe that Italian food is just "the same five ingredients a thousand different ways." Most people are only exposed to their region's version of a certain type of cuisine. One brief peek into Marcella Hazan's culinary bible Essentials of Italian Cooking will blow the mind of anyone who thinks Italian food is mostly just spaghetti and tomatoes. Twitter is perhaps the best place to find strong opinions and lively discourse about both food and Italians. So it's no surprise that Twitter had a whole lot to say about @va_dickens' hot take on Italian cuisine.

@va_dickens drops a highly controversial take

via @va_dickens
Advertisement
People used memes to express their feelings

via @va_dickens

Often when someone makes a bold and highly controversial claim on Twitter, instead of jumping head-first into the discourse, many opt for memes.
via @va_dickens
via @va_dickens
Advertisement
via @va_dickens
Others replied with spicy comebacks

via @va_dickens

Was @va_dickens dissing Italian food, like, from Italy? Or was she talking about American Italian food? Culinary experts and neophytes alike jumped in to defend Italy's name. @dotmariusz replied, "Tell me you've never been to Italy without telling me you've never been to Italy." Others extended @va_dickens' roast to other kinds of cuisine.
via @va_dickens
Advertisement
via @va_dickens
via @va_dickens
via @va_dickens
Advertisement
via @va_dickens
via @va_dickens
via @va_dickens
Advertisement
Italians rise up

via @va_dickens

Actual Italians showed up in the replies with their pitchforks, calling out Americans for misspelling pecorino.
The thread was a learning experience for some

via @va_dickens
via @va_dickens
Advertisement
Some people argued about what those five ingredients are

via @va_dickens
via @va_dickens
Is Italy even real?

via @va_dickens