'UPDATE: My Parents went ballistic': Twin steals coveted baby name of dead friend, internet sides with them before things boil over

What do you do when your twin brother steals the name you planned to give to your future daughter? Especially when you promised your dying friend to honor her by doing so.

Reddit unexpectedly sided with the twin brother and his GF's decision to name their child "Amelia" which was the name this Redditor, u/AITAbabynames, planned to give their future daughter. The name had been that of a childhood friend of u/AITAbabynames who had passed away from cancer at the age of 12. u/AITAbabynames swore to their dying friend that they would name their future daughter after her.

Commenters largely voted u/AITAbabynames to be the AH and felt it was strange for u/AITAbabynames to gatekeep a name for a daughter that they may never have—but I don't agree. There are so many names available in the world it seems strange to me to pick the one that is meaningful to your sibling. If the GF had had her own reasons for the name (outside of "I like it"), then it might be reasonable, but otherwise, it seems strange for the twin brother to go along with it.

The Redditor went away to consider the verdict, deciding that some of the comments from readers had merit and deciding to follow their advice. They reached out to reconcile with their brother, which is when their parents fully realized what was happening and got involved.

It sounds like, at the moment, things are worse than they were initially—but at least u/AITAbabynames now has everyone else on their side.

Like what you see? Follow our WhatsApp channel for more.

Advertisement

Stay up to date by following us on Facebook!

Tags

Babies family drama amitheahole aita baby baby names brother siblings am-i-the-ahole family

Scroll Down For The Next Article

Also From FAIL Blog

'Who are the rudest customers you've met?': Service Industry Employees Share Their Most Nightmare Experiences with Extremely Entitled Customers at Work

'Who are the rudest customers you've met?': Service Industry Employees Share Their Most Nightmare Experiences with Extremely Entitled Customers at Work

Trending Now

New employee gets forgotten after boss is fired, collects paycheck with no work to do for months: 'I'm riding the wave till it crests'

New employee gets forgotten after boss is fired, collects paycheck with no work to do for months: 'I'm riding the wave till it crests'

'They’ve made it clear who their favorite child was, it's only fair he steps up': After always favoring her younger brother, 32-year-old neglected sister tells parents she won't look after them when they get older

'They’ve made it clear who their favorite child was, it's only fair he steps up': After always favoring her younger brother, 32-year-old neglected sister tells parents she won't look after them when they get older

'I deleted his name': Overachieving high school student removes partner's name on group project after he refused to do any work, partner gets a failing grade

'I deleted his name': Overachieving high school student removes partner's name on group project after he refused to do any work, partner gets a failing grade

UPDATE: 42-year-old boss tells 29-year-old employee that she's not being a team player after she solves escape room quickly: 'My boss is giving me the cold shoulder'

UPDATE: 42-year-old boss tells 29-year-old employee that she's not being a team player after she solves escape room quickly: 'My boss is giving me the cold shoulder'

Dad demands 16-year-old daughter replace 16-year-old stepbrother's expensive noise-cancelling headphones after she intentionally breaks them, wife and daughter think he's being unfair: 'I don’t think you get to break someone’s stuff and not pay for it'

Dad demands 16-year-old daughter replace 16-year-old stepbrother's expensive noise-cancelling headphones after she intentionally breaks them, wife and daughter think he's being unfair: 'I don’t think you get to break someone’s stuff and not pay for it'

Overworked employee working 75 hours a week gets criticized for not being efficient enough, leading employee to cut their work time in half: ‘This was my wake-up call’

Overworked employee working 75 hours a week gets criticized for not being efficient enough, leading employee to cut their work time in half: ‘This was my wake-up call’

Advertisement