'My brother yelled 'Gotcha!'': Christmas gets canceled when siblings play a diabolical prank on their sister after she celebrates buying her first home, she ends up going no contact because they crossed the line

Author image for Jesse Kessenheimer
Jesse Kessenheimer • Writer and Editor
Dec 22, 2024 9:00 AM EST

As if dropping $100k+ on your first downpayment isn't stressful enough, this prankster family decided to drop a mean-spirited prank on their sibling after they closed on a house. 

Becoming a first-time homeowner is stressful enough, but fanning the flames of your own family member's self-doubt is downright diabolical. If you've never purchased a home before, the idea of dropping tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars on a home can be enough to turn your stomach. Still, on top of that, there's no shortage of paperwork to leaf through, realtors to deal with, and a whole slew of housing market stressors that can make newbie buyers go crazy. So when the person in our next story finally finalized payment on their first house, they were so relieved they threw a celebration party with their closest family members. However, things quickly unraveled when their siblings decided to play a cruel prank, fabricating an authentic-looking loan denial letter… just to make their sister's stomach drop. 

Keep scrolling for the drama that might undo a merry Christmas for this family who crossed the line while pranking their sibling. 

Advertisement
  • 01
    Cheezburger Image 10444758528
    via fotostorm

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02
    AITA for cutting all contact with my family because of a prank? So I have posted a story on here before and I got some pretty good advice so please help. Here's what happened. I (27F)
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 03
    have always had a complicated relationship with my family. They've always been the type of people who think any joke is fine as long as someone laughs, no matter who gets hurt. Over the years, I've tried to brush it off and
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 04
    not let it bother me too much, but this time, they crossed a line I can't ignore. Recently, I achieved something big in my life: I bought my first home after saving for years. It's
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 05
    something I worked incredibly hard for sacrificing vacations, nights out, and basically anything extra to make it happen. I was beyond proud of myself and excited to finally have a place to call my own. Naturally, I wanted
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 06
    to share this milestone with my family, even though our relationship has always been rocky. A few weeks ago, we had a family dinner to celebrate my new home. Everything seemed fine at first, they congratulated me,
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 07
    asked about the house, and seemed genuinely happy for me. But halfway through the night, my brother (30M) and sister (25F) handed me an envelope. They said it was a "surprise" to help me with my house.
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 08
    I opened it, and inside was what looked like a legal notice stating that my house purchase had been canceled because of a "clerical error" and that it was now being sold to someone else.
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 09
    It even had an official looking letterhead, my name, and details about the house. I was in complete shock. Everyone around the table started laughing, and my brother yelled, "Gotcha!" Turns out, they
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 10
    had faked the letter and thought it would be hilarious to see my reaction. I burst into tears, which only made them laugh harder. They even recorded the whole thing on their phones to post on social media.
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 11
    When I finally managed to speak, I told them how cruel this was. Buying this house was the biggest thing I'd ever done, and they turned it into a joke at my expense. Their response? "You're so sensitive. It was just a prank. Lighten up!"
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 12
    I left the dinner early, completely heartbroken. A few days later, I decided I'd had enough. This wasn't the first time they'd pulled a "prank" like this. Over the years, they've humiliated me
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 13
    countless times once ruining a job interview outfit by "accidentally" spilling coffee on it, another time pretending to lose my dog just to see me panic. I cut off all contact. I didn't
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 14
    make a scene, I just stopped responding to messages, blocked them on social media, and declined invites to family events. Now, I'm getting guilt-tripping messages from extended
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 15
    family saying I'm being selfish and tearing the family apart. My mom even left me a voicemail crying about how much she misses me and begging me to come back.
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 16
    But I can't bring myself to forgive them. This prank felt like the final straw, and I don't see how I can trust them again. So, Reddit, AITA for cutting off my family over this prank?
    via Spiritual-Ad5091
  • 17
    Lvn-Nitemare-13 NTA - Most "pranks" are just an excuse for horrible people to buy others under the disguise of a joke. Ask yourself what do these people bring to your life? As someone who has cut off family I agree with your decision. It can be very liberating to cut out the toxicity.
    via Lvn-Nitemare-13
  • 18
    BestConfidence1560 You're rightfully upset because it wasn't a prank. It was bu ying. The "it was just a joke" bs is something every buy does to justify humiliating people.
    via BestConfidence1560
  • 19
    They thought it would be fun to upset you on your big night and then take videos of it and post it on social media? And your mother is crying that she misses you? No she had an opportunity there to rip them a new one about their behavior and about treating
    via BestConfidence1560
  • 20
    you with kindness and respect, and she thought it would be better to go along with the prank. You deserve better than this. I'm glad you finally decided to call an end to their bu ying.
    via BestConfidence1560
  • 21
    Don't let them or any extended family members Pressure you into doing anything you don't want to do. I'm sorry that they couldn't just be happy for you for your achievement. Congratulations on your new home.
    via BestConfidence1560

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

end of the year christmas family drama first time homebuyer dads festive holiday season lights famiies drama buy owner kids brother house siblings relatable homeowner decorations moms holiday parenting homebuyer dad prank story family tree sibling sister property stories parent mom home cousins holidays parents
Scroll Down For The Next Article