Teacher forbids 17-year-old from talking about the weather, she gives him detention for a week: 'I have to write an essay about why what I said was wrong'

Author image for Ben Weiss
Ben Weiss • Writer and Editor
Jan 21, 2025 2:00 PM EST

Who knew that talking about the weather would be such a controversial issue for this teacher? 

There are obviously various inappropriate forms of behavior that can lead students to get detention in school. Cutting class, breaking the rules, and not completing homework assignments are among the classic causes. However, this 17-year-old student, who had previously never had any issues with other educators at his school, got into hot water with his English teacher over the frequency with which he liked to discuss the weather. 

Keep scrolling below for the full story and for the funniest reactions!

Advertisement
  • 01
    A B C
    via Element5Digital

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • This student wanted to be a meteorologist, so naturally, he was unable to stop himself from talking about the weather with his friends during lunch. For some reason, though, this seemed to bother his English teacher so much that she forbade him from being able to talk about it again. What did the weather ever do to her?

  • 02
    I (17m) have always been fascinated by weather and I want to become a meteorologist some day. I often discuss my interests in weather and nature with my friends at lunch. For
    via classassignmentai123
  • 03
    some reason this seems to bother my English teacher because right after Christmas she told me that I'm not allowed to discuss anything weather related at school anymore. I was upset about it but whatever.
    via classassignmentai123

  • When the student decided to write about a tornado for a science project (in which they were allowed to choose their own topics), the English teacher caught wind of this, so to speak, and stepped in to shame the student for breaking her arbitrary rules.

  • 04
    Anyway, in science class, we have to write a research paper on a topic of our choosing and I decided to do a research paper on the 2021 Mayfield, Kentucky tornado. I asked my science. teacher and he approved the topic.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 05
    What I didn't know was that my science teacher asked the English teacher to help proofread everyone's papers.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 06
    So last Monday she called me out in English class and demanded to know why I broke her rules about discussing weather related topics? She told me she saw the paper I wrote. I told her it was an assignment for another teacher
    via classassignmentai123
  • 07
    in another class and she said she didn't care and that I had to serve detention for breaking her rules. I asked her why she even cared and she yelled at me not to argue with her. I
    via classassignmentai123
  • 08
    told her maybe she needs to mind her own business. I ended up getting detention for the rest of the week and a Saturday detention. The principal told me I have to write an essay about why what I said was wrong and that I have to apologize to the teacher.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 09
    I don't think I did anything wrong. She gave me detention because she didn't like the subject of a science paper I did for another teacher. To me, that's
    via classassignmentai123
  • 10
    literally none of her business and she's overstepping her bounds. My parents told me I shouldn't have told her to mind her own business. I was frustrated. I've had issues with her all year. I've never had issues like this with any other teacher. AITA here?
    via classassignmentai123
  • 11
    Cheezburger Image 10456333312
    via Unsplash + (Giulia Squillace)

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Several members of the online community shared their reactions and feelings about teachers who flex their muscles just to assert a false sense of authority for the heck of it. 

  • 12
    Remember-The-Arbiter NTA I'm not allowed to discuss anything weather related at school anymore spits drink what?? Schools should be encouraging children to take pride in and build a career out of their interests.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 13
    We've all had that kind of English teacher at some point, I'm afraid, and I'm sure they mean well but at the end of the day it's bad for your development for you to be prohibited from discussing your interests.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 14
    Geexx NTA. You may want to get your parents involved. It comes across like your English teacher has some very skewed views. Your parents may
    via classassignmentai123
  • 15
    need to speak to both her and the principal and ask exactly what the rule is, and why you're not allowed to discuss topics that you find interesting, at a place of learning, with the appropriate teacher.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 16
    [deleted] NTA your whole school is AH. I can't imagine being a principal hearing this story and giving a detention to the student not the teacher. are these people on. A student can't talk about weather? Can't have an interest in meteorology. I wish i could speak to that b.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 17
    Koko_Qalli NTA That's a teacher on a power trip alright, they are so harmful.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 18
    Jasmin Jaded • NTA - she can be bothered by your interests all she wants, but it's not like this is an inappropriate topic for school, and your science teacher approved your paper.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 19
    As for your assignment from the principal, you should say that it was wrong to away she needs to mind her own business because of any of the following: you should have asked nicely for her to mind
    via classassignmentai123
  • 20
    your business less; you should have told her the topic was approved by the teacher the paper was being written for; and you can say that the teachers need to be more transparent
    via classassignmentai123
  • 21
    about who they're handing their work off to because she's the only one you has a problem with your 100% school friendly topic, and had you known she'd be involved,
    via classassignmentai123
  • 22
    you could have pretended to care about something else for the paper. Basically, you were "wrong" because you've tried to respect her ignorant request when she's around, and you were tricked in to this.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 23
    As far as the apology, you're so sorry no one told you she'd be grading the papers, and you would have submitted a request to have someone else check for spelling errors to protect her delicate sensibilities from something as controversial as
    via classassignmentai123
  • 24
    meteorology, and you'll be sure to do what you can from now on to make sure she's not subjects to your intellectual development in something you're so passionate about.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 25
    I mean, maybe change the wording a bit, but that's as close to you doing something wrong as it gets, and even more of an apology than this is worth.
    via classassignmentai123
  • 26
    If your parents are involved in your schooling and reasonable to any degree, they should be involved in this. The paper to the principal should be signed by them as supporting your acknowledgement of "wrongdoing," and need to be there for the apology.
    via classassignmentai123

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

detention aita school students teacher high school entitled Terrible Teacher funny entitled people
Scroll Down For The Next Article