Hostess humiliates friend for not bringing a dish to the potluck despite giving approval over text: "She put me on blast in front of people for something I didn't even do wrong"

Author image for Ely Bulnes
Ely Bulnes • Writer and Editor
Apr 11, 2025 7:00 PM EDT

There was a point in my early twenties where I was either hosting or attending a potluck every single weekend. For a big group of young adults, it was a great way to socialize without spending too much money. It was also a great opportunity to share your favorite dishes. My go-to was always a big, herby couscous salad with tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, sliced cashews, and raisins. If I didn't have time to prepare my salad – even though it was really easy to make on purpose – I loved stopping by my favorite bakery to bring a dessert to share.

In our story today, a young woman gets the host's okay to not bring a dish to the potluck. However, she gets called out in front of everyone for showing up empty handed. While I agree with netizens' assessments that not bringing anything at all to a potluck is a bit of a faux pas, the host was totally out of line putting her on the spot like that! To form your own opinion, scroll down below.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01

    AITA for not bringing anything to my friend's potluck after she told me not to?

    Cheezburger Image 10492663808
    via Aghavni Shahinyan

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02
    One of my close friends hosted a dinner at her place last weekend. She called it a "potluck" and sent a group text saying we should each bring a little something, drinks, snacks, whatever. It wasn't
    via u/junebanan
  • 03
    anything fancy, just casual. I asked her what I should bring and mentioned I'd be coming straight from work and might be a little rushed. She replied that I didn't need to worry about it, she had plenty of food and just wanted me to come.
    via u/junebanan
  • 04
    Cheezburger Image 10492632320
    via Linda Hughes Photography

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 05
    So I didn't bring anything. I showed up, said hi to everyone, and honestly, the night was going fine. People brought stuff, a salad, some cupcakes, a couple bottles of wine. I was planning to just help clean up or do dishes since I didn't bring anything, and I figured she meant what she said.
    via u/junebanan
  • 06
    But later on, while people were complimenting the food, she made this offhand comment like, "Well, not everyone contributed... but we're still glad she showed up." Everyone laughed, and it didn't seem super serious, but I felt my face get hot. I didn't know how to respond.
    via u/junebanan
  • 07
    I stayed polite and tried not to act weird about it, but I felt uncomfortable the rest of the night. On the way home, I kept thinking about it. I get that maybe she was a little annoyed, but she literally told me not to bring anything. And now I feel like she put me on blast in front of people for something I didn't even do wrong.
    via u/junebanan
  • 08
    Cheezburger Image 10492632576
    via corelens

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 09
    I haven't said anything to her yet because it feels small and I don't want to be dramatic, but I also can't shake the feeling that it wasn't fair.
    via u/junebanan
  • 10
    asmah57 Yeah, NTA. That was quite r de of the hostess. If this is someone you value, I'd recommend bringing it up casually. Ask if perhaps there was a misunderstanding bc you thought she said to come anyway. (From your description it doesn't sound like a mistake.) Chances are they will get defensive, but at least you attempted to clear the air.
    via u/asmah57
  • 11
    If you take a couple days and it doesn't bother you as much, you can decide to not bring it up to the hostess. The good thing is that you now have more information. You now know that you can't trust them
    via u/asmah57
  • 12
    to be honest in situations like that. (Imo, it is unreasonable to expect people to read your mind when you tell them the opposite of what you really want. Like requesting no gifts for a birthday, then pouting.)
    via u/asmah57

  • I've known people to react badly after receiving no gifts on their birthday after telling everyone not to get them anything. Just be honest! Then when others earnestly plead for nothing on their birthday because they already own too many things, they still end up with a mini-haul of extra junk they specifically didn't ask for.

  • 13
    junebanan OP Yup that's what i be been thinking. She did tell me not to bring anything, and then kinda made me look bad. Its hard to know if it was a misunderstanding or she just changed her mind and didn't say anything. I might not confront her directly but I def clocked the way she handled it.
    via u/junebanan
  • 14
    Excellent-Shape-2024 Back in the dark ages, when I was a kid, it was just known that you don't show up at anyone's house without a little something. A few chocolates, or a box of strawberries, or a bottle of wine. Seriously,
    via u/Excellent-Shape-2024
  • 15
    OP could have brought any of these things to work with her and then to host's house with minimal effort. It is a bit presumptive to think everyone but her should contribute. I get that host said "you don't have to bring anything" - let me translate that..."You don't need to go to the trouble of making a pot roast or a casserole dish".
    via u/Excellent-Shape-2024
  • 16
    Seriously--OP could have even bought a bag of ready made salad and whipped it together at host's house. Now you know. Always.bring.something. I don't think she's ta, I just think few people have basic good manners or |
    via u/Excellent-Shape-2024
  • 17
    social skills any more. Including the host, who should have never made that comment to OP, and especially should never disrespect a guest and in front of all the other guests. ESH.
    via u/Excellent-Shape-2024
  • 18
    ThePurplestMeerkat If the host expected OP to bring something, then the host should not have said the exact opposite. If someone's words cannot be taken at face value, then their words are worthless and they are not trustworthy.
    via u/ThePurplestMeerkat
  • 19
    AMissKathy Newman NTA, HOWEVER I feel like your text to her may have been a bit manipulative. The whole 'I'll be rushed I'm coming from work' was really irrelevant and wouldn't. have stopped you buying a bottle of wine, leaving it in the car and then contributing to the pot luck. It could have easily come across as you trying to get out of contributing.
    via u/AMissKathyNewman
  • 20
    It would have been so simple to say nothing and just bring something non perishable. In future just do this. It may be worth also looking over your messages to see if they could be interpreted as you trying to get out of contributing.
    via u/AMissKathyNewman
  • 21
    In saying all that, if she has told you not to bring anything then she can't turn around and have an issue with it, hence the NTA.
    via u/AMissKathyNewman

  • It's pretty clear that our protagonist isn't well-versed in potlucking rules. However, if the host was going to act so catty about it, she could have said something like: “Hey, it's okay if you don't cook. Can you manage to bring some cookies or a drink?” Seriously, people can communicate like adults instead of acting passive-aggressive. 

  • 22
    TinyNiceWolf Agreed. The host may have thought "OP is trying to get out of bringing anything, by saying they'll be rushed." The host then graciously said OP didn't have to worry about it, but resented OP and very ungraciously complained at the party. The host was out of line for that. NTA.
    via u/TinyNiceWolf
  • 23
    But perhaps the situation could have been avoided if OP had replied to "You don't need to worry about it" with "No, I want to bring something, what can I bring that I can buy the previous day?" or "Well then I owe you guys, so put me down for two dishes at the next potluck". That makes it more explicit that OP isn't trying to get something for nothing by violating potluck rules.
    via u/TinyNiceWolf
  • 24
    zmartinez20 ESH in my opinion. Common sense is important. What was she supposed to say? "If you can't bring anything don't come?" You don't show up empty handed. You would've been a couple minutes late and felt a lot better about eating what everyone else brought. If it were an expensive dinner everyone paid for and you ate free, you'd feel differently. But I
    via u/zmartinez20
  • 25
    Cheezburger Image 10492632832
    via Gustavo Fring

    This image is for illustration only, and the subjects are models; the image does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 26
    think you would've been spared the embarrassment if she had said just to not come, or if she didn't make that comment in front of everyone. Definitely went out of her way to humiliate you, but it was either do it in front of you or talk behind your back. Both AHs but I don't think you had any actual bad intentions, just need some lessons on social norms maybe.
    via u/zmartinez20
  • 27
    DolphinDarko That was passive aggressive of your friend and unnecessary. However, use this as lesson in good manners. Never show up empty handed. You could have gone to the grocery store the night before, the morning before work or on the way to her home. A bottle of wine or some cookies, it's not that hard.
    via u/DolphinDarko
  • 28
    KateNotEdwina Always take something to a potluck. Even if it's soft drink or a bottle of wine. Saying that she was r de calling you out like that.
    via u/KateNotEdwina
  • 29
    justforfun75 YTA. What was your friend supposed to say to you when you basically forced her to approve your selfishness. It's a potluck. You have to bring something. Don't have to time to pick something up after work? Plan ahead and buy something nonperishable ahead of time and bring it with you to work. It's really not that hard. Yeah, YTA.
    via u/justforfun75
  • 30
    cute_puur NTA. You have asked her and she told you not to and made fun of you not bring anything. That's a red flag in friendship.
    via u/cute_puur

Tags

womanhood friendship besties AITAH toxic adulting relationships parenting potluck love adulthood red flag dating entitled people
Scroll Down For The Next Article