‘I ain't leavin'’: Tenant files a lawsuit against their landlord after she tries to wrongfully evict them and their service dog, then sends the documents to the landlord's neglected PO box so she fails to show up to court

Author image for Lana DeGaetano
Lana DeGaetano • "Show me to me please."
Sep 8, 2025 4:00 PM EDT

You'd think a landlord would know by now that tenants will always find a way. The tenant in this next story files two lawsuits against their landlord after they try to wrongfully evict her based on having a service dog, or any other "issue" under the sun. So, the tenant decides to send important court documents and other information to their landlord's PO box. This PO box, however, is apparently heavily neglected, so the landlord never receives the mail… Oh no! Or not…

Landlords are in a position of ultimate power: They own the building you live in, and call the shots on what you're allowed to do with it. There are certain protections that landlords cannot overstep, or they risk a lawsuit that might cost them thousands to millions of dollars in cash. Tenants' rights are heavily protected because we are put in a vulnerable position as renters. If a landlord wanted us out at the drop of a hat, most protections would prevent them from doing so. That's why the tenant here is in the right, and likely didn't even need to seek petty plans to make their landlord out to be negligent… because the landlord clearly already does that easily enough themselves.

Advertisement
  • 300 SOMAR "She hates me because I have a service dog."
    via Andy Luo for Unsplash

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • "Landlord [messed] around, now she found out. Guess who missed our court date :)"

    SK Canada. My landlord has been a massive dingdong since I moved in, she hates me because I have a service dog.
    via heavyh**o
  • And she's been trying to make up reasons to evict me for months now. So I've filed both a human rights and a landlord court complaint (we have awesome legal channels in Canada that are effectively free and require no lawyers, provincial tribunals).
    via heavyh**o
  • Malicious compliance me kicks in, I'm ready to be petty. I'm allowed to send her documents via mail.
    via heavyh**o
  • She didn't give me her home address on the lease, that's fine. She gave me a PO Box. So I mailed the hearing notice and all my evidence to her PO Box.
    via heavyh**o
  • But oh nooo, the package | printed out was so thick that it had no chance of fitting in her PO Box.
    via heavyh**o
  • So Canada Post won't forward it to her home address. So I mailed everything to her PO Box. And the pickup slip has been in there for the past week.
    via heavyh**o
  • Her post office of choice is only open during business hours. Which is what she works. So she had no clue to go check her PO box.
    via heavyh**o
  • Despite me telling her over and over that a court date was coming up. I even sent her evidence files 23 through 28, and a document list titled "part 2".
    via heavyh**o
  • Told her to let me know if she was missing anything. She hates me, so she didn't respond.
    via heavyh**o
  • If only she paid any amount of attention, or treated me with a drop of civility... womp womp for her :).
    via heavyh**o
  • Well our appointment was this morning. She uploaded no evidence. She didn't call the court to provide her contact info.
    via heavyh**o
  • And she ignored the phone call from the court when our slot came up. Who even answers "private number" if they're not expecting it? :)
    via heavyh**o
  • The hearing was ultimately adjourned because I'm asking quite a bit of money, and a ton of things to be repaired around the house.
    via heavyh**o
  • lawyer judge in a suit with documents and a gavel on the table
    via Getty Images For Unsplash+

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • I may have gone looking for a few extra things. If I'm taking her to court, may as well knock it out all at once right?.
    via heavyh**o
  • She now she looks insanely negligent for missing our court date, which is a huge backbone of my case against her.
    via heavyh**o
  • I have to wait a couple extra weeks for a new date, but hey the time slot was extended by over an hour so I get even more time to rake her over the coals.
    via heavyh**o
  • I offered her a settlement months back, asking for an apology and $380 for out of pocket expenses.
    via heavyh**o
  • Now my legal ask is going to cost her at least $10k just in awards to me. And then possibly 10s of thousands of dollars to do necessary repairs on the attic and foundation...
    via heavyh**o
  • Shouldn't have talked smack about my dis ility and service dog. She's priced this full house and yard like 30% under market rate (but she somehow doesn't know that).
    via heavyh**o
  • I aint leavin.
    via heavyh**o

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

bad landlords reddit stories landlord entitled parents malicious compliance landlords reddit story service dog service dogs entitled people karma bad landlord entitled reddit thread Reddit entitled people
Scroll Down For The Next Article