Female roommate, Kelly, gets served eviction papers by allergic homeowner after she sneakily adopts German Shepherd from shelter despite living in a "no pets allowed" condo: 'This wasn't a surprise rule I made up'

Author image for Blake Seidel
Blake Seidel • Managing Editor & Brand Manager
Nov 19, 2025 9:00 AM EST

Some people aren't dog people, and we feel bad that they'll never experience the love of a doggo, but that's their right. Some people dislike their fur getting everywhere, others are allergic, and still others consider it too high-maintenance. It's hard to convince a non-dog person to become a dog lover, and it certainly didn't work for this entitled roommate who thought she could convince her horribly allergic landlord and roommate to accept the dog she adopted on a whim, despite knowing that no pets are allowed in their condo. 

She came home one day with an untrained German Shepherd that she bonded with at a shelter, and just hoped for the best. Her friend and owner of the condo she lives in tried to be accommodating. She gave her a lot more leniency than we would have in her position. She waited patiently while the doggo barked all day, tore up some of her shoes, and scratched up her wood floors. She's also taking Benadryl daily in order to deal with the dog's hair. If you've ever taken Benadryl before, you know how sleepy it makes you, so it's a wonder she's able to get anything done at all. 

But at this point, she's had enough, and it's time to tell her to get rid of the pup or move out. Kelly called her cruel; we call it fair.

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to start your Caturday with the funniest felines on the internet!

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01

    How do I tell my roommate she needs to move out after she adopted a dog without asking me?

    Eviction notice with DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING EVICTION 'She'll be held responsible for any further damage to [my] home.' VACATE WILL RESULT IN LE OLDINGS, ATTORNEY FEES AND PENALTY DAMAGES. STS, Section 1752 Civil Code
    via Michael Burrell

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02
    I (26F) own a condo in Phoenix. My roommate "Kelly" (28F) has been renting a room from me for about two years.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 03
    Things have been mostly fine until last month. Kelly has been talking about wanting a dog for a while.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 04
    I told her multiple times that I'm not comfortable with a dog in my condo. I have severe allergies to pet dander and I also travel for work frequently.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 05
    I was clear from the beginning that no pets were allowed. Three weeks ago I came home from a work trip and there was a dog in my living room.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528

  • It's not just disrespectful, it's outrageous. If the condo owner simply didn't like dogs, that would be one thing (still not okay), but she's allergic to dogs. You can't ignore allergies. If she's anything like we are during the first month of Spring, her life with the dog must be unbearable.

  • 06
    A full grown German Shepherd. Kelly said she "fell in love" with him at a rescue event and adopted him on the spot.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 07
    German Shepherd dog
    via Marcin Jucha

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 08
    She said she thought I'd "come around" once I met him. I immediately told her this wasn't okay and she needed to return the dog or rehome him.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 09
    She said she already paid the adoption fee and did all the paperwork, and that it would be "cruel" to give him back.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 10
    She promised she'd keep him in her room and I'd barely notice. That lasted two days.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 11
    The dog has full run of the condo. He's destroyed two pairs of my shoes, scratched up my hardwood floors, and barks constantly when Kelly's at work.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 12
    Border collie destroying furniture
    via pixelshot

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 13
    My allergies have been terrible - I'm taking Benadryl daily just to function. I've asked her repeatedly to find somewhere else for the dog.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528

  • We can barely function when we take Benadryl. Maybe it's different for different people, but we can't focus, and we are so sleepy. Like, can't keep our eyes open, sleepy. How can she work or accomplish anything when she's taking that every day?

  • 14
    She keeps saying she's "working on it" but nothing changes. Yesterday I found out she's been posting on social media about "her dog" and her apartment, acting like she owns the place.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 15
    I told her last night that if the dog isn't gone in two weeks, she needs to move out.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 16
    She burst into tears and said I'm being heartless, that she's already bonded with the dog and can't give him up.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 17
    She said she can't afford to move out right now and I'm basically making her choose between her "baby" and having a place to live.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 18
    Now she's turned some of our mutual friends against me saying I'm trying to make her homeless over a dog.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 19
    But this is MY condo that I own. She violated a clear rule and now she's acting like I'm the bad guy.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 20
    How do I actually get her to move out? Do I need to do a formal eviction?
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 21
    I've never dealt with this before and I don't want to be cruel but I also can't live like this.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 22
    Odd-Occasion-3528 What makes this worse is she keeps guilt-tripping me about the dog. Saying things like "He was in a shelter, he deserves a home" and "I saved his life, I can't just abandon him."
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 23
    I feel terrible but also I TOLD her no pets before she even moved in. This wasn't a surprise rule I made up. She agreed to it and then completely ignored it.
    via Odd-Occasion-3528
  • 24
    BigConfidence1563 This is how you tell her: You hand her notice of eviction or whatever that is in country you live in and let her know that she has x amount of time to either rehome the dog or she is getting evicted.
    via BigConfidence1563
  • 25
    Will any of them chip in to fix the damages? No? Did they pay for your condo? No? Right, so they can all take the off and preferably dog with them. You don't need friends that are so keen on virtue signaling when it's not their property and financial burden.
    via BigConfidence1563
  • 26
    and would find I would be out which adoption centre she got him from and let them know she adopted while her landlord (you) have not agreed to it and are asking for the dog to be removed from her because she lied. As far as I am aware most ponds/shelters will check prior for you getting pet if you can actually have it.
    via BigConfidence1563
  • 27
    Edit to add: I would find the post with dog and apartment and make very clear comment saying that she ain't owning sh* because it's your house and you have not agreed to a dog and you remind her that she has to rehome the dog or she is being evicted.
    via BigConfidence1563
  • 28
    Brilliant Jaded8402 I would let the shelter know that she didn't have her landlords permission before adopting the dog. The ones by me will take the dog back because checking with your landlord if you have one is part of the adoption agreement. Not doing so can actually have you banned from adopting from them again.
    via BrilliantJaded8402
  • 29
    Quick-Possession-245 Just give her an eviction notice. Ignore the guilt trips. She KNEW that dogs were not okay. Evict her on the basis of a lease violation. Check the state laws. In many cases, if the owner lives in the house the laws lean more toward the owner than if you are a commercial landlord.
    via Quick-Possession-245
  • 30
    Evict her and demand court costs. I am really pro-tenant. But she went over the top here. She is making you miserable and unwell in your own home and taking no ownership of the situation. You screwed up by not taking action right away, but stop giving her time.
    via Quick-Possession-245
  • 31
    Beneficial-Sort4795 My roommate/cousin showed up from a visit with her (shitty useless) parents with a kitten. She was broke, allergic and ignoring the lease we both signed that said 'no pets'. Even without all that, I've never
    via Beneficial-Sort4795
  • 32
    wanted a live in cat. I looked at her moron father and told him to take the kitten right on back to his car. There was a signed lease and I wasn't getting kicked out of my home because he was too stupid to check with the actual person paying the rent and gave
    via Beneficial-Sort4795
  • 33
    her a kitten she couldn't even afford. My cousin cried and locked herself in the bathroom for hours. I could give a damn. I sent him off with the kitten and told him don't ever try to make rules in my house again.
    via Beneficial-Sort4795
  • 34
    You need to ignore the guilting and crying and foolishness and hold firm. She violated the lease and her and the dog need to go for the lying and guilt trip alone. I don't know what lie she told but you typically need to say you own the home before you can
    via Beneficial-Sort4795
  • 35
    adopt a pet without them checking with your landlord on a rental. Get ahold of the adoption place and they'll likely repo the dog cause of her lie. Assuming she didn't lie and get him from someone she knows.
    via Beneficial-Sort4795
  • 36
    Tell her she can go willingly now or you can formally evict her and that will stay on her record. And you won't have anything nice to say as a reference for a new place. She violated the lease and she's out, end of story. And she'll be held responsible for any further damage to your home. Take pictures, keep receipts.
    via Beneficial-Sort4795
  • 37
    The mutual friends- tell them you're glad they're onboard and you'll let Kelly know she's free to move in with them and take Cujo with her. They'll enjoy his taste in shoes. Bet they real quick when their expensive shit is on the line.
    via Beneficial-Sort4795

Check out our Instagram for more hilarious animal content!

Love our stuff? Shop for some of our pawsome merch here.

Tags

rules dogs german shepherd allergic homeowner sneaky surprise eviction roommates animals no pets
Scroll Down For The Next Article