Husband debates whether or not to confront wife after she keeps sending food back to the kitchen every time they go out to dinner: '[The] fries weren't as crispy as normal!'

Author image for Ben Weiss
Ben Weiss • Writer and Editor
Dec 17, 2025 2:00 PM EST

Picky eaters think they have it rough, but let's not forget what it's like to for the people in their lives.

As a former picky eater myself, I understand the absolute turmoil I put my family and friends through for the first two decades of my life, especially when it came to finding restaurants with menu items that I could enjoy. However, becoming an adult meant not just expanding my horizons in terms of the food I would consume, but it also meant ensuring that the person carrying the burden of what I wanted or didn't want to eat would have to be me and only me.

This long-suffering spouse had to deal with his wife's continual lack of satisfaction with the food that she would order at restaurants. No, this had nothing to do with dietary restrictions, nor was it a "one time" occurrence in which the food that was served was justifiably undercooked or overcooked. This lady had developed an unfortunate habit of sending items back to the kitchen time and time again, and it was only getting worse. For the record, I do feel the need to disclose the face that even in the heights of my picky eating days, I never sent food back. I just didn't eat what I didn't want. 

As for this man's debacle, it was only a matter of time before he needed to speak out. Good luck to him because it doesn't sound like his spouse is particularly amenable to criticism.

Advertisement

  • "[Would I be wrong] if I asked my wife to stop sending food back so often at restaurants?"

    It seems like between 1/4-1/3 of the time we go somewhere, she sends something back to be remade. In her defense, she is never rude about it and always both thankful and grateful to the staff. Now don't get me wrong, I'll
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • send something back if it's burnt or wrong, but I feel like most of the times she sends it back for things that I personally wouldn't and I'm forced to either wait for my food to get cold or eat alone
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • then wait for her to eat. Here's a few examples of reasons she's asked for her food to be remade in recent memory.
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • 1. Hamburger wasn't seasoned enough. 2. Fries weren't as crispy as normal 3. Less sauce on her pasta than normal. 4. Not enough cheese on her cheesesteak.
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • In my mind, I don't expect food at a restaurant to be perfect every time. I honestly wouldn't care about her doing this if it wasn't happening as frequently as it is.
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • At the same time, I want her to be able to enjoy our night outs. WIBTA if I gently brought it up? Edit: Whoa I didn't expect my wife's picky eating to blow up this much. Just for some clarification,
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • no I don't think this is some kind of power trip or her being a Karen. It just really bothers her for some reason when her food doesn't come out the way she expected. This plus a few other things I've noticed in our years
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • together make me think she is slightly on the spectrum, but I know better than to ever say that to her. I'll try and gently bring it up sometime and maybe offer some alternative solutions. Thank you all.
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • A man and a woman sit at an outdoor dinner table.
    via Unsplash+ (Kateryna Hliznitsova)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • WestStrength2719 NTA - My mom does this and it can be embarrassing at times.
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • butterflya82 NTA. My ex bf did this a lot over small things. I ended up just eating my dinner as why should I eat cold food
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • NowaGAgirl NTA but your wife should perhaps order fries crispy or ask for extra sauce on the side or mention that she likes her pasta saucy. If she is vocal when ordering things like this won't happen as often. Also, salt and pepper from the table will remedy the burger issue
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • writing_mm_romance I waited tables in college at a steakhouse. My brother used to come in a couple times a month and each time he'd send his prime rib back. I finally told him that I wouldn't allow him to be seated in my section anymore because of it, it was that ridiculous. Another time at the same restaurant I had a customer send their prime rib back 3 times, and the chef finally cut a new piece of prime rip and placed in a to-go container with fresh sides, then filled two soup cups with au ju
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • Sparklingwine23 NTA, if she's that picky she should make her expectations known upfront so the kitchen can know if they can accommodate her requests. Also, asking for more sauce just means getting a side of it, she doesn't need to send her whole meal back. If this is a common problem I'd stop eating out with her. I eat out regularly in my very busy home city and all over the world and have legit sent food back maybe twice?
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • Mammoth_Bed3182 In 3 out of the 4 examples listed, she could just get them to make her some fresh fries, bring her some extra pasta sauce, or bring her some extra cheese for her cheesesteak. None of these things should take long or prevent her from eating some of her food so that you don't have to wait. Also, they seem like VERY picky reasons to send food back. Regardless of whether or not she is being polite. I would ask her if she would throw out and remake entire dishes at home for these mini
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • JustASquirrelyGirl As a former server (quit a few months ago, so recently), NTA. Your wife is annoying and nitpicky and trust me, if you frequent these restaurants, the employees talk shit about you guys and servers likely argue over who is taking your table. Even if you aren't a regular, the servers are shit talking you with the kitchen. She doesn't need to send any of this back and the fact that she is is incredibly wasteful and annoying huge waste of everyone's time. Saw your comment about ho
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • No_Break_6660 I'm 49 years old. I've maybe sent food back once in 25 years of eating out. Your wife sounds difficult or is very bad at communicating expectations. I would 100% have a conversation with her.
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • lady_sisyphus Teach her the word "extra", and to use it WHILE ordering. Extra cheese, extra sauce, extra seasoning, extra crispy. I prefer all of those things as well, which is why I ask for them when ordering. Extra is never the default.
    via Reptaaaaaaar
  • Extra-Government551 -Hamburger wasn't seasoned enough. I guarantee the waiter was like "bitch, there's a salt and pepper shaker right there on the table." NTA. Edited for clarity.
    via Reptaaaaaaar

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

aita marriage restaurant husband couples dinner kitchen picky eater
Scroll Down For The Next Article