Regular customer demands retail worker stop smiling and drop her cheerful customer service act, she complies, leaving the customer to deal with the uncomfortable reality of her request: '[I] would stop even smiling as she'd approach the counter'

Author image for Brad Dickson
Brad Dickson • Managing Editor
Jan 2, 2026 12:00 PM EST

It has often been said that there's no pleasing everyone, and that attempting to do so is a futile effort. However, when you're expected to please people as part of your job, you're almost caught up in an expectation of doing what is impossible.

And that is customer service, retail, and food service in a nutshell. These industries have high rates of burnout, owing to the fact that they almost require you to fracture your personality in order to meet expectations. And expectations are high, even being a manager doesn't save you from the need to feign hollow sincerity at any given moment. With many retailers adopting review systems where an 8-10 out of 10 is the only acceptable score, and anything less ensures that you're going to be hearing from upper management, asking questions as to why you weren't able to push the customer "over the line." 

There's a reason why so many large companies famous for their customer service rely on forced smiles and canned appeasement that explicitly avoids anything beyond surface level. It's all about playing to percentages and remaining as inoffensive as possible, seeming friendly without opening the interaction up for chances for things to go sideways. And when you think a customer is a "real one" and gets it, there's still a chance that they might turn around and fly off the handle about something or claim to take offence at the same witty banter.

All of this expectation can be exceedingly difficult in the mornings, when you're still bleary-eyed and fighting off a fitful sleep. It's no small task when you find yourself needing to be cheery in the mornings when you're not a morning person to start with. In any other situation, you might be excused for being a little blunt or even standoffish, but when you're in a customer service role, you hardly get that chance, as one blunt interaction can spiral out and become a big deal. 

But, after all of that, there are customers like this one who actually take offense to being greeted cheerfully and go as far as demanding that the cheerful act of banter be dropped entirely. This retail worker was all too happy to comply with this demand, turning instead to a natural, cold, and lifeless demeanor any time that customer, who was a regular, was around. This left the customer increasingly uncomfortable, and while they probably could have complained further and made a big deal about all of it, they accepted that their demand had resulted in their present reality. Definitely an important lesson to be learned in here somewhere.

Advertisement
  • Shopper smiles and grocery store worker as he hands her a potato
    via Getty Images For Unsplash+

    The image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • "Be careful what you ask for, you just might get it."

    I used to be a retail manager at a convenience store and as such, I (NOT a morning person) would have to be at work at 5am. Knowing how I myself felt about having to be awake at that hour, I would do my best to be cheerful and make my customers smile by lightly joking a bit and telling them to have a wonderful day as we finished our transactions.
    via Shadva
  • One morning, one of our regulars came in, and I greeted her brightly as she approached the counter. She snarled at me that she hated my cheerful demeanor and that I always told her to have a wonderful day
    via Shadva
  • then demanded that I NEVER so much as smile at her again. I apologized for my cheerfulness and told her that I would immediately, and permanently, comply with her wishes. I proceeded to do exactly that.
    via Shadva
  • From that day forward, I'd treat other customers in my normal, cheerful way, but as she'd approach the counter, I'd stop smiling and bantering and drop into my natural Resting Bitch Face. I would complete our transaction, then cheerfully turn to the next person in line and continue my banter.
    via Shadva
  • After about a month of this, the woman came back in at her normal time and complained about how much she hated that I wouldn't banter with her like I did the other customers and how miserable it left her feeling all day. I reminded her of her
    via Shadva
  • previous demands and that she was getting exactly what she'd demanded. I also reminded her that I'd said that my lack of banter with her would be permanent.
    via Shadva
  • She continued to come in every morning at her usual time and I continued to banter with the other customers, but would stop even smiling as she'd approach the counter, then turn to the next person in line and continue the banter. She continued to look miserable.
    via Shadva
  • Had she simply asked me to tone it down a bit, or said she just wasn't in the mood for banter that day, I would've adjusted accordingly. Instead, she got exactly what she asked for.
    via Shadva
  • Melodic_Turnover_877 That sounds just like a woman that I work with. She got pissed off at me for being friendly and talking to her, so I stopped talking to her. Then she got pissed off at me for not being friendly and not talking to her. Sorry, but you can't have it both ways.
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva There's always one that just refuses to be anything other than miserable.
    via Shadva
  • [deleted] An excellent serving of MC.
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva Thank you :)
    via Shadva
  • r00k42 Customers with personality are my favorite. It gives me something to work with. The average Midwest Nice customer is a smooth and pleasant transaction, and these are most of my interactions. But the unhappy ones can usually be won over by going the extra mile in service or taking time to show them you care, giving them a little extra attention. The more skeptical ones will be a "customer for life" when they realize you care. Sure, there are a few bad apples that expect you to do it all fo
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva The customers like your last description I would usually laugh out loud at simply because that was the response they wanted when they did it. It was meant as a joke and I'd take it as such. The few that seemed to mean it in a nasty fashion would get a slightly different treatment. Their "Hey BITCH! What's a guy gotta do to get service around here?" would be greeted with, "Thanks for using my title, but if you're gonna act like that, it's QUEEN Bitch to you! Go back out and try again."
    via Shadva
  • ShadowDragon8685 Damn. Karen dropped a fucking bunker-buster on that bridge, didn't she?
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva Like I said, be careful what you with for, you may not like it. lol
    via Shadva
  • sciteach2030 I decided to distance myself from the perpetual grumps. I know we all need to vent sometimes but Jesus it was every damned day! I am a lot happier at work and I only hear their nastiest from time to time. I love that you put that customer in her place, usually when you are in customer service you can't do that! I applaud you for a job well done!
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva When I interviewed for the position, I told the owner that no one was perfect, including him as my potential boss, myself or customers and that the outdated adage about the customer always being right was pure bullshit. He agreed and hired me on the spot. I worked for him, at both of his stores until I was assaulted in my home and my lower back was shattered. I still miss working with and for him.
    via Shadva
  • Ninja_Flower_Lady Gosh, what did she say after you explained? Did she say please go back to the way it was?
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva Actually, no. She never said anything of the sort after I reminded her of the previous conversation. She neither apologized for her previous behavior nor asked again for me to begin treating her like everyone else.
    via Shadva
  • Marcultist Oh boy, based on this comment section, I'm about to deliver an unpopular opinion. I'm not saying that customer should be rewarded for her poor behavior, or that it's ever okay to treat an employee so harshly, but OP is basically punishing this customer forever because one day she had a bad morning that was misdirected onto them. Unless there are more details OP left out, it was a one-time mistake that didn't ruin any lives; so the punishment (while certainly a quality MC) is probably
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva Your response is valid. I can definitely deal with someone with an occasional case of the grumps, usually by toning things down, asking if they're having a bad day and saying that I hope it gets better for them. Normally I would've just taken it as a bad day for her and let it slide but this woman was ALWAYS rude and condescending, even with other customers. Enough was enough.
    via Shadva
  • sciteach2030 Omgosh. I am so sorry you had to go through that. Sending big hugs
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva Thank you. It was many years ago and I'm doing fine :)
    via Shadva
  • Kansas Brewista Maybe it's just me, but aren't you carrying this a tad too far? Is there grace at all in your heart?
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva As I mentioned in another comment, this was more than 20 years ago. Also, as I mentioned in yet another comment, that particular woman was always rude and condescending. In either case, I have no regrets.
    via Shadva
  • fingers She recognized her mistake. Asked to go back to normal. You chose not to. You look petty in this situation. Go back to being your usual self with her. You don't know what was going on in her life a few months ago. She's looking for kindness now. You don't have to be miserable with her.
    via Shadva
  • OP Shadva I just stopped being cheerful, I remained polite. This was also 20+ years ago, so any time for regret, on either side is well past.
    via Shadva

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

workplace discussion employment issues antiwork jobs employees Horrible Bosses workplace story employment
Scroll Down For The Next Article