22-year-old student refuses to lend laptop to careless roommate who previously broke it and didn’t fully pay for repairs, stands his ground: ‘I’m not comfortable risking it again’

Author image for Cata Holmes
Cata Holmes • Writer
Apr 15, 2026 4:00 PM EDT

A 22-year-old student finds himself in a tense situation with his roommate after refusing to lend out his laptop. The conflict stems from a previous incident where the roommate damaged it and did not fully cover the repair costs. Now, a simple request has turned into an ongoing disagreement about trust and boundaries.

Sharing a living space often requires a balance between cooperation and personal boundaries. While it is common to lend items to roommates, there is an unspoken expectation of responsibility and respect. When that trust is broken, even unintentionally, it can shift the dynamic, making future requests feel less like favors and more like potential risks.

Financial responsibility also plays a major role in these situations. Replacing or repairing expensive items can be stressful, especially when the burden is not equally shared. Even if the damage was accidental, the lingering impact remains. This can create hesitation and reinforce the need to protect personal belongings more carefully moving forward.

Ultimately, situations like this highlight how important clear communication and accountability are in shared living environments. Setting boundaries is not necessarily about holding grudges, but about learning from past experiences. Navigating these conflicts respectfully can help maintain the relationship, while still allowing individuals to feel secure about their own space and possessions.

Advertisement
  • Laptop on modern desk workspace displaying code, representing study, work, and personal property
    via Unsplash+ (via Christopher Gower)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    Laptop on modern desk workspace displaying code, representing study, work, and personal property

  • So I (22M) live with my roommate (23M), “Jake.” We've been living together for about a year, and overall it's been fine, until recently.
    via NoBat5123
  • About three months ago, Jake asked to borrow my laptop for a “quick assignment.” I was hesitant because it's pretty expensive and I need it for school, but he promised to be careful. Long story short, he spilled coffee on it. He apologized a lot, said it was an accident, and promised he'd help pay for repairs.
    via NoBat5123
  • The repairs ended up costing a lot, and while he did chip in a little, I still paid the majority of it. It was frustrating, but I let it go because I figured accidents happen.
    via NoBat5123
  • Fast forward to this week: Jake comes to me again asking to borrow my (newly repaired) laptop because his isn't working. I told him no. I tried to be polite about it, but I basically said I wasn't comfortable lending it out again after what happened last time.
    via NoBat5123
  • He got pretty annoyed and said I was being “petty” and “holding a grudge over an accident." Now things are kind of tense in the apartment. He's been making passive-aggressive comments like "must be nice to not trust your friends."
    via NoBat5123
  • I get that accidents happen, but I also feel like I have a right to protect my stuff, especially since I already took the financial hit once.
    via NoBat5123
  • Some of our mutual friends are split. A couple think I'm being reasonable, but others say I should "give him another chance" since he didn't mean to break it the first time.
    via NoBat5123
  • So... AITJ for refusing to lend him my laptop again?
    via NoBat5123

  • Many readers sided with him, pointing out that setting boundaries after a costly mistake is not petty, it is practical. The comments quickly filled with people sharing similar experiences and emphasizing the importance of accountability in shared living situations. For many, trust is not just about intentions, but about how someone handles the consequences of their actions.

     

  • Two young men facing off in a tense confrontation outdoors during a personal conflict
    via Unsplash+ (via Getty Images)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    Two young men facing off in a tense confrontation outdoors during a personal conflict

  • LissaBryan Tell your mutuals that they can loan their laptops to him. NTJ
    via NoBat5123
  • Sweet-Law-3776 NTJ. He already proved he can't be trusted with your laptop and you shouldn't have to risk it again, especially after paying most of the repair costs yourself.
    via NoBat5123
  • carmenthegood Why, in so many of these posts, 'the friends are split'. Why are the friends all involved?
    via NoBat5123
  • Effective-Result79... He didn't paid the full repair, so...
    via NoBat5123
  • tone210sa You never should have loaned it to him the first time. And after he damaged it by spilling coffee on it you should never loan it to him again.
    via NoBat5123
  • Legitimate_Oil270 NTJ. He's obvously careless with belongings. Why should you risk an expensive electronic that you NEED for school? If he needs a computer to use he can go to the library and use one there. Or ask his parents to buy him a new laptop.
    via NoBat5123
  • Ok-Pollution8344 Ntj. He broke your laptop and didn't pay to repair it or replace it. Had he paid for the full repair, it would be a different story. He showed you he doesn't respect your stuff and won't fix his mistakes.
    via NoBat5123
  • bia834 It's your computer, who give what your friends af think. If they say anything say loan his yours if you want to. Otherwise mind your own business.
    via NoBat5123
  • Phaorpha NTJ, you already learned that lesson. Let him get his own cheap laptop he can destroy.
    via NoBat5123
  • Roommates relaxing at home, highlighting shared living dynamics and everyday interactions
    via Unsplash+ (via Getty Images)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

    Roommates relaxing at home, highlighting shared living dynamics and everyday interactions

     

  • TomeThugNHarm... Interesting how debts are always mere "grudges." NTJ.
    via NoBat5123
  • ResponsibleLiability If he'd paid for ALL of the previous repairs I'd still be hesitant about lending again but would consider it. But seeing as he hardly contributed it's a big fat NOPE
    via NoBat5123
  • Educational Gift_... NTJ. "Jake, yeah I'm being petty because, well, you broke my laptop. Yes, I'm holding a grudge because again, you broke my laptop and didn't pay for its repair, so you will not now nor ever use my laptop again.”
    via NoBat5123
  • ForeignOstrich6939 NTJ. Public libraries have computers people can use. Tell him to go there.
    via NoBat5123

  • In the end, this situation became less about a laptop and more about self respect and learning from experience. By standing firm, he reinforced his own limits without escalating the conflict. Sometimes growth comes from uncomfortable conversations, and choosing to protect what matters can be the clearest way to maintain both independence and peace of mind.

     

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

sharing bad roommates reddit story computer reddit thread entitled people
Scroll Down For The Next Article