22-year-old student refuses to lend laptop to careless roommate who previously broke it and didn’t fully pay for repairs, stands his ground: ‘I’m not comfortable risking it again’

Advertisement
  • Laptop on modern desk workspace displaying code, representing study, work, and personal property
  • So I (22M) live with my roommate (23M), “Jake.” We've been living together for about a year, and overall it's been fine, until recently.
  • About three months ago, Jake asked to borrow my laptop for a “quick assignment.” I was hesitant because it's pretty expensive and I need it for school, but he promised to be careful. Long story short, he spilled coffee on it. He apologized a lot, said it was an accident, and promised he'd help pay for repairs.
  • The repairs ended up costing a lot, and while he did chip in a little, I still paid the majority of it. It was frustrating, but I let it go because I figured accidents happen.
  • Fast forward to this week: Jake comes to me again asking to borrow my (newly repaired) laptop because his isn't working. I told him no. I tried to be polite about it, but I basically said I wasn't comfortable lending it out again after what happened last time.
  • He got pretty annoyed and said I was being “petty” and “holding a grudge over an accident." Now things are kind of tense in the apartment. He's been making passive-aggressive comments like "must be nice to not trust your friends."
  • I get that accidents happen, but I also feel like I have a right to protect my stuff, especially since I already took the financial hit once.
  • Some of our mutual friends are split. A couple think I'm being reasonable, but others say I should "give him another chance" since he didn't mean to break it the first time.
  • So... AITJ for refusing to lend him my laptop again?
  • Two young men facing off in a tense confrontation outdoors during a personal conflict
  • LissaBryan Tell your mutuals that they can loan their laptops to him. NTJ
  • Sweet-Law-3776 NTJ. He already proved he can't be trusted with your laptop and you shouldn't have to risk it again, especially after paying most of the repair costs yourself.
  • carmenthegood Why, in so many of these posts, 'the friends are split'. Why are the friends all involved?
  • Effective-Result79... He didn't paid the full repair, so...
  • tone210sa You never should have loaned it to him the first time. And after he damaged it by spilling coffee on it you should never loan it to him again.
  • Legitimate_Oil270 NTJ. He's obvously careless with belongings. Why should you risk an expensive electronic that you NEED for school? If he needs a computer to use he can go to the library and use one there. Or ask his parents to buy him a new laptop.
  • Ok-Pollution8344 Ntj. He broke your laptop and didn't pay to repair it or replace it. Had he paid for the full repair, it would be a different story. He showed you he doesn't respect your stuff and won't fix his mistakes.
  • bia834 It's your computer, who give what your friends af think. If they say anything say loan his yours if you want to. Otherwise mind your own business.
  • Phaorpha NTJ, you already learned that lesson. Let him get his own cheap laptop he can destroy.
  • Roommates relaxing at home, highlighting shared living dynamics and everyday interactions
  • TomeThugNHarm... Interesting how debts are always mere "grudges." NTJ.
  • ResponsibleLiability If he'd paid for ALL of the previous repairs I'd still be hesitant about lending again but would consider it. But seeing as he hardly contributed it's a big fat NOPE
  • Educational Gift_... NTJ. "Jake, yeah I'm being petty because, well, you broke my laptop. Yes, I'm holding a grudge because again, you broke my laptop and didn't pay for its repair, so you will not now nor ever use my laptop again.”
  • ForeignOstrich6939 NTJ. Public libraries have computers people can use. Tell him to go there.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article