Employee starts 8 hour finance shift at 7 AM, boss reprimands him for his 'schedule and visibility': 'Most people come in around nine and leave around six'

Author image for Ally Perry
Ally Perry • Writer and Editor
May 20, 2026 9:15 AM EDT

Is it right to allow an employee to make their own work hours?

There are plenty of people in the workforce who, for one reason or another, believe that flexibility is essential when it comes to their satisfaction at work. They want to know that their job will be manageable alongside their other responsibilities, or they simply want to feel like they are in control of when they do or don't work. It is an understandable desire to have.

Not all companies are going to offer the kind of positions that provide this, which means it can be a godsend to manage to secure a job at a place that does. However, this can sometimes come with strings attached. Just like employers who claim to offer 'unlimited' PTO, those who allow their employees to make their own hours can sometimes take issue with those workers who actually go ahead and do that.

In theory, this arrangement shouldn't be an issue if the work that a person is assigned gets done in the time that it needs to be done. Still, some bosses can be suspicious if their schedule deviates too far from the norm. They assume that something nefarious is going on.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • A businessman, seen from behind, drinks from a mug and works at his laptop with a view of the city skyline
    via Getty Images (Unsplash+)

    A businessman, seen from behind, drinks from a mug and works at his laptop with a view of the city skyline

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • A financial analyst had developed the routine of going to work from 7 AM to 3:30 PM, taking a half-hour break for lunch, which meant he worked the eight hours expected of him. This was at odds with many of his colleagues, who didn't tend to start until 9 and who took hour-long lunches.

    One of these coworkers, who had been struggling with work and staying late, emailed their boss about his early finishes. She claimed not to understand why he was allowed to do this. The manager responded by setting a meeting with him, and he wanted advice on how to navigate it.

  • My boss wants to meet tomorrow about me leaving "too early" and I'm not sure how to handle it without sounding defensive

    Im a salaried analyst at a financial services firm. Been here about two years. Our policy is pretty straightforward, work eight hours a day, take whatever lunch you need, flexible start and end times as long as the work gets done.
    via Latter-Evidence-7124
  • I come in around seven in the morning, take a thirty minute lunch at my desk, and leave at three thirty. Total time at my desk is eight and a half hours with thirty minutes of that being lunch, so Im actually doing the full eight.
    via Latter-Evidence-7124
  • Most people at my office come in around nine and leave around six. They take a full hour lunch and spend a decent chunk of the day chatting in the kitchen, which is fine, I just prefer to start early so my afternoons are mine. I get all my work done. I finish deliverables ahead of time more often than not. My last two reviews were strong.
    via Latter-Evidence-7124
  • A senior on my team has been struggling for a while now. Cant keep up with the new system we moved to last year, takes forever to get her reports out, often there until seven at night finishing things up. Last week she went to our manager and said she didnt understand how I get to leave at three thirty when shes there until late. She framed it as a fairness issue.
    via Latter-Evidence-7124
  • My boss messaged me yesterday saying he wants to discuss my "schedule and visibility" tomorrow morning. Visibility is the word that bothered me.
    via Latter-Evidence-7124
  • Im salaried. I dont get paid overtime. If I get my work done in eight hours and the policy says I can leave, I dont really understand why staying longer for the sake of it should be the unwritten expectation. But I also dont want to walk into that meeting tomorrow sounding like a brat about it.
    via Latter-Evidence-7124
  • How do you push back on something like this without coming off as entitled, especially when the person who reported me is clearly drowning and probably not coming at it in bad faith
    via Latter-Evidence-7124
  • A businessman, seen from behind, works on his tablet with his laptop and a view of the city skyline in front of him
    via Getty Images (Unsplash+)

    A businessman, seen from behind, works on his tablet with his laptop and a view of the city skyline in front of him

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Aggravating_Job_9490 All these comments are defensive and are not helping you handle the situation. First of all, let your boss speak and see what they say. They may not know you're coming in at 7. If they address that you're not working a full day.
    via Aggravating_Job_9490
  • Simply explain you're coming in earlier to get a head start and avoid distractions when the office is full and that you finish all your work. Be calm, be professional. If they ask for you to help other
    via Aggravating_Job_9490
  • people. I simply ask if I do this, what other duties can I set aside and this will prevent me from finishing what I need to do. This way, you're shifting the responsibility to them. After the conversation, you simply send a
    via Aggravating_Job_9490
  • thank you note with what was discussed summarized. Always think ahead and always play chess and not checkers. Office politics is the norm and that's how you keep a job or stay ahead.
    via Aggravating_Job_9490
  • Hot-Cress7492 If your policy is actually documented, refer to it. You're right, the visibility aspect is the way of your boss saying he/she wants to see you when they're there.
    via Hot-Cress7492
  • KeyMulberry9623 "visibility" is the corporate word for "i need you to be inconvenient on purpose so the people who take longer to do the same work feel better about it"
    via KeyMulberry9623
  • Bulky Tiger8706 "I've consistently worked my full required hours, my deliverables are on time, and my reviews have been strong. I prefer starting earlier so I can leave earlier, which I understood was allowed under the flexible schedule policy. I'm happy to discuss team visibility or
    via BulkyTiger8706
  • communication expectations, but I want to make sure performance and completed work remain the focus rather than simply matching everyone else's hours."
    via BulkyTiger8706
  • inknglitter Is there something you're able to do in the early part of your shift that your boss thinks is beneficial, but maybe hasn't consciously considered?
    via inknglitter
  • For instance, are you able to take calls or respond to messages from people in different time zones, or focus on projects with urgent deadlines? Would you not being there early to complete that work cause any disruption to business?
    via inknglitter
  • Highlight that. It's usually much harder to get people to come in earlier (consistently & on time) than it is to get them to stay later once they've arrived.
    via inknglitter

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

boss employee manager work hours workplace
Scroll Down For The Next Article