Family argues with in-laws because they are moving out of the country, and now they can't see each other very often, even though they never got together when they lived close by: 'You already see each other just once or twice per year.'

Advertisement
For context, my wife and I (early 30s), live in the same city as her family. Recently, we got a great job opportunity abroad and we took it, with a date set for our relocation in October. We don't necessarily want to stay in that country permanently, but we see it a great opportunity and life experience, and our job contracts are for now set for a 1-year term with possibility for extension.
Visual representation of a house full of boxes and plants.
When my wife announced it to her parents, she got a pretty bad reaction ranging from "why would you want to move there?" to something like "what are we gonna do without you living nearby?". This really made my wife sad and ped me off because, despite living just 30 minutes away from them, we almost never see her parents or brother (usually like 3 times per year, incl. Christmas). My wife would love to see them more often and used to initiate a lot
and propose a variety of meeting places (inviting to our home too), but the parents often reply with "Oh, we're tired and busy now, let's see each other next month" and her brother always says he has so much work and also suggests meeting a month later which usually never happens. It's important to note her parents are retired and have a loooot of free time, they're also overall healthy and still drive. Her brother does work full time but we all
have the standard corporate 9 to 5 jobs. Last weekend, we all met for a lunch before summer holidays start, and her brother approached me and said sth like "I'm very sad you and my sister are leaving. We will never see each other much now". I simply replied "Well, you already see each other just once or twice per year, so you can continue doing that when you go for vacation to our new country". BIL was surprised by this and said "come on, that's not true", and I said "it's
been like this ever since I met your sister". (for context, the family owns a summer house in the country we'll be moving to, so they really do go there at least once per year always.) After this, someone joined us and the topic changed, but BIL was pretty cold to me for the rest of the night. I understand I probably embarrassed him, but I find it pretty hypocritical that they blame us for leaving while every time rejecting or stalling my
wife's proposals to meet up. My wife didn't hear this convo, but I later told her and she laughed a bit and agreed. AITA?
A woman filling boxes with her stuff, model image.
Brentan 1984 Nta You told the truth You'll see her family just as much when you move. Her parents want her nearby in case they get sick or you have a baby.
atlieninberlin NTA truth hurts sometimes. I moved abroad circa 15 years ago and my family was supportive as I wanted a new opportunity, that is what a healthy relationship would be, not passive agressive shaming. Have fun and enjoy your new adventure
Pretend Temperature I don't understand how people can be so disillusioned about their own lives. He doesn't know how often he sees his sister? Like NTA of course.
Head-Emotion-4598 NTA. My in-laws also love talking about how much they miss us/want to see us but actually spend the least amount of time possible with us. I honestly think they just say it because they think they're suppose to. I don't even try any more. Go have wonderful adventures in your new location and if you happen to see her
family, great. Otherwise just enjoy life with your wife!
ReadMeDrMemory NTA. Just realize that people often hate to have their hypocrisy pointed out. But I would be the last person to blame you for doing it.
anaisaknits NTA. Thank you for sticking up for your wife. Sometimes people need to be shown the truth of their ways.
Minky29 NTA I wouldn't say you embarrassed him, you just pointed out that he was incorrect
Kaleidoscope Top4276 You called him out for not spending time with your wife as much as he could have and he took it as an insult. Hopefully he cools off and realizes you have a point. NTA

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article