Accidental Puppies On Purpose? OP Wants Answers And Reddit Wants To Help

Sometimes, a question gets posted on Reddit's Relationship Advice or Am I The Asshole pages that is way above Reddit's pay grade. It's usually the type of thing where people are told to go see a lawyer or a doctor instead of asking stranger's on the internet. In this case, it was people saying OP should hire a private investigator! Sounds crazy, but stick with us for a moment and you'll see what we mean.

OP is a farmer. He handles almost everything for his parents' small property, maintaining pens for a herd of sheep and a herd of goats, as well as raising two dedicated herding dogs to guard their livestock from predators. But, with so much responsibility on his plate, OP also has to keep some pretty strict rules on the property. One of the most important is that other people aren't allowed to bring their dogs over. OP's dogs are working dogs, not really pets, and since he also studs them out, there's a pregnancy risk for anyone bringing their pets over. Lo and behold, OP's girlfriend didn't listen to him, let her friend bring a dog over, and now there's a litter of puppies running around that nobody has the means to support! When OP turned to Reddit to ask if he was in the wrong for refusing to pay, he got a resounding Hell No, but also a lot of answers suggesting that this was all a setup. Honestly, we feel the same way too. So, we're waiting on an update to see if Taylor or the girlfriend admit guilt here. But, until then, enjoy the rest of this ridiculous and hilarious thread so far. And, when you're done, be sure to keep checking back for more hilarious AITA posts like this one. 

Author image for SamHaKosem
Advertisement
  • 01

    Doesn't Sound Insane Yet

    Font - I know this sounds insane but its been causing grief for weeks. I moved back home a few years ago to take over my parents' hobby farm. My parents asked I continue to keep sheep and goat herds. Predator animals are common so we've always had livestock guard dogs there. I have 2, they are very well trained and socialized, but I don't allow dogs I don't know on the farm unless I'm there the entire time. The set up is like an 'H' - One side is the sheep pastures/barn, the other side is goats.
    via u/aitapuppy_power

    This sounds like a case for Maury already. This guy doesn't want to pay to support the puppies that his dog created, but, he thinks he has a valid reason. We have to admit, at the start we were skeptical of how OP was going to convince us, but by the end, we were totally on his side. You'll see more if you keep reading. 

  • Advertisement
  • 02

    Disaster Waiting To Happen

    Font - One of my dogs is a male and not neutered for reasons relating to the community and us all knowing where our helpers come from and are going to since these doggos perform a specific function in a farming community. Other dog is an older female and spayed. My job requires me to travel once in awhile. I had a week trip about 4 months ago. My gf invited her friend Taylor to come stay with her while I was gone. Before Taylor arrived she asked us if there was a room she could put her dog's cra
    via u/aitapuppy_power

    There are some people in this world who just were not blessed with the gift of intelligence. There are other people in this world who are just plain dumb, and this Taylor sounds like one of them. What the heck is she doing bringing a dog in heat to a farm with an un-neutered work dog, especially after specifically being told not to? 

  • 03

    What Do We Think?

    Font - I asked my cousin while I was gone, he said he and his wife saw the dog on the leash. Taylor left the day I got home. Weeks later her dog had puppies. Gf admitted they only put Taylor's dog on the leash when my cousin was over, and let her run the rest of the time. Her dog kept getting into the dog yard with my boy and they stopped her if they saw her. Taylor wants me to pay half of the vet bills and puppy expenses until they're homed. She's railing about me to my gf about not having my d
    via u/aitapuppy_power
  • 04

    Who Could've Seen This Coming?

    Font - ultrarelative 17 hr. ago Asshole Enthusiast [5] NTA. She brought her non-spayed dog to a house with a non-neutered male dog while her dog was in heat. It takes a special kind of stupid to let a dog in heat run around unsupervised, and you tried to keep it from happening. People like this give me tension headaches. 20.5k Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow
    via u/ultrarelative
  • Advertisement
  • 05

    Clarification From OP

    Font - aitapuppy_power OP 15 hr. ago It was mid-March and the pups are just about 4 weeks old now. I did pay for Taylor to do a heritage test on the puppies, and they are his. Two looks like little versions of him to boot. I wouldn't want anything from the sale of the pups, I generally charge a stud fee and/or pick of goat/sheep until my female gets close to retiring lol I have had the thought it might've been planned as others have suggested and it was...I'd be done. I do plan on asking my gf w
    via u/aitapuppy_power
  • 06

    Listen To The Fellow Farmer

    Font - 2 soayherder 15 hr. ago Asshole Enthusiast [6] Farmer here who keeps a heritage breed of sheep myself. Not only are you NTA, the fact that you're not getting the answer IS the answer, in my opinion. There are SO damn many things that can go wrong with an unleashed dog on a farm with livestock even without the dog being in heat. But there are just too many things lining up here which make me way too suspicious. They just happened to bring their dog who just happened to be in heat and just
    via u/soayherder
  • 07

    We Agree, Homegirl Is Daft

    Font - painted_hound 18 hr. ago NTA and why is she getting at you for not having your working dog neutered? When her pet dog is also not spayed! This is her own fault, you told her not to bring her dog and she did anyway, knowing her own dog was in heat. She's a moron. Edit: your gf is also TA and an idiot because she definitely should have known this would happen and went behind your back on it anyway. 1.2k Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow sorryiquit42 - 9 hr. ago Partassipant [1] OP n
    via u/painted_hound
  • Advertisement
  • 08

    We Smell A Setup

    Font - MadTom65 18 hr. ago Partassipant [4] EUU) NTA. Is it possible that she wanted a litter of puppies sired by your dog? Taylor is an entitled AH. Your girlfriend is an AH for allowing this to happen. 2.6k Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow aitapuppy_power OP 18 hr. ago I've had that thought, and I really hope not. I do stud him out for other farmers so they don't have to pay insane fees from greedballs and know what they're getting. My gf knows I'm very picky about that so I'd be pret
    via u/MadTom65
  • 09

    A Bit?

    Font - HogwartsAlumni25. 18 hr. ago Asshole Enthusiast [7] NTA - she should have listened. Also it's a bit rich of her to complain about your dog not being neutered yet her dog wasn't spayed? 4.7k Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow aitapuppy_power OP 17 hr. ago I've been wondering that and the only response has come from my gf saying Taylor doesn't want to traumatize her dog with that kind of surgery. 2.7k Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow
    via u/HogwartsAlumni25
  • 10

    Yea Amen To This One

    Rectangle - Ellas Enchanting 14 hr. ago Uhhh 1. Your gf sucks 2. Sounds like it was planned and Taylor realized how expensive it was and now wants money for the bills. Do NOT GIVE EITHER OF THEM MONEY 69 Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow
    via u/EllasEnchanting

    For a weekly dose of animal-themed community challenges - Subscribe to our Newsletter!

    Can't get enough of ICanHasCheezburger? Find us on Instagram!

Check out our Instagram for more hilarious animal content!

Love our stuff? Shop for some of our pawsome merch here.

Tags

boyfriend dogs aita puppies am i the asshole girlfriend argument farm Reddit
Scroll down for the next article

Also From Animal Comedy

Trending Now

20 Itty Bitty Cute Baby Animals To Bring A Smile To Your Face (April 27, 2025)

20 Itty Bitty Cute Baby Animals To Bring A Smile To Your Face (April 27, 2025)

01
'She sent a random man into our home and then pretended she was there': Pet sitter scams hardworking family out of $300 after agreeing to watch their doggos overnight, forcing the pawrents to send Dad home in the middle of vacation

'She sent a random man into our home and then pretended she was there': Pet sitter scams hardworking family out of $300 after agreeing to watch their doggos overnight, forcing the pawrents to send Dad home in the middle of vacation

02
20-year-old college roommate's refusal of student's emotional support dog in their shared space sparks accusations of insensitivity: 'I lost my temper'

20-year-old college roommate's refusal of student's emotional support dog in their shared space sparks accusations of insensitivity: 'I lost my temper'

03
23 Gamer Animal Memes for Pawrents Who Game With a Cat on Their Lap

23 Gamer Animal Memes for Pawrents Who Game With a Cat on Their Lap

04
22 Woofing Whimsical Dog Memes Borking Barks Full of Funnies

22 Woofing Whimsical Dog Memes Borking Barks Full of Funnies

05
23 Fresh and Feel-Good Animal Pics to Hatch Happiness in Your Hooman Hearts

23 Fresh and Feel-Good Animal Pics to Hatch Happiness in Your Hooman Hearts

06
Advertisement