'I made sure the boiler was rendered useless': Tenant gets even with landlord following refusal to reimburse him for boiler repair; tenant renders boiler useless

Advertisement
  • 01
    Font - Posted by u/Jave285 1 day ago Refuse to pay for boiler repair during winter? Okay then... This was about 10 years ago. Still makes me feel good whenever I think about it.
  • 02
    Font - I used to rent a house. The landlord lived abroad, so his Brother (nice guy) looked after maintenance and the landlord's Lawyer (do chebag) looked after the contract/legal stuff. I had the Brother's phone number as he was my point of contact if anything needed fixing.
  • 03
    Font - One winter, the boiler broke. This is in Northern Europe, so this is considered to be an emergency repair. I called the Brother multiple times, but it always went straight to voicemail. It didn't even ring. I left a bunch of texts, and spent the first night shivering under all the bedding in the house as temperatures outside approached freezing.
  • 04
    Font - The next morning, I left more voicemails and texts, but by the afternoon, still no response. By this point, the temperature inside the house was around 7 degrees Celsius. I decided to take matters into my own hands, and ring around for an engineer to fix it. They came that
  • 05
    Font - evening, diagnosed the problem (a worn out motor), removed the broken part, installed the new part, and billed me for parts and labour. I texted the Brother to let him know what I had done.
  • 06
    Font - A few days later, the Brother finally responded and apologised for being out of touch. He had been on holiday. I said no major harm done, but I need reimbursement for the repair. He told me to call the Lawyer and gave me his number.
  • 07
    Font - I called the Lawyer and explained everything. He was like a brick wall. Totally unreasonable, unsympathetic to the situation, and accusatory to me, saying that I had broken the terms of the tenancy agreement. I said that they had also violated the agreement by not responding to an emergency
  • 08
    Font - repair in a reasonable amount of time. Under the circumstances, I felt I had no choice, and hope we can come to some sort of arrangement. He said no. I asked whether we could split the bill - I pay for the labour, and they pay for the part, which will
  • 09
    Font - remain in the boiler in their property indefinitely. He said no, and at that point said I should "put this all down as a lesson learned and move on", and hung up on me.
  • 10
    Font - I was not very happy, to say the least. The bill was pretty significant, and I had effectively repaired their boiler for them free of charge. Not to mention the inconvenience and discomfort of being without heating in winter.
  • 11
    Font - I was looking at the engineer's bill wondering what I could do, then realised - the bill has my name, my phone number, my signature on it, and the part and its cost clearly listed.
  • 12
    Font - I waited 8 months until the tenancy agreement expired, then moved out (I was planning to anyway). I called the same engineer and asked him to remove the motor from the boiler. He questioned why, but I talked around it, paid him cash, and
  • 13
    Font - all was good. It obviously cost me more money, but ended up being totally worth it. When I moved out the next day, I made sure everything was spotless, and left the property like a perfect
  • 14
    Font - tenant. The Brother came to inspect the property. He had a cursory look around to check nothing was obviously damaged, then bid me goodbye, and I gave him the keys. Thankfully he didn't check whether the boiler was
  • 15
    Font - working. Why would he? He knows I would have informed him immediately had it broken again. Either way, the security deposit landed back in my account a few days later.
  • 16
    Font - A couple of months went by, and then I got a text from the Brother asking if the boiler had been working okay when I left. I said yeah, why? No response. Next day I got a phonecall from the Lawyer. He was furious.
  • 17
    Font - Lawyer: Did you remove the motor from the boiler?! Me: Yes. Why? Lawyer: rants about damage to landlord's property etc
  • 18
    Font - Me: Sorry, bit busy right now. Please put all of this in writing to my email hangs up Later that day I got a VERY long, ranty email threatening legal action. He obviously took some time to put it together, but honestly it reeked of intimidation tactics.
  • 19
    Font - I waited a day or so, just to be annoying, then replied: "Dear Lawyer, Thank you for your email. Please find attached a document that proves that the boiler motor in question is my own personal property.
  • 20
    Font - I recommend you put this all down as a lesson learned and move on. Sincerely, OP" I attached the engineer's original bill and clicked send.
  • 21
    Font - Never heard back. To this day, I'm not 100% sure I was legally in the clear, but it was definitely worth the risk, knowing that they had to pay for it in the end.
  • 22
    Font - TL:DR Landlord's representative refuses to reimburse me for emergency boiler part replacement, so I take the part with me when I move out, rendering the boiler useless.
  • 23
    Font - EDIT: People keep asking why I didn't withhold rent until the cost of the repair was covered. Answer: that's not legal in my country.
  • 24
    Font - Lay-ZFair 1 day ago +2. I hope the landlord made the lawyer pay for it. 536 Reply
  • 25
    Font - Maximum-Dealer-6208 · 1 day ago Why didn't you just call back the nice-guy-brother and tell him about the lawyer? I would've expected him to straighten it out since he was responsible for the boiler anyway, and he obviously understood your situation.
  • 26
    Font - Jave285 OP 23 hr. ago . It had been clear to me throughout my tenancy there that the Brother was just a handyman/maintenance guy. I also got that from my initial conversation with him about the boiler.
  • 27
    Font - But to be honest I just wanted to scrow over the lawyer as much as possible at that point. Sweet reh-ven- 342 ↓ Reply Share
  • 28
    Font - gizahnl +1 - 1 day ago Hope you moved out in winter & it took them a bit of time to find another tenant so their pipes burst due to freezing Since it was Northern Europe, and thus likely sane renters protections, you could've probably just have deducted the bill from the rent.
  • 29
    Font - My partner had some issues with her landlord in Germany where he wasn't responding to repair requests, so she stopped paying rent to him. Went on like that for at least half a year before she decided to move out. Turned out the guy di-d and that's why he wasn't repairing the place, so she could've lived there for a lot longer for free of she'd known 127 Reply Share

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article