Internet Gets Creative and Hilariously Takes Guesses at Deciphering this Mystery Cookie Cutter

Isabella Penn

Nov 19, 2023 9:00 PM EST

Cookie cutters never quite nail the shape they are supposed to be. But that's where the real fun kicks in—when you break out that bag of random cookie cutters once in a blue moon and play the "Guess What Heck Is This" game. In the spirit of Thanksgiving, have you ever seen a turkey-shaped cookie cutter? It's basically a shapeless blob. But hey, I guess the real magic happens when you start decorating that thing.

This woman on Reddit might've stumbled upon the most bizarre cookie cutter shape ever. She simply couldn't figure out what it was, so she took to the Internet—and the responses are hilarious. People threw out guesses that are almost as random as the actual answer. Which we do reveal, btw. We wouldn't leave you hanging. Scroll to the end to find out.