Dungeons and Dragons Player Criticizes First-Time Dungeon Master, Stating Campaign Lacked Loot Despite Acquiring Magic Items

A first-time Dungeon Master running the Lost Mine of Phandelver campaign for two separate friend groups finds themself in a tricky situation. After diligently preparing the entire campaign, the DM received unexpected criticism from a player regarding loot distribution and overall campaign style. Nobody likes hearing that they messed up, but this DM was open to hearing how they could improve. How did the issue even arise?

Well, it began when the DM expressed excitement about finishing campaign prep. The player expressed dissatisfaction, claiming they weren't finding enough loot. The DM countered by highlighting the magical items the party had already acquired, including the magical sword Talon and a ring of protection.

The conversation escalated when the DM pointed out missed opportunities, particularly the custom loot placed within Thundertree specifically for some players. The frustrated player dismissed this, arguing that the DM wasn't providing enough clues and that other DMs offer more customization and random loot tables. Caught off guard, the kindhearted DM turned to good old Reddit for advice. What would you say?

Then, check out a critical hit of Dungeons and Dragons memes for roleplaying dice rollers.

Advertisement

Tags

games table dispute frustration dice roll barrels dnd players magical items dungeon master dnd party dnd loot characters ttrpg sourcebook dnd campaign dungeons and dragons

Scroll down for the next article

Also From Geek Universe

Trending Now

6-year-old ruins sibling's manga after she uses them as coloring books, annoyed sibling is met with unexpected reaction after sharing it online: ‘She made it better’

6-year-old ruins sibling's manga after she uses them as coloring books, annoyed sibling is met with unexpected reaction after sharing it online: ‘She made it better’

Gamer Accurately Makes Popular Animal Crossing Characters as Humans On the Sims

Gamer Accurately Makes Popular Animal Crossing Characters as Humans On the Sims

37 Dungeons & Dragons Memes That Crit You Right in the Funny Bone

37 Dungeons & Dragons Memes That Crit You Right in the Funny Bone

If You Think the New Predator Looks Bad – You're Missing the Entire Point

If You Think the New Predator Looks Bad – You're Missing the Entire Point

26 Harry Potter Memes to Enjoy While Lounging in the Cozy Gryffindor Common Room (April 24, 2025)

26 Harry Potter Memes to Enjoy While Lounging in the Cozy Gryffindor Common Room (April 24, 2025)

42 Pictures That Are So Incredibly 80s, You Might Hear a Synth Solo Just Looking at Them

42 Pictures That Are So Incredibly 80s, You Might Hear a Synth Solo Just Looking at Them

Advertisement