New parents secretly change their 4-month-old's name after the husband's sister-in-law steals their original name choice and gives it to her 7-month-old: ‘First, middle, and last name’

Author image for Lana DeGaetano
Lana DeGaetano • "Show me to me please."
Jun 26, 2025 4:00 PM EDT

Arguments over baby names are a tale as old as time. Most parents want their tiny tot to have a unique edge to their personhood, while some might be inspired to name their kids after the ancestors who came before them. Either way, those same parents probably prefer having their child's name be their name only—cousin Jennifer really couldn't think of another name besides "James"? I find that hard to believe…

The dilemma lies in the inherent competition that is involved with baby-naming. It shouldn't exist, sure, but it does—this story and many others make that abundantly clear. Why do folks feel the need to "steal" names that another parent couple is thinking about naming their child? Is it an envy thing? Perhaps, a FOMO thing? I have no idea… The parents in this next story, who hid their future child's name, chose to change their child's name. The father's sister-in-law chose to name her baby, who was born first, the name they were planning on using for their child. Yes, the sister-in-law did this on purpose. Scroll below to read about the family's reaction.

Advertisement
  • HIS NAME IS
    via Sincerely Media for Unsplash

  • "AITA for silently changing my son's name after my brother and SIL gave my nephew the name too?"

    My wife and I had our son 4 months ago. We had a name chosen early in her pregnancy. We kept that name to ourselves
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • but my SIL (married to my brother) found it out when she was still pregnant with my nephew (almost 7 months old).
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • She never said how. She just told us she loved the name, congrats and she couldn't wait to meet him. We assume she snooped
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • because she was not told. I even mentioned it to my brother and he said that his wife does like to browse through people's things like it was no biggie.
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • Then when my nephew was born they announced his name and it was the name we chose. First, middle and last name. My brother
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • called right after SIL posted the announcement and he told me to keep quiet because his wife had a rough birth and she didn't need drama and he knew we might not like it but she really wanted the name.
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • Cheezburger Image 10522315008
    via Luma Pimentel for Unsplash

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • Her reason? My brother and I have matching twin-like names and SIL wanted to connect our two boys by just giving them the same name so they were each other's namesake.
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • My wife and I talked it over and we decided to pick a different name. But we'd pretend to keep the original name until there was
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • zero risk of SIL changing my nephew's name (6 months after a birth is harder to make a change in our state).
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • We only started telling people the true name last week. My parents and sisters said it made sense. Friends and my ILs understood
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • why we did it. My brother told me I upset his wife by silently doing this sh and taking away her choice to match the boys. He told
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • me it was a move. I told him his wife using the full name we chose was a move.
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • I asked him if he considered how much tougher it would be with both boys enrolled in the same schools with the very same
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • name. Not to mention banking, doctors, dental all kinds of stuff. He told me plenty of people have the same name and it's not a big deal and it's harder to mix sh up now and we're just trying to gatekeep names.
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • I think he's cray. So does my wife. She said he clearly doesn't want SIL to be mad. But AITA for what I did? Like are we weird for thinking of this kind of stuff?
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • LovingWisdom Definitely NTA: Your brother is outraged that you "took away SIL's choice to match the boys" What about the fact that she took away your choice to have an individual name? By invading your privacy? He's fine with that I assume?
    via LovingWisdom
  • DaikonCompetitive147 He acted like it was no biggie while I'm thinking I need to keep a closer eye on her in future.
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • LovingWisdom Of course he did, it's a big deal when his wife is upset, but when his wife upsets someone else he couldn't care less. You need to keep her out of your private spaces, you shouldn't have to watch her like she's a child.
    via LovingWisdom
  • 24601moamo NTA. Skip the brother. Tell SIL she is creepy and she's not allowed around your son until she gets her behavior under control. It's creepy in my opinion.
    via 24601moamo
  • Annual_Union8025 Your brother and sister in law are WEIRDOS. Not just for picking the same name secretly that you had already chosen (and then hypocritically getting mad at you for secretly changing your son's name), but also for being mad that they can't force you all to have the same name as their son. They also don't sound very bright.
    via Annual_Union8025
  • DaikonCompetitive147 I'm shocked he isn't fighting it. But he seems to be willing to do whatever she wants.
    via DaikonCompetitive147
  • Wed_Penny Dreadful13 How did she find this info? She would never be allowed in my house or near my things.
    via Wed_PennyDreadful13
  • DaikonCompetitive147 We had some blankets with the name and our best guess is she found them while snooping.
    via DaikonCompetitive147

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family dynamics family drama baby baby names entitled parents entitlement mother reddit story family feud parenting entitled family pregnant reddit thread parent Reddit name Parenting Fail parents entitled people Father Parenting FAILS
Scroll Down For The Next Article