‘I told her absolutely not, if she had money for a luxury trip, she has money to help Mom’: Brother refuses to cover his sister’s half of their mom’s $6,000 medical bill because the sister took a 10-day luxury vacation in Italy

Advertisement
  • AITJ for refusing to cover my sister’s half of our mom’s medical bills after she took a luxury vacation?

    Cheezburger Image 10554785792
  • Advertisement
  • Our mom (62F) had an unexpected surgery. Insurance covered most, but there's still a $6,000 balance.
  • My sister (34F) and I (31M) agreed to split it since Mom doesn't have savings. Two weeks later, my sister went on a 10-day vacation to Italy.
  • Just weighing her options.

    Cheezburger Image 10554774784
  • Advertisement
  • When I asked about her half, she said she "doesn't have the cash right now" and that I should cover it because I'm "better with money." I told her absolutely not, if she had money for a luxury trip, she has money to help Mom.
  • Now she's calling me heartless for "making Mom wait" and says I'm "using money to punish her." Mom doesn't want to "take sides," but I know she's stressed.
  • Cheezburger Image 10554770176
  • Advertisement
  • AITJ for refusing to cover my sister's share?
  • SportySue60 NTJ... she should never have agreed to split the cost with you if she didn't have the cash...
  • BreezyBill Mom should get a payment plan from the doctor.
  • Advertisement
  • Parkour82 if your mother has no assets, then do not pay the bill yourself. The medical place should arrange something with your mother as a payment plan. Even if 5$/ week. Let your mom pay that instead.
  • singerontheside Do not pay more than your share, and don't feel guilty about it.
  • IndependentEarth123 10-day trips abroad are usually planned well in advance with non- refundable reservations and deposits. If your Mom's medical expenses were unexpected, then your sister should have been more upfront about her liquidity. However, her trip doesn't mean she suddenly dropped money to avoid paying your Mom's bill.
  • Advertisement
  • mcmurrml What is mom going to pay? You kids do not have to pay your mom's medical bills. 62 is not that old. She can set up payment plans. Don't get into the habit of paying her expensive bills. Why didn't you split the bill three ways if you wanted to help? Did you mom try to talk to the hospital on options? Don't get into this habit. You kids have your own lives and your own responsibility. Your sister is allowed to take a trip. She works hard I assume and why is she expected to sacrifice her
  • LazyAd622 Your mom is 62 years old. She needs to pay her own bills. Medical bills are commonly negotiated and a payment plan implemented.
  • Revolutionary_Bet679 Most hospitals will settle on a payment plan or offer a sliding scale rate if you call and talk to their billing dept. Dont pay your sisters share.
  • Advertisement
  • LissaBryan Your sister planned this. She planned her vacation well in advance. She knew she wouldn't have the money to pay for both. She waited until the last minute to drop the burden in your lap, expecting to force you into. paying for it. Don't let her lie and say she'll pay you back. She will not. You *know* she will not. Tell your mother that you're sorry, but your sister chose Italy over the surgery she needs.
  • United-Plum 1671 Your sister isn't obligated to pay for your mom's hospital bills. Your mom is 62 not old and feeble. She should be contacting the hospital to work out a payment plan and not putting it on her kids. Stop acting like your sister is the irresponsible one in this scenario

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article