Senior mechanical engineer dismisses junior's correct analysis, costing the company tens of thousands of dollars: 'Maybe next time you’ll check my math before calling me useless'

Pro tip for all managers out there: listening to employees with "less experience" than you is always a good idea.

There are several reasons why this is a good idea. First and foremost, whatever happened to the longstanding concept that the best idea should win? Regardless of industry, it would behoove managers to ignore the false notion that they always know best simply because they have been working longer. In fact, sometimes it takes people who are not so accustomed to the way things "should" be for a decent solution to be proposed.

Second, managers should always think twice before ignoring people on their team if they want to maintain loyalty and respect. Don't managers want to be seen as good managers? One would think this is a self-explanatory concept, but in actuality, plenty of managers fail to grasp the concept of what it takes to actually consider the experiences of the people on your team. You don't want someone going over your head and making you look bad in the process.

Finally, the worst possible scenario that can transpire after ignoring an employee's idea on your team is if your project backfires for the company at large, all because you didn't take your employee seriously. That's exactly what happened to this senior mechanical engineer!

Like what you see? Follow our WhatsApp channel for more.

Author image for Ben Weiss Ben Weiss
Advertisement
  • Three engineers wearing eyeglasses work on their respective projects in a workplace environment.
    via ThisisEngineering

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Advertisement

  • The author, a junior engineer, pointed out a flaw, per his mathematical calculations, that his manager immediately dismissed. Well, that flaw ended up being correct, and it cost the company tens of thousands of dollars. Furthermore, the client was enraged, and the senior engineer's job was instantly on the line. That's what you get for assuming you're better than your employees, sir!

  • "Maybe next time you’ll check my math before calling me useless"

    I used to work as a junior mechanical engineer at a mid- sized firm. My team lead was one of those old school engineers who thought experience automatically outweighed logic.
    via DewyFern5
  • He constantly dismissed my input, rolled his eyes when I ran simulations, and loved saying, you fresh grads think computers know everything.
    via DewyFern5
  • One day, we were working on a structural support design for a heavy industrial line. I pointed out a potential stress failure in one of
    via DewyFern5
  • Advertisement
  • his beam selections during my FEA (Finite Element Analysis). He laughed, said my numbers were theoretical nonsense, and went ahead with his design.
    via DewyFern5
  • I sent him an email documenting my analysis, cc'd the project manager, just for the record.
    via DewyFern5
  • A few months later, during installation, his beam failed under load during a dry test. Luckily, no one was hurt, but it cost the company tens of thousands to fix. The client was furious.
    via DewyFern5
  • Advertisement
  • When the project manager asked what happened, I calmly pulled up the same email the team lead ignored, timestamped, detailed, and attached with simulation reports.
    via DewyFern5
  • They didn't demote him. Instead, the manager said, From now on, I want you to work closely with him, pointing. towards me. Every design leaves this office with his verification.
    via DewyFern5
  • The look on his face was priceless. Now every time he submits a drawing, it lands right on my desk first for junior review.
    via DewyFern5
  • Advertisement
  • When he tried to joke about it once, I just smiled and said, Maybe next time you'll check my math before calling me useless. The silence hit harder than the beam failure.
    via DewyFern5
  • An engineer wearing eyeglasses works amidst a blurry background.
    via ThisisEngineering

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • FrostEchoesy • 17h ago . That "junior review" title probably burns him more than any demotion ever could.
    via DewyFern5
  • Advertisement
  • Lisa8472.15h ago I was working on a proposal budget recently. My boss. looked at it and asked why I had both a senior and a junior engineer, neither of which was more than half time. Couldn't I just combine them into one role?
    via DewyFern5
  • I told him no. Partly for skill sets, and partly because a second person checking the first's work is really important (we ALL make mistakes sometimes). And I'm likely going to be the senior engineer if this goes through. Your team lead was a total idiot.
    via DewyFern5
  • Bramble-Shade 17h ago . He underestimated you and overestimated his beam. Both failed under load.
    via DewyFern5
  • Advertisement
  • wereyena • 12h ago . Make sure you document all your projects and every single projects you review and use it as leverage when u ask for a promotion
    via DewyFern5
  • Two men review engineering plans from a document.
    via ThisisEngineering

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

Stay up to date by following us on Facebook!

Tags

mathematics toxic-manager employee work stories manager work engineering overworked-employees Horrible Bosses funny work stories
Scroll Down For The Next Article

Also From FAIL Blog

Employee loses job opportunity after former coworker exposes them for taking credit on a project they didn't earn: 'I didn't badmouth her, just gave a factual example'

Employee loses job opportunity after former coworker exposes them for taking credit on a project they didn't earn: 'I didn't badmouth her, just gave a factual example'

Trending Now

16-year-old abruptly kicked out by father with just $20 and no support for "talking back", spends days homeless before friend shelters him, he is eventually fetched by his father, but struggles with forgiveness years later: 'I've never healed from this'

16-year-old abruptly kicked out by father with just $20 and no support for "talking back", spends days homeless before friend shelters him, he is eventually fetched by his father, but struggles with forgiveness years later: 'I've never healed from this'

01
A Midday Lunch of 29 Brown-Bagged Funnies to Get You Through the Workday (October 13, 2025)

A Midday Lunch of 29 Brown-Bagged Funnies to Get You Through the Workday (October 13, 2025)

02
Homeowner demands their neighbor’s new fence be moved after she installs it several feet into homeowner’s property: ‘[She] asked if I would be willing to just live with it due to the expense’

Homeowner demands their neighbor’s new fence be moved after she installs it several feet into homeowner’s property: ‘[She] asked if I would be willing to just live with it due to the expense’

03
58-year-old essential employee gets laid off 1 year before retiring, entire team quits out of loyalty, HR begs them to come back for double their original pay: 'I'll come back for 13 weeks'

58-year-old essential employee gets laid off 1 year before retiring, entire team quits out of loyalty, HR begs them to come back for double their original pay: 'I'll come back for 13 weeks'

04
Entitled neighbor demands that HOA-exempt residents in the neighborhood join, resident refuse: '[He's] upset because we're not included in their misery'

Entitled neighbor demands that HOA-exempt residents in the neighborhood join, resident refuse: '[He's] upset because we're not included in their misery'

05
Manager accidentally screen shares payroll information during a team meeting: ‘I discovered I am one of the lowest paid employees!'

Manager accidentally screen shares payroll information during a team meeting: ‘I discovered I am one of the lowest paid employees!'

06
Advertisement