Son refuses to sell his inherited home at a 20% discount for a family “friend” his mom hasn’t spoken to in 20 years: ‘She asked why I wouldn’t be generous and charitable, I am not wealthy. I am a teacher.. I have been poor my entire life’

Author image for Etai Eshet
Etai Eshet • Editor
Oct 26, 2025 3:00 PM EDT

One modest rural house, passed down through the generations, suddenly becomes a test of moral fiber. The guy who inherited it wants to sell it fair and square. The mother, now comfortably cushioned by remarried wealth, wants him to play local savior. Her plan involves selling to a family friend for a generous discount, in the name of community spirit. He's still living on a teacher's salary and doing mental math on medical bills, but apparently he's the selfish one for wanting market value. It's like the Inheritance magically sent the mother the ancient Greece and turned her into a financial moral philosopher, looking for virtue in her son's pockets.

Advertisement

  • AITAH for not wanting to sell an inherited home at a huge discount?

    Confused male teacher holding a pen in front of a chalkboard with circuit diagrams, while an older woman outlined in red leans in with a puzzled expression.
    via Dalila Dalprat/ gonzalo mateos

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • There’s a pattern that repeats itself in some families. The one who inherits something instantly becomes the designated lesson in generosity. Everyone else gets to act noble on someone else’s balance sheet. It’s the emotional version of crowdfunding, except the donor is guilted into thinking virtue requires a discount. In modern generosity, optics matter more than math. People want charity to look selfless but rarely want it to cost them anything. The wealthy love advising others to be giving because they’ve finally reached the safety of abundance. Meanwhile, the ones still budgeting every grocery trip are expected to prove they have a good heart by ignoring practicality. 

  • Note: I am going to try my best to avoid charged/loaded language here, as I am genuinely interested in objective takes on this scenario.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I am autistic, so I am worried my read on the situation might be "off" because of that.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • Background: I (35- 40m) have recently inherited my grandparents' small 2-bedroom home in the rural U.S., one of the lowest cost-of- living locations in the country.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • This is the home my mother spent many years of her life in, basically her entire teens.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • Cheezburger Image 10565679616
    via BearFotos

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • My grandparents continued to live there throughout the 80s, 90s, 00s, and 10s, up until my grandmother was placed into a supervised living facility.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • For the past 4-5 years we have allowed a family to live there as caretakers, maintaining the home in exchange for no rent whatsoever.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • The home was deeded to me about a year into the arrangement, and the family knew the situation wasn't permanent.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • In early 2024, I notified the family that I would be listing the home in 2025.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • They understood, and I received little pushback. They were grateful for the 4-5 years of relatively free housing, and they had their things packed and moved by my deadline with no conflict at all.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • Cheezburger Image 10565680640
    via Dalila Dalprat

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • The conflict has since arrived with my mother. She recently asked me if I was going to sell it for the low price it was appraised for in 2022 (after I took ownership, we had an appraisal).
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I informed her that I probably wasn't going to because a lot has changed since then, and I feel like it would be smart and fair to get an updated value.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • She seemed upset by this answer, and mentioned that an old family friend (someone we haven't spoken to in 20+ years) had reached out to her on social media to ask about purchasing the property.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • When she shared that appraisal value, the person said it was out of their budget. That's when my mother began explaining to me her opinion that this is an opportunity to show generosity and a giving spirit by helping someone out in a time of need.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • Rather than get an accurate appraisal and sell to an unknown buyer for market value, she suggested I sell at about a 20% markdown to this former family friend.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • R1 BATTERY RES ли A+B OR RES B+C AND LED t = - Vim (1+22)
    via gonzalo mateos

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • When I asked her why I should even consider doing that, she simply stated that their family has been in the area for a long time and maybe they're trying to be better.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • For context, this family-including the very person referenced, has a long history of property crime and drug-related arrests in the area.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I'm not suggesting that means their entire family is full of awful, horrible people. But I am stating outright that their presence has not been a net- positive.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • She asked why I wouldn't consider being generous and charitable, given the opportunity, and I explained my position.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I feel like I have been quite generous and charitable for the past 4-5 years, allowing a struggling family to live there.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • If I sold to ANYONE at a discount, it would have been them. Secondly, I am not wealthy.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I am a teacher, and my wife is disabled and only capable of working a small number of hours per week-which she does and is great at.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I have been poor my entire life. My mother was also poor until she married into wealth about ten years ago.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • When I tried to explain that our capability to extend charity is very different, I was told that I'm not being considerate or grateful for the opportunity.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • My plan is to sell this house and leave the state to teach elsewhere in a community that better aligns with my ideals and career goals.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • Rural America is not great for me when it comes to either of those things. On one hand, I understand I did not purchase nor build this home.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • It is entirely "free" to me. But I take issue with the idea that I should forego a realistic opportunity to improve my own family's future and security just for the feels.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I regularly engage in philanthropy at a budget that is bearable to me. But I have less than $50,000 annual household income.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • The amount she considers trivial is quite literally more than half of my annual salary, and it isn't trivial to me at all.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • I don't feel like I'm being an asshole in this exchange, but I can't help but question it, given the way this phone call played out.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • So am I an autistic asshole yet again, or is my mom being unreasonable about this?
    via GaryBuseyIsLord

  • Some call it kindness. In practice, it’s theater performed with other people’s assets. There’s nothing wrong with compassion but it loses its charm when it comes with performance notes. The guy isn’t greedy for wanting full price. He’s just tired of starring in somebody else’s morality play.

  • NTA teresajs If generosity is so important to your mother, she's welcome to offer to find the difference out of her own pocket.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • OP Gary BuseylsLord I offered that solution, as well.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • celticmusebooks NTA and if your mom is so "high" on charity she should buy the house at market value and resell to her friends. If I read your post correctly the house will appraise higher now than when you took it over-- and they said that the previous appraised price was outside of their budget. So she wants you to discount the already below market price. Is that correct? My money is on them not being able to get a loan and you'll either be expected to cosign or do some wacky under the table l
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • OP Gary BuseylsLord That is correct.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • maski360 Inheritances and money are such great ways to tear families apart. I agree something smells funny here beyond Mom feeling like she has some say in the future of her childhood home. There are a couple of possibilities: 1. She feels slighted, so if she doesn't benefit from the sale of the house, her son shouldn't either. 2. As u/vwscienceandart says, she doesn't want "the neighborhood to change" and thus wants to control who lives in the house next. 3. She has a relationship with drug hea
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • OP Gary BuseylsLord I have a PhD, so they don't really try to suggest things like that to me very often (that I don't "get it"). That was more of my own consideration as a measure of thoroughness.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • 0101001 NTA. As mentioned by others, you can offer to sell the home at its current FMV to your mother who can then sell the home at a discount to the family. Alternatively, you can get the home appraised, sell it to the family at a discounted rate and have your mom pay you the difference, which she should do from the generosity of her heart to a family she deems is in need. You don't need to explain yourself. You aren't wealthy, you don't have the privilege of the kind of generosity your mom is
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • OP Gary BuseylsLord I found the request to be batshit insane, as well.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • axc199stang These people are not family friends. Let's make that clear. He is a low class moocher trying to get a house on the cheap using past connections out of greed.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • OP Gary BuseylsLord That is my assessment, as well.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • MissionHoneydew2209 It's gracious of your mother to offer her home to these struggling people. Oh.... wait. She offered YOUR home? Screw THAT. There's a reason you grandparents left this home to you. They wanted you to thrive - so go do that with a 100% clear conscience. NTA, in any way shape or form. Your mom is a giant one for pressuring you into giving away your chance to better your family's life, and get the hell out of Mayberry, RFD.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • thedoodely Actually, someone you haven't contacted in 2 decades coming up to you to buy a property like that out of nowhere smells an awful lot like a flipper.
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • GroovyYaYa Appraisal doesn't always match sales price either!! You are looking for a market value estimate don't necessarily hire an appraiser, get a real estate agency. They will know what the MARKET is right now. You could be gifting much much more if you went through with it. As you said, it would be one thing to sell it to the people who had been living there, essentially rent free. It would be very easy to sell "as is" saving on some closing costs, etc. as presumably they'd be aware of any
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • jittarao NTA. Your mom's preaching generosity with your assets and your future security, not hers. Tell her: "If you believe in this so strongly, you're welcome to buy the home from me at current market value and then give your friend the discount yourself. That's real generosity. Otherwise, I'm selling it for what it's worth." If double property sales tax is a concern where you live, she can always pay you the difference directly. You already gave 4-5 years of free housing. That's more than gen
    via GaryBuseyIsLord
  • Neat-Client9305 I, in general, am not impressed with people who are generous with other people's belongings. Your mother needs to mind her own business
    via GaryBuseyIsLord

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama inheritance brother mother tradition siblings family feud favoritism wedding sister fiancé grandmother Father teacher
Scroll Down For The Next Article