18-year-old daycare worker forbids 7-year-old from using her colleague's hand sanitizer, despite her colleague offering the hand sanitizer to her: 'She needs to learn that she can't always get what she wants.'

Advertisement
  • Person holding hand sanitizer over child's hand
  • Am I the bad guy for wanting to allow a girl to use my hand sanitizer?

    I know the title sounds weird, so I'll start by providing some background info. 1 (20F) work at an after-school-program and there's a little girl (7-8 F) who has some sensory issues (hasn't been diagnosed with anything, so I won't attempt to here). One day I
  • Gil in red floral headband and a yellow shirt
  • was working with her, she started to melt down as my coworker (18F) gave all the kids hand sanitizer due to being averse to the smell and texture. I let her use mine (the Touchland Watermelon one from Ulta) and she calmed down, so I told her that in the future, she could just ask me to use mine. Well, today, she asked if
  • she could use my hand sanitizer. I of course said yes before my coworker said she could just use the school's. The girl calmly explained that she didn't like the smell and texture, but my coworker told her "I don't care" and told me not to let her use it because she needed to learn that she couldn't always get what she
  • wants and it would result in the other kids wanting to use it. To be clear, I would have no issue with the other kids using it and am all for teaching kids that they can't always get what they want, but I just don't think this is the time or place to do so. However, me being neurodivergent could cause me to be biased, so I wanted to get some more neutral perspectives as to whether I was the AH
  • Daycare teacher with daycare kids at a table
  • Klutzy_Start708 Not an asshole. Perhaps worth discussing it with her parents so they can equip her with her own supply of hand sanitiser if it's a sensory issue that might impact her health in future.
  • International-Eye676 OP Yeah, that's what I was thinking, too, or talking with who her teacher is (I work at a school where I know a lot of the staff and have good relationships with them since I also went there) and asking him/her for advice on how to approach the parent/guardian
  • Nice-Dinner-8456 imagine a scenario where sensory needs trump stubborn rules and empathy wins
  • HeavensAnger NTA. Your coworker said "I don't care" to a kid calmly explaining a sensory issue. That's not teaching a lesson, that's just being mean. You found a simple fix that works-keep doing it.
  • International-Eye676 OP That's what pissed me off the most, to be honest. I know that if a teacher had said that to me, there would've been hell to pay (I'm ND as well). Plus, it may make this kid afraid to advocate for herself, which is such an important skill for kids to have, especially if they're ND and are around people who don't really understand what it's like for them
  • ProjectJourneyman Your coworker seems to be an immature kid, and not an ideal person to have around young children. Not uncommon in these environments, you'll only be able to do so much to improve the situation for the kids. If you have some authority, gently guide her on how to be supportive of childhood development. If you don't... just know that you weren't in the wrong.
  • rybpyjama Teaching this kid they don't have to ignore their own needs and can advocate, and they have an ally who respects them and is taking cues from them is honestly the more important lesson so I think you're good.
  • How many kids are out there having issues with hand sanitiser to the point of being stressed out/anxiety or having a meltdown just to be 'difficult'? Very few. I suspect you have a good idea of the difference between a kid just complaining vs a sensory issue, and even if not- is this the mountain that any educator really wants to be taking a stand on?
  • International-Eye676 OP When she first expressed having issues with the sanitizer, her reaction was more similar to a panic attack than a meltdown, which is what solidified my reasoning that she was in sensory overload
  • CaptainSeapants17 NTA. Some people, especially when it comes to taking care of kids, just believe you shouldn't change ANYTHING to make a kid more comfortable. She's not your boss, she can't police your actions. I'm glad the kids have someone empathetic and kind like you caring for them.
  • International-Eye676 OP Aww, this really means a lot! I'm typically only with this particular group a couple times a week when another coworker of ours has her college classes, so I really want to put extra effort into building relationships with the kiddos, which is my favorite part about working with kids (I'm also a History Education major, so I like to call my current kiddos my practice babies)
  • Loud_Confidence2956 NTA It's hand sanitizer. Your coworker is making mountains out of mole hills. You teach kids that they can't always get what they want by teaching them how to handle disappointment and regulate themselves. That's a skill for managing things outside of your control. What goes on someone's body should be well within their control.
  • International-Eye676 OP Exactly, since with something like hand sanitizer, there are several different kinds out there to choose from. There's also the option to just wash your hands in the bathroom (something this kiddo is also fine with)
  • Latranis You're not "biased." You're empathetic. Your coworker needs to learn empathy. I guarantee that girl will remember the teacher that saw her aversion to something and helped her with it.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article