Brother becomes legal guardian of his little sister and raises her as his own, his wife demands he kick sister out when she turns 18: ‘She's a burden on us’

Author image for Bar Mor Hazut
Bar Mor Hazut • Senior Editor
Nov 26, 2025 6:00 PM EST

Siblings who go through a tough childhood together and come out stronger on the other side tend to be overly protective of each other. They grew up in the same household, and they understand each other better than anyone else. It shouldn't surprise anyone that they would do anything for each other.

That is exactly how the older brother in the story below feels towards his little sister. He has been raising her since she was 8 years old, for his entire twenties. He has become a father figure for her, and he loves her just as such. So when his baby sister turned 18 and his wife started asking questions about her moving out, the brother became protective. Why would he ever want to kick his sister out, and why would his wife, who does nothing to contribute to the household, demand such a thing? 

This conversation quickly led to a full argument between the wife and husband, who couldn't see eye to eye when it comes to the teenager living with them.

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement

  • Should the older brother push his little sister out of the nest, or should he let her have this safe space for as long as she needs?

    Keep scrolling to read the full story.

  • 01

    AITA for refusing to kick my sister out the house?

    Hey everyone. I'm 30M and married to my wife 29F. After my mom passed away 10 years ago, i took guardianship of my younger sister let's call her mya who's 18F.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 02
    Young girl hugging older man from behind
    via A. C.

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 03
    She's like my daughter, and i love her to d th, she's my baby. Once our mom d ed, everything went downhill.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 04
    We ended up having to leave our apartment, and our dad wasn't in the picture either.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 05
    It was just me and her, and we've been together through the thick and thin. I worked my ass off, just to keep us afloat.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 06
    I'd work a day job at walmart, and at night i'd put her to sleep and then go deliver pizzas.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 07
    It was rough, trying to take care of myself and my sister but i always made it work.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 08
    Whenever i was able to have downtime, i'd take online community college classes in accounting so we could have a better life.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 09
    I studied accounting, got my associates and then became an accounting clerk. Afterwards i was able to switch positions and landed a better paying role at $70K which changed our lives.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 10
    I met my wife through a mutual friend, and we ended up getting married and we've been married for a few years now.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 11
    My sister has now turned 18. In the morning when my little sister went to school, i'm at the kitchen table drinking my coffee.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 12
    My wife comes up to me and says "babe, i want to talk to you about something important".
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 13
    I said "go for it". She said "Don't get mad at me, for saying this but is mya gonna leave the house now that she's 18?
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 14
    do you want me to kick her out?". I coughed for a second, because i was shocked.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 15
    I told her to repeat what she said. She says "i mean she's 18 now you know, and it's like how long is she gonna stay with us?
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 16
    are you gonna kick her out or what or do i have to do it?". I then said "what the fuck?
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 17
    why would i kick out my own sister out of my house?". She said "I don't know!
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 18
    I mean i just thought that she can finally leave us alone you know, get her own place isn't she bit of a burden don't you think?".
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 19
    I told my wife "Look, i don't know how you feel about Mya. But the last time i checked, i'm the one who pays the bills around here not you.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 20
    I'm the one who pays for you, the mortgage, the food, the insurance, the bills everything.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 21
    I don't think you should be telling me who i kick out. As long as i'm alive, and i can provide mya can stay here as long as she wants.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 22
    I don't care what you think, she's my sister. That thought never even struck my head, to kick my own baby out.".
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 23
    My wife then says "Jesus christ, you want to do everything for her, you want to pay for her college tuition, you want to pay for her shopping trips, you want to pay for her food she's a fucking burden on us can't you see?!".
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 24
    Guardianship Papers with Gavel on Desk
    via Kamitana_studio

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 25
    I told her "Yeah, when you start paying the bills here, then you can talk but for now, b t out".
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 26
    My wife then walked away. (Yes i was disrespectful here i apologize but i can't stand it if someone says anything against Mya) I always want to give my sister a better life then i had as a kid, and never want her to feel any void of anything.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 27
    I'm going to be paying for college soon, once she starts, i've given her a car, money for anything she needs, and i'll be taking care of all her college expenses along with the scholarships she received as well.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 28
    I don't want to kick my sister out at all and we live a comfortable life, my wife is a stay at home wife, she's never worked a job, didn't go to uni/college nothing.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 29
    She just lived with her parents till we got married. AITA? EDIT: Everyone is asking me why doesn't my wife work.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 30
    She never really wanted to work to be honest, my wife is indian-american. Her mom and dad were both wealthy and my wife just wanted to be a stay at home wife.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 31
    Even my mother in law never worked, neither does any of the females in her family.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 32
    I have tried telling my wife before, you know she should get some skills. Whether it's college, or certificates/or courses, something that way it ensures she can manage and take care of herself god forbid something happens.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 33
    I'll pay for it. I told her she can work any job even if she doesn't want to get any skills.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 34
    But she chooses not to, so it is what it is. I don't know if it's the culture for her, or whatever it may be.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 35
    But i came to terms with that ages ago.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 36
    gonzotek77 I find hard to believe you never saw any red flag.i would ask your sister, how your wife treats her when ur not home
    via gonzotek77
  • 37
    OP Defiant-Conflict-366 So actually my wife, and my sister get along quite well. Even when i'm not at home, they talk all the time, watch tv shows together they'll even go out together which i adored. which is why i'm a bit shocked this is coming now.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 38
    Bearliz NTA. My son was married to one like that. Someone took care of her her whole life. She said when the kids turn 18 they are out that same day. They divorced for that and her infidelity.
    via Bearliz
  • 39
    Vixen TheoryIIII NTA. You're an amazing brother and it clearly shows you want the best for your sister. Your wife should learn how to accommodate her
    via VixenTheoryIIII
  • 40
    OP Defiant-Conflict-366 thank you.
    via Defiant-Conflict-366
  • 41
    One-Revolution-9670 NTA, but you sure married one.
    via One-Revolution-9670
  • 42
    NotSorry2019 NTA. Time to boot the freeloading wife out before you have children with her. You married poorly.
    via NotSorry2019

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama aita guardian kids brother mother siblings wife parenting husband family sister women parents children Father
Scroll Down For The Next Article