Woman’s sister demands she apologize to her 28-year-old boyfriend, who gets offended when asked what he does for work and lectures his way out of answering: ‘Turns out he’s unemployed by choice and lives off his grandparents’ rental income’

Advertisement
  • My sister wants me to apologize to her new boyfriend because he ‘felt judged’ when I asked what he does for work

    A man sits on a beige couch, mid-rant, one hand on his forehead and the other out in exasperation. With a quote: "It's not depth, it's insecurity."
  • Advertisement
  • My sister (25F) brought her new boyfriend (28M) to a family dinner. He seemed nice enough, so I asked a normal getting-to-know-you question: "What do you do for work?" He got weirdly defensive and said, "I don't define myself by capitalism." I laughed because I genuinely thought he was joking, but he wasn't.
  • Later that night, my sister called me furious. Her boyfriend told her he felt "interrogated" and "judged" by me, and that my question was "classist." I asked my sister what he actually does for work, and she said he "prefers not to label his lifestyle." Turns out he's unemployed by choice and lives off his grandparents' rental income.
  • Now she wants me to apologize to him for "making assumptions about his path." I told her that asking what someone does for work isn't an interrogation, it's literally the most basic small-talk question on the planet.
  • Advertisement
  • A man lounges on a gray sofa, slouched back with one hand to his forehead and a weary expression. He holds a glass of water loosely in his other hand, looking drained or overwhelmed.
  • She says I'm "closed- minded" and that not everyone "subscribes to the grind." I'm starting to suspect she's dating a guy who uses philosophy to avoid responsibility.
  • My hot take: If someone can't answer a simple question without spiraling into a TED Talk, it's not depth, it's insecurity.
  • Advertisement
  • Much-Maintenance-827 He's not enlightened, he's unemployed with vocabulary. Keep your boundaries and let your sister enjoy her 'philosopher.' It'll wear off.
  • Ricco7716 You successfully managed to garner a lot of useful information from 1 basic getting to know you question. The main take is that your sister's new boyfriend is a bellend. Please don't apologise
  • Fair_Way3016 Lolll. Sounds like someone is very insecure about being unemployed. I bet that if He said he was unemployed right away, you wouldn't have judged him and moved on. So no, you really don't owe him an apology. But if you want to say something to keep the peace, (Although its not ur job amd its really fine if you dont) you could say exactly what I said. "Hey, yeah I'm sorry I made you feel judged. But I really dont judge you for being unemployed. In the future maybe just say that, inste
  • Advertisement
  • Top-Bit85 This one actually made me snort out loud. What did your parents think of her philosopher?
  • Cereaza She's being a pick me, and he's an unemployed loser. His opinion should mean nothing to you.
  • VileBrute Unemployed by choice.... Get tf out of here. What a great man for any woman she should drop him quick. Will be a one way relationship and you are right, full on insecure and ashamed of himself. You did nothing wrong.
  • Advertisement
  • Bored-Turnip So he's an unemployed mooching bum, most likely waiting for his grandparents to die so he can inherit their assets and pretend like he's built wealth from nothing. If he was not embarrassed by his lifestyle, he would have had no issues saying that he does nothing and let's other pay his way. Sounds to me like he wants to be a socialite without the income or wealth.
  • Laughing_Dragon_77 Tell your sister that he should feel judged, because a fair amount of internet strangers are very definitely judging. ETA: that includes me. I'm judging.
  • lanlan531 "I don't define myself by capitalism". This one actually made me audibly release air out of my nose, that's a crazy response haha
  • Advertisement
  • DJMemphis84 My hot take bot. =

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article