Homeowner refuses to let her homeless 31-year-old brother move into her house after he trashed it and refused to pay bills the first time he lived there: 'I can't handle that stress and damage again.'

Author image for Emmy Pratt
Emmy Pratt • Writer and Editor
Dec 25, 2025 8:00 PM EST

You can only give someone the benefit of the doubt so many times.

If you are a kind-hearted individual, it can be easy to find yourself getting taken advantage of by family members and friends who will walk over anyone to get what they want. You might see the best in everyone, and never think that someone you've known and loved for decades upon decades would betray you by trashing the house you let them live in for free when they're going through a difficult period of their life. Unfortunately, you can't always predict when somebody will take advantage of you, so you have to be the one to protect yourself first. 

If you've been burned once, you're much less likely to be burned again. If someone lets a drifter friend of theirs sleep on their couch for 6 months and discovers that they've been stealing money from them the entire duration of their stay, there's a good chance they won't let anyone else stay over at their house for a prolonged period of time like that ever again. They might trust their college-student sister or their chronically employed cousin more than they trust their "friend," but they know that if they make the same mistake twice, it will be unequivocally their fault this time. 

Even if you know that someone cannot be trusted to live in your home rent-free without trashing the house and making the house's residents' lives miserable, it can be challenging to say no to someone who is desperately begging for help that you aren't going to give to them. 

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement

  • Some family members pressure others to take on the financial and emotional burden of the family's bad seeds. They aren't self-sacrificing enough to do it themselves, so they make sure to pack on the guilt as much as they possibly can. The sister in this story has "helped" her brother during times of woe before, and he made sure she'd never do it again. Now that he's pleading with her to help him, the rest of the family is pressuring her to give him a second chance. Here's to hoping they'll be around to help him for the third and fourth chances. 

  • 01
    A house with a yard and garbage
    via Bruno Guerrero

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 02

    Am I the bad guy for refusing to let my homeless brother move back in after he trashed my house last time?

    I (29F) own a small house I worked my ass off to buy and fix up. My brother (31M) has always been a total mess with jobs and life in general. Last year he begged to stay with me just a couple months, because he'd landed a good job right
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 03
    here in our state, super close to my house. He swore he'd save up quick and move out on his own. I said yes but set clear rules: pay some bills, clean up, no parties, stick to the job. He never paid anything, trashed the place, had loud friends over
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 04
    all hours, borrowed my car without asking, and let his secret dog pee everywhere including my new rug. He ended up losing that job anyway, and after months of hell, I kicked him out. Now he's homeless again, but he says
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 05
    Person in black jacket and yellow helmet riding pink kick scooter on sidewalk during daytime
    via Manny Becerra

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 06
    he's got another job lined up in the exact same area and is crying that he needs a place to crash while he "gets stable." Swears he's changed and will follow rules this time. I said no I can't handle that stress and damage again. He called me heartless. Aunt and cousins are
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 07
    guilting me hard about family coming first and second chances. My friends say I'm right to protect my home and sanity.
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 08
    Three colleagues having conversation on the break
    via Getty Images (Unsplash+)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 09
    That_Theme_5283 NTA. He's just going to repeat his behavior. If your aunts and cousins are so worried they can house him themselves.
    via u/That_Theme_5283
  • 10
    OP Successful-Sun-8226 I gave them this response.
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 11
    MistressofaDM You don't owe him a second chance just because he is family. Your aunt and cousins are welcomed to help him if they feel so strongly about him deserving the help.
    via u/MistressofaDM
  • 12
    OP Successful-Sun-8226 You're the best. Honestly, hearing you say I'm doing the right thing makes me feel so much less guilty about standing my ground.
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 13
    omcta2212 NTA why don't the rest of your family house him or cosign/put the deposit for a flat for him if he's changed.
    via u/omcta2212
  • 14
    OP Successful-Sun-8226 Exactly.
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 15
    No-Mushroom1485 NTA! Your home and house is you're little heaven, if they cant respect that then let peace be thicker than blood! Also it's not your fault bro's life is messed up
    via u/No-Mushroom1485
  • 16
    OP Successful-Sun-8226 I needed to hear that today,thank you. It's hard when family keeps pushing, but I know I have to protect what I've worked so hard for.
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 17
    ashlar9248 Nta. Gotta love family taking advantage of family.
    via u/ashlar9248
  • 18
    OP Successful-Sun-8226 That's really hard, and I feel for him, but it's not my responsibility to solve his housing problem at the cost of my own stability.
    via u/Successful-Sun-8226
  • 19
    Gingereej1t "Oh hey Aunts and Cousins, thank you! I'll let my brother know that you're gonna let him live with you. Good luck!" NTA
    via u/Gingereej1t
  • 20
    NTA OldGuto Pretty clear he doesn't really respect you: >I said yes but set clear rules: pay some bills, clean up, no parties, stick to the job. He never paid anything, trashed the place, had loud friends over all hours, borrowed my car without asking, and let his secret dog pee everywhere including my new rug. So he's homeless again, I wonder why? As for the aunt and cousins, why don't they take him in? Heck even offer to help him move into their places.
    via u/OldGuto
  • 21
    A2AdjectivesAndANoun NTA the family members that think he's so changed can put him up in their house or a short term rental or long term hotel or something. He hasn't done anything to make amends, so why should you believe he's changed? Side note, SECRET DOG??? | would lose it if someone staying with me brought in a dog without my permission.
    via u/A2AdjectivesAndANoun
  • 22
    mnfanjk Once? Shame on him. Twice? Shame on you. A home is a haven. People with a history of abusing it? Don't get let in. Your family who call you heartless can put him up. NTA.
    via u/mnfanjk
  • 23
    singlefulla Tell your aunt and cousins to house him till he gets straight
    via u/singlefulla

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

landlord brother house homeowner homeless aunt bills family sister cousins
Scroll Down For The Next Article