18-year-old steals his childhood doll from his 3-year-old sister after discovering his cousin had stolen it from him and given it to his sister: 'I really wanted her back.'

Author image for Emmy Pratt
Emmy Pratt • Writer and Editor
Jan 10, 2026 8:00 AM EST

He might be the rightful owner of the doll, but his sister will not understand.

If you've ever been lucky enough to own an American Girl Doll, you know that it's not something to be taken lightly. Those dolls have been at least $100 since the 20th century, and they're not the kind of toys that you should just give to a toddler to use as they wish. American Girl Dolls have names and identities! They are for a sensitive older child who can understand that Felicity isn't just a girl with red hair and green eyes…she's a warrior for animals who is willing to break the law to keep them safe. If a child can't grasp the gravity of Julie's parents divorce, then they aren't old enough to play with American Girl Dolls. 

Many families break the recommendation that their kids shouldn't get an American Girl Doll until their 8 years old or older. They are either rich enough to buy a brand new Samantha doll when their youngest "accidentally" rips her arms off, or they're careless enough not to care when she gets torn to shreds. There is literally an American Girl Doll Hospital for the expressed purpose of repairing dolls who got in the hands of irresponsible kids who couldn't properly take care of them. The most responsible doll collectors never want to get to the place where their doll has to go to such an institution. 

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • A little girl sleeping on a bed with a stuffed animal
    via Getty Images (Unsplash+)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • The teenager in this story was upset when he discovered his treasured American Girl Doll was taken by his cousin to give to his toddler sister. He decided to take the doll back from her, because it wasn't his cousin's to give away in the first place, but now he's wondering whether that was the right choice.

  • Am I the bad guy for taking a doll from my 3 year old sister?

    So tonight I(18M) found out that the American girl doll that I have had since i was about 8 was stolen by my slightly younger cousin a few years ago and the way i found this out was bc he gave her to my baby sister (3F).
    via u/foxboy6646
  • I missed the doll (Blair) for many years and I had tried to look for her before but when I couldn't find her i assumed my granny had thrown her out or put her away somewhere. Now that she's back my little sister has been
    via u/foxboy6646
  • dragging her and throwing her by the hair and it really upset me to the point of tears. I picked her up after she had thrown her down and left her there for a while and began
    via u/foxboy6646
  • A close up of a person with curly hair
    via Andrej Lišakov

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • finger combing her curls back. out. when my little sister noticed she ripped her out of my hands by a small piece of her hair pulling some of it out. And I tried telling her how important the doll was to me and how I really
    via u/foxboy6646
  • wanted her back and i promised i would share her when she got a bit older and could be gentle with her but that she ment a lot to me. And at that point my mom stepped in telling me to just let her have the doll bc she didn't
    via u/foxboy6646
  • know it was mine when she gave it to her. So I just left, I went outside and I sat in my car to calm down but when I went back in they were both asleep and I took Blair and I feel kind of guilty but I'm scared
    via u/foxboy6646
  • of her getting more messed up and idk what to do.
    via u/foxboy6646
  • New_Part91 I would keep her hidden. A three year-old is too young for an American girl doll anyway, they are quality dolls. It should be handled with care. If you take care of it, you may want to pass it down to your own child someday.
    via u/New_Part91
  • OP foxboy6646 That was my plan before she went missing was to pass her down to my own kid. Thank you!
    via u/foxboy6646
  • WVildandWVonderful They're also heavy and not soft. OP, why don't you get your sis a soft, colorful, fun-looking doll to play with in the meantime? NTA
    via u/WVildandWVonderful
  • A little girl sitting on the floor holding a doll
    via Yunus Tuğ (Unsplash+)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • OP foxboy6646 I definitely will! I think I also want to find one that looks more like her since she doesn't have any that resemble her yet. Thank you!
    via u/foxboy6646
  • floofelina NAH. Buy two less meaningful ones from Target and play dolls with your little sister. That's what'll make it meaningful to her.
    via u/floofelina
  • OP foxboy6646 I definitely like this idea especially bc her birthday is coming up soon and I think it'd be really cool to get her a doll that looks like her with a bunch of accessories that she could enjoy until she's ready for a more expensive doll. Thank you!
    via u/foxboy6646
  • Professional-Scar628 NTA the original owner gets stolen items back even when the thief gives them away. That's the danger in buying something that might be stolen. Or getting it gifted to you. However, a 3 year old isn't going to understand this and is simply going to be upset that their toy was taken away. I propose that you take the doll back, but buy your sister a new toy as a replacement. The excitement of a new toy (and maybe some ice cream ③) should help mitigate the sadness from having th
    via u/Professional-Scar628
  • OP foxboy6646 Thank you so much! She's in surprisingly good condition and I'm planning on stopping my Walmart tomorrow afternoon to find her a my life doll that she can play with without worrying about it getting messed up or anything!
    via u/foxboy6646
  • floofelina I would just get two now and not let it build up to an ongoing conflict because you'll definitely lose that one. She's more likely to forget the quicker she gets a substitute.
    via u/floofelina
  • OP foxboy6646 Yes absolutely!
    via u/foxboy6646
  • RequirementQuirky468 These days American Girl has a toddler-safe version called Bitty Baby. That'd probably be a good choice as far as being able to say "But look Mom, I bought her the baby-safe doll from the same company, so it's a reasonable replacement!" and keep the focus on giving her something appropriate instead of taking away the good doll and giving her a crappy doll.
    via u/RequirementQuirky468
  • OP foxboy6646 I really wish I could afford that but a new American girl anything is a bit out of my budget for right now plus she's a bit destructive with all her toys right now so something cheep that's ok to mess up may be preferable to an expensive doll that she doesn't understand the value of. Thank you so much for the suggestion tho!
    via u/foxboy6646
  • Company|||5169 I'd be having a conversation with that cousin about what he did and the fact that he couldn't even be bothered to return it to you after the theft but instead gave to your sister.
    via u/CompanyIII5169
  • OP foxboy6646 Yeah I know I will. I've had to have conversations in the past about him taking things that were mine but Blair was the most expensive and the only thing that wasn't returned until now. Honestly I'm not that mad at him since he was a kid when he took her and he may not have even realized he still had her until he gave her to my little sister
    via u/foxboy6646
  • Eternalthursday1976 You are not an asshole but you can't just take a gift that was given to her without replacing it. She's not going to understand your explanation, just that now you stole her present from someone else. Target or Walmart brands are both good replacements for it
    via u/Eternalthursday1976
  • OP foxboy6646 Yes thank you based on some of the other responses I plan on putting her back in the morning before she wakes up and getting her a replacement to hopefully trade with her after I get out of school tomorrow
    via u/foxboy6646
  • alligatorsgorawr NTA I have my two American Girl dolls from when I was a kid (I saved up to buy them myself) and accessories. I have a two year old and a five year old, I would definitely not allow either one of my kids to play with them until they show they are responsible enough to treat them well, and appreciate their value. Have you seen the knockoff ones at Walmart and Target? At that age she's not going to care as long as she has a doll. I'd get a knockoff one for your sister, and securely
    via u/alligatorsgorawr
  • OP foxboy6646 Im still living at home for a few months but im not so worried about her going missing again as my cousin was going through a phase of taking everything around the time she went missing so i really dont think that it was anything malicious. And i plan on getting her a my life doll tomorrow. Thank you so much!
    via u/foxboy6646
  • Competitive_Test6697 INFO: whats the condition of the doll after the cousin had it for a few years? Is it really worth crying over? Seems a bit weird. (Never heard of these dolls and from UK)
    via u/Competitive_Test6697
  • OP foxboy6646 She was actually in really good condition for all she's been through other than some tangles in her hair. American girl dolls are very expensive and coming from a lower income household going to get her was a special treat with my grandparents and I feel weirdly protective over her bc of that.
    via u/foxboy6646

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

stealing toddler brother teenagers siblings doll family sister cousins playing
Scroll Down For The Next Article