Employee accidentally receives coworker's $6k bonus, wonders whether they should report it or not: 'It stings but this money was never yours'

Author image for JR Atkinson
JR Atkinson • Writer and Editor
Jun 12, 2026 9:00 PM EDT

Have you ever accidentally received something you were supposed to?

Sometimes you end up in a situation that you wish you hadn't, and there is nothing you can do about it. You've found yourself in a pickle, and there's not a lot you can do to get out of it. The person in this story, who was shared to the work subreddit, was in one of those particular situations. They knew that something was wrong, but they didn't know what they could do to fix it. When a mistake works out in your favor, is it on you to be the one to fix it? Or should the person who made the mistake have to be the one to rectify it? The employee here was caught in that world, where they got an unexpected windfall, and then realized that they probably shouldn't have. But when you randomly get a truckload of money, should you have to let it go just because someone else messed up? What if the money didn't belong to you in the first place? For a lot of us, $6k is a lot of money. For this worker, it was the difference between paying off a credit card bill and continuing to accumulate debt. But the problem was, he wasn't sure if the money actually belonged to him or not. After doing some digging, they realized that they probably didn't come into the money honestly. If something seems like it's too good to be true, it probably is. But that's easier said than done. When you receive money that feels like it will change your life, then you probably want to hold onto it with everything you've got. The employee in this story certainly did. But the longer they thought about it, the more they knew that they should probably let it go. But letting it go was not going to be as easy as it seemed. Keep scrolling to see what happened here and see what you think about it.

Advertisement
  • Cheezburger Image 10638176768
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    An employee looks at his computer, confused

  • They paid me a six grand bonus that was meant for a colleague on long term leave.

    i got my year end bonus on tuesday and im now realising it wasnt actually meant for me. im a mid level finance analyst, second year at this company, and the bonus letter said the company had a good year, my
    via UmpireAdvanced8376
  • work has been recognised, and the figure on the bottom was just over six grand. i was expecting about fifteen hundred quid. i assumed the company had genuinely had a better year than expected and that i was being recognised for picking up the work of a colleague whos been on sabbatical for the last six
    via UmpireAdvanced8376
  • months. i moved most of it straight onto a credit card balance ive been chipping away at for a year and a half. that card is now sat at zero for the first time since i moved out of my parents place.
    via UmpireAdvanced8376
  • today i was going through the payslip out of curiosity because the breakdown wasnt fully itemised in the original email. the bonus reference at the bottom of the line item shows a different employee number to mine. ive worked out whose number it is. its the colleague on sabbatical. he and i have very similar names, same first initial, same first three letters of the surname. someone in payroll has clearly fat fingered a row in a spreadsheet. hes back at his desk in five weeks.
    via UmpireAdvanced8376
  • i have three options that i can see and they all feel terrible in different ways. one, tell payroll today, get the money clawed back, sit at my desk monday morning with a fresh credit card balance on my actual real card. two, say nothing, hope payroll catches it themselves before he returns and i can act surprised. three, say nothing, hope nobody catches it at all, live with the fact that ive technically stolen six grand from a colleague who has no idea any of this happened.
    via UmpireAdvanced8376
  • i know option one is the right answer, the issue is i actually need that money and i emptied a card with it that i was carrying for legitimate reasons not nights out. and the colleague isnt struggling, hes on a paid sabbatical to do a masters. has anyone been in this with a clearer head than me right now.
    via UmpireAdvanced8376

  • Commenters gave their takes and opinions.

    New_Revolution_9226 at six grand this isnt a quiet error you can ride out, payroll does a year end audit and they will find it, get ahead of it on monday.
    via New_Revolution_9226
  • Cheezburger Image 10638178304
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    A man looks at his computer screen, confused

  • JuggernautFit7248 go with opton one, tell payroll monday, the card going back in the red will sting but its better than months of dread.
    via JuggernautFit7248
  • Last_Life_1983 Option one. It stings but this money was never yours. And it's not 20 bucks that might get rounded up and not discovered. It's thousands. It will be noticed at some point. And even if it won't - will it be worth to live with this knowledge? Living in fear all this time, knowing the mistake might be
    via Last_Life_1983
  • discovered? I assume you still got some bonus too? Or was it only your colleague on sabbatical and you really got nothing?
    via Last_Life_1983
  • RevenueEmbarrassed97 my friend had this happen with a maternity top up that wasnt hers, she flagged it and they let her keep half as goodwill, the worst case is rarely as bad as you think.
    via RevenueEmbarrassed97
  • BeautifulChaosEnergy Ask if they can deduct it in instalments from future pay cheques? Figure out what you can comfortably "lose" per cheque and suggest that They may do it, they may take a bigger chunk each cheque, or they may expect you to pay it back in full by end of week
    via RevenueEmbarrassed97
  • rockyroad55 You don't know what the other colleague is going through. Maybe they need the money for family or other reasons. The correct answer is to tell payroll about it. Is it worth losing your job over this?
    via rockyroad55
  • purplelilac701 You are a kind soul and you know you need to let payroll know asap.
    via purplelilac701
  • Current-Show2460 What are the legal consequences in your country/your state for not returning this money? In some jurisdictions, this type of error is the employer's fault, and the employee doesn't have to claw it back. If no legal obligation to return, then enjoy it
    via Current-Show2460
  • Economy_Fan_8520 Meh just say do nothing. If it ever comes up just say you never noticed any employee reference at the bottom You just assumed you were rewarded for your hard work / company performance
    via Economy_Fan_8520
  • TeeJayReddits "Dear HR, Thank you so much for the generous bonus. It really makes me feel like you've noticed and appreciated the extra work that I've been putting in while blank is out."
    via TeeJayReddits
  • It gets the ball rolling on their end when they realize the error, but also puts them in a position where they might realize you deserve. that bonus. Your coworker may be entitled to it, but the company may be willing to pay it out twice.
    via TeeJayReddits

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

boss antiwork workplace-stories toxic-workplace job bosses work working reddit thread bad bosses
Scroll Down For The Next Article