Man skips anniversary dinner for a baseball game and lies to his fiancée, sibling reveals the truth, now the wedding is on hold: 'She deserved to know'

Author image for Celeste Mello
Celeste Mello • Writer and Editor
Jul 7, 2026 12:00 PM EDT

Missing an anniversary dinner is not great, but lying about why you missed it only makes everything worse. And sometimes, lies can reveal a much bigger problem.

In this story, the groom-to-be told his fiancée that he missed their anniversary dinner because he had been called into work. That would be a bit disappointing, but understandable, because work emergencies happen. Some responsibilities cannot be avoided, and his fiancée perfectly understood that. The problem was that it wasn't true. 

The worst part is that this man dragged his sister into his lie by asking her not to say a word about it because telling the truth would "only make things worse". And sure, a baseball game doesn't sound like an obligation or an emergency, or anything unavoidable, so of course he wouldn't want to tell his fiancée that version of events. In his mind, it was apparently better to hide the fact that he just didn't want to celebrate their anniversary that day. It seems that discussing the possibility of moving the anniversary dinner was not an option for him. "Yes, it's definitely better to lie about this and never communicate honestly with my partner." I don't understand what goes on inside the mind of some guys. 

Anyway, his fiancée seemed to believe this version of events so much that she actually praised him for caring about his job. And that was the moment the sister couldn't keep her mouth shut anymore. She had to let her know the truth.  

Advertisement
  • This model depicts a couple having a tense argument at home, representing the confrontation when the fiancée discovers her partner's lie about their anniversary dinner.
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    This model depicts a couple having a tense argument at home, representing the confrontation when the fiancée discovers her partner's lie about their anniversary dinner.

  • AITA for telling my brother’s fiancée why he really missed their anniversary

    My brother told his fiancée he missed their anniversary dinner because he got called into work.
    via bumbl3beee3
  • I knew that wasn't true because he was with me at a baseball game.
    via bumbl3beee3
  • He begged me not to say anything because he'd already lied and "it would only make things worse."
    via bumbl3beee3
  • A crowded baseball stadium at dusk, showing the game a man attended instead of his anniversary dinner.
    via Unsplash+ (Jimmy Conover)

    This model represents a crowded baseball stadium at dusk, showing the game a man attended instead of his anniversary dinner.

  • A few days later, his fiancée was talking about how lucky she was to have someone who cared so much about his job, and I
    via bumbl3beee3
  • couldn't keep my mouth shut. I told her where he actually was.
    via bumbl3beee3
  • A close-up of a wedding ring, symbolizing an engagement put on hold after a fiancée discovers the truth.
    via Unsplash+ (Alexander Mass)

    A close-up of a wedding ring, symbolizing an engagement put on hold after a fiancée discovers the truth.

  • She immediately left, and now their wedding is on hold.
    via bumbl3beee3
  • My brother says I ruined his relationship over "one stupid lie," and my parents
    via bumbl3beee3
  • think I should've stayed out of it because it wasn't my business.
    via bumbl3beee3
  • I think she deserved to know she was being lied to. AITA?
    via bumbl3beee3
  • Edit: To clarify, my brother invited me to the game and I was unaware of their anniversary.
    via bumbl3beee3
  • An illustrative image of a couple on a date at an elegant restaurant, representing the anniversary dinner a fiancée expected to share with her partner.
    via Unsplash+ (Kateryna Hliznitsova)

    An illustrative image of a couple on a date at an elegant restaurant, representing the anniversary dinner a fiancée expected to share with her partner.

  • WrittenInTheStars NTA. What the f is going on in this sub. "Not your business" he literally made it your business when he used you in his coverup.
    via WrittenIntheStars
  • OneMinuteSewing yup, don't lie in front of me and make me part of that lie without my consent.
    via rustyglow
  • Raccoonsr29 NTA. A lot of really terrible spouses in this comment section, wow. This is not a small or justifiable lie.
    via Raccoonsr29
  • 1Rainbow Unicorn NTA. She deserved to know. Thank you for telling her
    via 1RainbowUnicorn
  • DangerousLack NTA, and anyone saying YTA probably doesn't have a healthy relationship. Edit to add: whoa whoa wait your brother invited you to the game?! | thought it was the other way around. Sorry OP but your brother suuuuucks.
    via DangerousLack
  • rustyglow Fr the fact that OP to the game and then blamed his job for missing the anniversary is next level manipulation... He didn't just lie he actively set the trap and then made OP the villain for pointing it out
    via rustyglow

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama anniversary brother siblings relationship-drama sister fiancee
Scroll Down For The Next Article