Animal Comedy Newsletter

Entitled Mother-In-Law Tries To Butt Into Relationship, Reddit Hilarity Ensues

Advertisement
  • 1

    This Whole Thing Smells Fishy

    Font - My husband and I got a puppy, Scout, a few weeks ago. He is now 12 weeks. For background: I have a 2-year-old medical and psychiatric alert service dog. I got him before my partner and I got married, and he was fully supportive of my and my dog (Toby) and is a great caretaker of him. I've always wanted two dogs and we've both always wanted kids. After a lot of discussion and spreadsheets, we decided to get a second dog (to be a friend for our current dog and to help him learn how to "shar

    We understand why OP is really trying hard to be kind to her MIL and not jump on everything she says, but we wouldn't have taken that passing comment as such a passing comment. After everything else you're about to learn about this woman, it sounds like that would've been a serious comment nine times out of ten. 

  • Advertisement
  • 2

    Poor Scout

    Font - Fast forward two weeks to now. My husband took the comment from MIL as a great idea and has been pushing for us to look into giving Scout away to BIL to be trained as his service dog. The trainers did an aptitude and temperament test and Scout passed with flying colors. The only thing keeping Scout from being BIL's dog is me. Husband and I agreed to not make a final decision until we both totally agree. Husband's argument: We had such good luck finding a perfect puppy (full papered AKC go

    Obviously, the wife is upset. Obviously, the husband feels handcuffed. But, has anyone thought about what this means for poor, little Scout? He's just getting used to his new home, and now someone else is deciding whether he's going to work his entire life, or just get to be a normal dog. The whole thing is a bummer. 

  • 3

    Well, What's The Verdict?

    Font - My argument: I don't feel like we owe his parents our dog because their potential puppy failed his test. They could've started looking for a service dog for BIL before he graduated high school. MIL isn't on great terms with either of us (classic narcissist, regularly puts down husband publicly, makes nasty remarks about my siblings when we come visit, yelled at us at our own wedding for not doing things the way she wanted, etc), but keeps trying to sweet talk and guilt trip us into giving
  • 4

    Doesn't Make Sense To Us Either

    Font - teresajs 6 days ago Sultan of Sphincter [621] ΝΤΑ None of this makes sense to me. If your BIL is attending college in a month, your puppy wouldn't be a service dog by then. My understanding is that many service dogs are raised and initially trained by other people and then the dogs are matched to people who need the dog. From what I've seen on documentaries, there's no guarantee that one particular dog would train well for a specific disability, nor that it would be a good match for any p
  • Advertisement
  • 5

    She Had 18 Years!!!

    Font - ShamusMcGregor 6 days ago edited 6 days ago Partassipant [4] NTA... MIL has had 18 years to prepare for this day and it's not your problem to solve. And who the fuck does your MIL think she is? You can't just ask to have someone's dog. What kind of monster? For her to put you in that situation is just awful. Fuck her and your husband for even making you consider it. I would tell your husband the answer is unequivocally NO and end the discussion. It's also on him to deal with his mom. Take
  • 6

    They Did Research, MIL Did Not

    Font - Abbreviations Plus654 6 days ago Partassipant [1] NTA. While I understand your husband's POV, I also understand your POV. It really boils down to the fact that you two did your research and chose a dog that was going to fit well in YOUR family. It isn't your (or your husband's) fault that his parents did nothing to help their son until 8 weeks before college starts. That isn't fair to anyone-- your dog included. 248 Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow
  • 7

    Manipulate, Manipulate, Manipulate

    Rectangle - halvora 6 days ago Partassipant [4] NTA, and this is literally a coincidence. Don't be bought of by the "its not a coincidence" BS. Your family manipulated your husband and is trying to manipulate you. Its disgusting of your parents and your husband to ask you to part ways. Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 178
  • Advertisement
  • 8

    Is He Always Like This?

    Font - V VVetSpecimen - 6 days ago Asshole Enthusiast [5] NTA, and if I'm being real your husband is a real AH for suggesting you give a member of your family away. (O) Injoy 121 Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow JCBashBash 5 days ago Colo-rectal Surgeon [32] Yo, and allowing his mother to make decisions in their home. Like him going along with his mom and pushing his wife to just go along with what his family wants is off-putting Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 28
  • 9

    It's MILs Fault At The End Of The Day

    Font - Jermicdubya 6 days ago Partassipant [4] NTA. A lack of planning on their part does not constitute an emergency on yours. When you have children, will they expect you to give them up, too, because it will be easier for BIL than finding a wife and having kids of his own? Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 107 kombuched 5 days ago I was looking for this comment 11 Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow
  • 10

    He Sounds Atrocious

    Rectangle - drusilla14 6 days ago Partassipant [3] You are NTA but your husband is AH. How can he think about giving away "his" dog? If he wants to help his brother, then he can help him find another dog. Giving Scout to his brother is husband being too lazy to do this and trying to expedient at Scout's expense. Keep Scout and do NOT allow your husband to give him away. Ugh! Husband is such AH! Reply Give Award Share Report Save Follow 68

    For a weekly dose of animal-themed community challenges - Subscribe to our Newsletter!

    Can't get enough of ICanHasCheezburger? Find us on Instagram!

Tags

Next on Animal Comedy

Scroll down for the next article

Comments