'I did not feel comfortable handing him a lump sum of cash': 31-year-old demands sister give him half of $300k inheritance, rejects offer to work with her for $100k a year instead

Author image for Ally Perry
Ally Perry • Writer and Editor
Aug 25, 2025 9:00 PM EDT

Living in these times, where it feels increasingly difficult to achieve basic but costly life milestones like buying a house or starting a family, some people believe that their only hope for a modicum of financial stability is receiving some money when an older, richer relative passes away. Who inherits what within a family has always been an issue with the potential for drama, and it is only made more tense when there are people involved who feel like they really need the cash.

Ultimately, who gets what is down to the person who wrote the will. However, time and again it is proven that there are many individuals who have no issue in challenging that. The dilemma for the family members left in possession of some very attractive goods is whether they are willing to be generous or if they have a good reason to keep what they have been given to themselves.

Advertisement
  • 01
    a close up of an angry man clutching his neck
    via Pablo Merchán Montes (Unsplash+)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • For one woman, this issue became a pressing one when her brother expected that she would give him half of the significant amount that she had inherited from their grandmother. He had already received a smaller amount of money from the grandmother's trust.

    Taking into consideration that he did not have a good financial history and that she had had to engage in a legal battle to receive her money, the sister was not comfortable in immediate sharing. However, she did offer her unemployed brother a well-paid job with her company, as well as a fund he could use for special events.

    Although he originally agreed to this offer, he then rejected it and stopped speaking to her. She wanted to know if she had done something wrong.

  • 02

    Am I wrong for not giving my brother half of my inheritance and instead offering him a job and long-term financial support?

    My grandmother passed away several years ago. In her original trust, she left $25k to each of her four grandchildren, and the remaining $1.2M was split between her two sons. Two years before she d_d, she amended the trust and changed the distribution so that the $1.2M would instead be split between two of the grandchildren me and my cousin. The other two grandchildren (including my brother) were not included.
    via d0hardthings
  • 03
    After her death, it was discovered that the trustee was stealing money from the trust. I personally paid over $30k in legal fees to fight this in court and was able to recover $200k of the $400k that was unaccounted for. Once everything is finalized, I'll receive somewhere around $600k, and my cousin will receive the same.
    via d0hardthings
  • 04
    side profile of a woman sitting on a couch
    via Candice Picard

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • 05
    Here's where the conflict comes in: my brother believes he's entitled to half of my share. For context, he's 31, lives with my mom, does not currently have a job or career, and has already received his $25k gift from my grandmother's trust. He's had a history of poor choices in the past, he is now making better ones but still has a ways to go.
    via d0hardthings
  • 06
    I told him I did not feel comfortable just handing him a huge lump sum of cash right now. Instead, I offered him a plan: • He could come work for my business, and I'd pay him $100k a year (which is double what he's ever earned). • I'd set aside money in a ladder CD to remain liquid, so I could gift him funds for important life events (house down payment, wedding, kids' college, etc.).
    via d0hardthings
  • 07
    he's At first, he loved this idea. But now, apparently changed his mind, is unhappy with the arrangement, and has completely stopped speaking to me — and even to my son, his nephew, who had a close bond with him. - I feel like I made a very generous offer · giving him both an opportunity to build stability and also ensuring he'd still benefit from the inheritance long-term. But now I'm questioning if I'm the a hole for not just giving him what he wants. AITA?
    via d0hardthings
  • 08
    three twenty us dollar bills
    via Jason Hawke 🇨🇦 (Unsplash+)
  • 09

    The majority of commenters sided with her.

    Electrical_Fix_4340 NTA, you presented him with a golden egg and all he had to do was show up and work for it. He wants the easy handout to feel like he's living big after years of being down, but he'll burn through it and wind up where he is now. Most likely anyways
    via Electrical_Fix_4340
  • 10
    ConnectionRound3141 NTA Your grandmother effectively cut him out because she saw who he was. An entitled brat. Stop bending over backwards for this guy. You are doing so at the expense of your son. Put the money away for your son. Your brother will be a trash employee and you know it.
    via ConnectionRound3141
  • 11
    Just stop. Please just stop. This is not your responsibility. This is not your liability. Your brother is trying to manipulate you into giving him cash. Period. A leopard doesn't change its spots.
    via ConnectionRound3141
  • 12
    Impossible_Nebula_33 Don't give him anything times are tough these days if he thinks his too good for what you kindly offered him then he can go on about his business and you set yourself up for a nice retirement. And set your children up for generational wealth. NO GOOD DID GOES UNPUNISHED. Remember that before you roll out the red carpet for this lazy
    via Impossible_Nebula_33
  • 13
    Regular_Boot_3540 You made a very generous offer. Your brother probably resents being treated like an incompetent child, but if he examines his own past behavior, he'll understand why. $600,000 is nice but is finite, and you're wise to conserve it. NTA
    via Regular_Boot_3540
  • 14
    No_Jaguar67 Why subvert your grandmothers wishes? It's your money and you could do great things, supporting your deadbeat sounding brother probably isn't one of those things. The fact that he is balking at your offer shows why he got $25 grand, and should be proof enough that you shouldn't waste your time. NTA but be as wise as your grandmother thought you were.
    via No_Jaguar67
  • 15
    Outrageous-Arm 1945 NTA, he's made his intentions clear, he wants a handout
    via Outrageous-Arm1945
  • 16
    wasakootenayperson If your grandmother wanted him to have that $ she would have written that in her will. She had her reasons - trust that. Nta
    via wasakootenayperson
  • 17
    Jumpy-Speaker8517 If my brother offered me a job with a 100k salary I would take it and thank him for the opportunity as that is a lot for a salary your brother just wants money for nothing.
    via Jumpy-Speaker8517
  • 18
    grayblue_grrl "and has completely stopped speaking to me That's called the trash taking itself out. He doesn't want to work for the money or anything really. NTA
    via grayblue_grrl
  • 19
    muscularmatzoball Yta. You are giving yourself all of the power in this arrangement, without really deserving it. If your grandma wants to give you a fortune and him a pittance by comparison, that is her choice, but it is wrong. Yes, you might not think he is responsible, but that should be his choice to make with the money. If he spent it all and wanted your share, it'd be a different question, and you would be in the right, but you are being a controlling and entitled ah here.
    via muscularmatzoball
  • 20
    Popular_Aide_6790 Nta so wow he has to earn his money what a novel concept. The entitlement of this guy
    via Popular_Aide_6790
  • 21
    Free-Place-3930 NTA. Just make your life better and easier and cut him completely off.
    via Free-Place-3930
  • 22
    hatfieldmichael NTA. Stand your ground. You are being both smart and generous.
    via hatfieldmichael

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama inheritance family aita job brother siblings sister reddit thread Reddit money
Scroll Down For The Next Article