22-year-old parks worker quits on the spot after 21-year-old supervisor Noelle's remark: 'Micromanaging is not your job'

Advertisement
  • 01
    In forest setting, man in plaid shirt looks at woman in green sweater drinking coffee, while woman in yellow hat holds one arm in front of her and looks at man
  • 02
    1 (22m) had an altercation involving myself, another coworker (21) (let's call her Jane), and one of my supervisors (21). We'll call her Noelle. I worked at a
  • 03
    national park visitor center and we began to get really busy over the summer. Understandably, we were all heated and stressed due to the high volume of
  • 04
    visitors at the park, which was great for our store since we helped with donations for the park and park projects.
  • 05
    Small backstory; Jane and I clicked really fast after I got hired. We were both hired there recently (her about 2 months before me) and we always tried to make the job fun
  • 06
    throughout the day since it was a retail job for a small-ish bookstore in the visitor center. We would chat often, but never let it effect our work. Whenever we were
  • 07
    working on our own tasks (ex. stocking shelves, grabbing inventory from the back, cleaning, doing inventory) we would always split off if we were walking in the same
  • 08
    direction before resuming our individual tasks. A couple of times (separate instances a couple months apart), we were talking for a very
  • 09
    short amount of time before Noelle would walk over to us and say "You need to break this leash and stop distracting each other." in a very negative and
  • 10
    inappropriate tone. During these two instances, we were doing separate tasks where we happened to be close to each other. We weren't distracting each other from work and
  • 11
    we were making sure we were on top of our tasks. We were slightly upset but we let it slide. After the first incident, Noelle was acting strange.
  • 12
    Whenever me and Jane were together, she would not speak to us at all, or speak to us rudely. If it was Noelle and I without Jane (or Jane and Noelle), she would talk to me as if we
  • 13
    were best buds, while talking crap about the other person (or other employees under her). I was told by Jane and another coworker that they both had separate
  • 14
    issues with Noelle and reported her to HR. The director of HR said to talk to Noelle on their own and that HR didn't need to get involved. I'm sorry, isn't your job to talk
  • 15
    to an employee if someone brought up an issue with them? Especially if it's multiple instances from different people??
  • 16
    Now to the main tea, why I went about this situation the way I did. It was one of our busier days during the summer and I was pretty stressed
  • 17
    due to the volume of visitors as well as not being fully staffed. Jane, Noelle, and I all happened to be working that day. It was near the end of Jane's morning shift
  • 18
    and about halfway into my evening shift. Jane and I were in the back, each picking a task that had to be taken care of while chatting it up a little bit. Out of the blue,
  • 19
    as Noelle was talking with another supervisor, she came up to us and said, condescendingly, "You need to get back to work now and stop talking."
  • 20
    This was also in front of multiple colleagues. Jane and I paused in shock and just stared at her, confused. I told Noelle that we were finishing a
  • 21
    conversation and were about to head back on the floor. Jane and I went back out, visibly pissed. It affected the rest of our days negatively and we had a conversation
  • 22
    about how we should handle this since it was a third time it happened with no follow up conversations. We decided not to involve HR because it was a very minor
  • 23
    incident (in our opinion). So, I sent a group text with the three of us recapping what happened and that I wanted the three of us to talk about it.
  • 24
    I said that I personally felt degraded for being rudely shut down during a quick conversation in front of my peers. Noelle said that we would talk about it the next
  • 25
    time we all worked together. A few days pass and I come in to clock into work. Noelle walks passed me with her boss (our manager, 'John') and
  • 26
    says that her, him, and I were going to have a talk outside. I thought "Perfect, we can finally discuss this and put it behind us." As soon as we stepped outside, she asked
  • 27
    (again, condescendingly), "So, about your text message, do you have anything else to add?" I looked at her confused and asked what she meant. She said that
  • 28
    I seemed passionate about the situation, to which I responded "kind of" and that I thought the three of us could resolve it. I then told her that I didn't feel comfortable
  • 29
    discussing further unless Jane was present. Noelle then said that she had nothing to do with it. To which I responded that the three of us were involved in the
  • 30
    altercation. Noelle said "I'm not talking about that, I'm talking about the text you sent." I was surprised. I told her that if I came off harsh that it wasn't my intention. It was
  • 31
    out of genuine concern for me and my coworker and how we were being treated (it's crazy how someone's ego can take that big of a hit over a minor incident). She
  • 32
    responded with "I was just doing my job." Yeah, micromanaging is not your job. After that mix up, she jumped to the incident involving
  • 33
    her, Jane, and myself saying that we shouldn't have been talking. To which I responded that it was only for a couple minutes while we were staying on task. She
  • 34
    then moved on to topics completely irrelevant. She mentioned how I wasn't "showing enough passion in my work". We work in retail stocking shelves and
  • 35
    occasionally asking customers to donate to support the national park (which my donation numbers were really high for the summer). If that's "not being
  • 36
    passionate enough", I don't know what is. John wasn't much help as he just stood there listening as his employee was degrading another. I told them that I was done discussing
  • 37
    with them (mainly because I didn't want to cuss Noelle out) and that we could finish the conversation later. They said okay and we all went back inside.
  • 38
    About an hour later, Noelle comes up to me and says "Just so you know, I don't think you're a bad worker." Well, you were treating me like one. If someone can't control their
  • 39
    ego or emotions, talks bad about their employees behind their backs, and is on a constant power trip, they shouldn't be in a management position. I didn't say much because I
  • 40
    didn't want to reignite the burning anger I was feeling already due to a personal situation, so I just dismissed her. About 15 minutes later, I was running the main
  • 41
    register asking people for donations and ringing them up. Once my time was up, I had a 15 minute break. I grabbed a small bag, went to the
  • 42
    break room, grabbed my belongings, started putting things I had to return to the company (key card for the gate, building key, radio, name tag, and a couple other
  • 43
    items), and drove to the National Park museum which was about a 2 minute drive up from the visitor center. I walked in and Jane happened to be covering a lunch
  • 44
    break there. I dropped the bag on the counter and told her to take it to John when she was done, then walked out and drove away. After that, I wrote a message to John,
  • 45
    the HR representative for the retail team, and the HR director submitting my immediate resignation and the reasoning behind it.
  • 46
    After that, I get a call from the HR director asking me to tell her what happened. I told her and she asked if I felt like that I could've talked to John or herself to
  • 47
    discuss it further. I flat out told her "Absolutely not." I then mentioned the couple times that complaints were made against Noelle before the first incident between
  • 48
    Jane, herself, and I and that action wasn't taken. And because of that, I couldn't trust HR to take action against Noelle, whether it would be a demotion or termination. I
  • 49
    would've accepted either outcome. She then told me that she would work on retraining management. A month later, Noelle is still working there.
  • 50
    She is still a supervisor and as far as I know, there was no action taken or retraining. Jane has told me that she has been thinking about leaving soon.
  • 51
    Story over. Should I have made a different approach to this? Should I have just let out my frustrations to Noelle? Should I still try to do something about it now?
  • 52
    Interested to hear your thoughts. EDIT: The issue was the constant micromanaging and unprofessionalism from Noelle and signaling Jane and I
  • 53
    out, as well as no disciplinary action taken from HR since there were other complaints against her. The other management team members didn't
  • 54
    have problems with anyone talking or rarely goofing off since we didn't let it affect our work.
  • 55

    Commenters were concerned about a potentially unreliable narrator here

    Spirited-Water1368 It's wild to me that every time Noelle reprimanded you for talking with your coworker, you argued with her about it.
  • 56
    srod9 You seem to have been setting up a whole narrative through your story about Jane and Noelle. Specifically, that Jane was jealous about Noelle. To be very honest, it's hard to tell
  • 57
    the actual story about what happened. All I can tell is that you were all coworkers and clashed as some point. Just let it be.
  • 58
    Man in plaid shirt stands in forest setting next to woman in green sweater pouring coffee and another woman in a yellow hat and green jacket

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article