Brother demands half of sister's inherited land after selling his own share for a failed business, but she refuses: ‘I shouldn’t have to lose my inheritance because of his decision’

Advertisement
  • Pensive young woman with long braids resting her hand on her cheek while sitting outdoors on a quiet wooded path.
  • AITAH for refusing to give my brother half my inherited land after he sold his share against everyone’s advice?

    1 (32F) was born and raised in the slams of kibera in kenya. With nothing much but I had most of the basic needs.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • My granddad had a 32 acres piece of land that he divided between me and my two brothers (his grand children) I don't know why but this was his will.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • I our mom told us to take care of him so i think this triggered him.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Even when he got dementia he could only remember our names. before he passed away three years ago.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • My older brother got the biggest portion since he's the firstborn, and my younger brother and I got smaller pieces.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • At the time everyone agreed with the arrangement and there was no conflict. Even from his children.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Thoughtful young woman with braided hair sitting by a window, resting her head on her hand while gazing off to the side.
  • The problem started last year when my younger brother decided to sell his land. He said he wanted to start a business in town.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • My mum, my older brother, and even some relatives told him not to sell it because land is something you can never replace once it's gone.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • He didn't listen. He had this promising business idea. He sold it anyway for what I personally think was a very low price.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • The business he started failed within a few months and now the money is gone. Recently he came to me and asked if I could give him half of my land so he could build a house.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Young woman with braided hair looking upward outdoors, standing in front of blurred green trees in a park setting.
  • I told him I felt bad about his situation, but I didn't think it was fair because he already had land and chose to sell it.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • He got really upset and said I'm being selfish and that siblings are supposed to support each other.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Now my mum has started pressuring me, saying that since I'm not married yet I "don't need that much land anyway" and that my brother needs it more.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Some relatives are also saying family land should stay within the family and that I should help him because he made a mistake.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • But the thing is, I've been planning to build a house and start farming on that land in the next couple of years.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • If I give him half of it, those plans are basically ruined. My older brother told me privately that I shouldn't give up any land because it won't stop there and I'll end up losing more.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Now family gatherings are awkward and my mum keeps hinting that I should reconsider because my brother is struggling.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • He is currently living with my mom in the same house. Part of me feels guilty because he's my sibling and he genuinely has nowhere to build now or bounce back.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • But another part of me feels like I shouldn't have to lose my inheritance because of his decision.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • AITAH for refusing to give him half of my land?
    via Kilonzo_P
  • duehickey NTA He had the same amount of land as you and decided to sell it, how is it fair on yourself or your other brother if he takes half of your share. He should own up to the fact that he made a bad decision and sort it out himself.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply This is what my big brother told me.... But again my mom has nothing to give him it's just me and my other brother
    via Kilonzo_P
  • duehickey If he really wants the land he can work hard and try and repurchase the land he sold beforehand, it was his decision to do so and it's unfair on you for him to try and take your share because he sold his.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply We tried to repurchase but holly Chrt the person wants triple the amount. Market price
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Fearless-Speech-1131 As an African, I'm familiar with this sh. Our families have this nasty habit of coddling male kids and manipulating females into mothering them with self sacrifice. Do not do it.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply I heard you. I will fight for what is mine
    via Kilonzo_P
  • ploud1 NTA He successfully completed the 'f... around' phase. Now it's time he finds out.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply Exactly my brother's words... The older one
    via Kilonzo_P
  • No_Wishbone_4829 Why has he not asked older brother for some of his
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply They assume i will get married and leave the land.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • ChaosCoordinator42 NTA. If his business had been wildly successful, would he have shared a large portion of the profits with you? According to him, siblings should support each other. You know he wouldn't have shared the profits. So he doesn't get a share of your inheritance.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply I had not think about this at all... He didn't even share the money he got from selling the land... This is absolutely true thanks
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Tal_Tos_72 Cop on to yourself. Seriously cop on and stop letting him and others walk all over you. Look at it this way, if you also sold your land and it failed. Who in their right mind would then just give you half THEIR property? Would you really expect your older brother to say to you "here you can now have the downstairs of my house because you are my brother"??? NO Just next time anyone asks. Just say "NO" and do NOT get into any discussions on it, don't elaborate, don't justify. Just shut
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply Thanks. I have just remembered 'no' is a complete sentence
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Is __ It ___ Clean __ Yet There you go, OP, there's a fellow African, who (I assume!) understands a h I of a lot more than a lot of us on this thread do, telling you to NOT to "help" your brother. Is there a lawyer or someone that helps with these kinds of disputes? Like, can you find a way, legally, to keep your brother from contacting you, or a way you can leave your land to your (much wiser!) older brother if something happens to you? I'm being honest here..... is it common in these situation
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply Thank you so much. I will look into this.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • TheNorthC Let's turn this around. If YOU had sold your land and lost everything, would your brother give you half of his? Would your mother be pressuring your brother to give you his land?
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply Tbh... NO... I was not even involved when they were selling his piece... Like in Kenya if you sell a land you need atleast 3 witnesses and a community leader... I heard about it from my elder bro. If I did this and came back they'd tell me "usijali utapata kwako" translate to don't worry you'll get married soon. Sharing their land would not be on the table at all.
    via Kilonzo_P
  • AlleviateMyguSh NTA: And the audacity of it all, you must protect yourself at all times. Even from family
    via Kilonzo_P
  • Kilonzo_P Original Poster's Reply Being a woman right! But I will fight for my piece
    via Kilonzo_P
Scroll Down For The Next Article