Job applicant hangs up during third interview after interviewer refuses to disclose salary to him for the third time: 'I need to make sure we're on the same page'

Advertisement
  • A businessman sitting at a table with tea writes in his notebook
  • I just hung up on a final interview call because they refused to discuss salary for the third time. Did I make a huge mistake?

    Guys, I need to know if I'm crazy or not. A few weeks ago, I was in the third and final interview for a senior project manager position at a large, well-known tech company (you've definitely heard of them, not some small startup).
  • The first couple of interviews went great. We had chemistry, the technical stuff was fun, and they kept telling me how my experience was a perfect fit for them.
  • But one thing was really bothering me: none of them wanted to give me a straight answer about the salary.
  • Round one (with the recruiter): "That's handled later by the compensation team." Round two (with the hiring manager): "We prefer to focus on the role fit first before discussing compensation." So today, in the final round with the department head, I decided to be direct and upfront.
  • Midway through the conversation, I told him: "I'm very interested in this role, but after three interviews and a take- home assignment that took me 6 hours, I need to know the salary range to make sure we're on the same page.
  • Can you share it with me before we continue?" He gave me a plastic smile and hit me with the classic line, "Company policy prevents us from discussing any numbers before a formal offer is made," and tried to change the subject.
  • I paused for a second, told him, "Thank you for your time, but I don't think this is a good fit for me," and I ended the call.
  • No yelling or anything, just... Done. Now I'm second-guessing everything. On one hand, I feel like I stood up for myself and my dignity.
  • This whole 'not discussing salary' thing is a power play and a devaluation of my time.
  • Imagine if we all started doing this? Maybe companies would finally get the message. On the other hand, my brain is screaming at me that I was reckless.
  • The job market is tough these days, and I might have thrown away a huge opportunity for the sake of a principle.
  • What if the offer was going to be amazing? So, what do you all think? Have you ever had to take a firm stand like this in an interview?
  • Is this secrecy around salaries just part of the game, or are things getting better? Should I have just played along and waited for the offer?
  • A businessman talks on his cell phone
  • Thebrianeffect Hr guy here. You did the right thing. If they don't tell you numbers until that late in the game, they are hiding something. I can't imagine posting a job without a salary let alone hiding it if someone asked. Also, 6 hours for a task? GTFOH. I'd have ran at that point.
  • malicious_joy42 It's not even legal in my state to post a job without a reasonable range. You did the right thing. They would have lowballed you anyway. A company that outright refuses to honor your time is also wasting their own.
  • OkTreat6460 6 hours of work and no pay? That says it all. These companies are getting ridiculous!
  • Priorowner 1989 Sounds like you dodged a bullet.
  • tinylittlepoopman HR/TA Exec here: Yes, this is crazy. If I really needed a job BAD I'd keep on, but it's insane not to talk about comp on call one. If you're misaligned, you're wasting the hiring team's time AND disrespecting the candidate. Good for you!
  • Lil-AngelGurl_99 So its not a two way street with these people....they have no respect for your time they could at least give you a range or something and you would know then whether its worth continuing. It's almost like buying a car without photos..
  • Main_Fudge_1796 You did the right thing IMO. People need to know numbers, especially this current economy. People have bills, mortgages and rent, families.....good for you!
  • Choices63 HR guy here for 25+ years. You did the right thing. I've posted the salary range my entire career. I talk about it in the first conversation and make sure my staff does as well. Anything less is bulls game playing and if that's how it's going to start, you definitely don't want to work there. It's just going to get worse.
  • slash1011 I wouldn't have progressed past round one without knowing the salary was aligned. Companies who won't discuss rem baffle me. Interviews should be a two way identification of fit, and a crucial part is rem. They've just wasted a whole bunch of time (yours and theirs) for no reason now.
  • Impossible_Log_9936 Good for you! I'm in HR and there is no way in h I they didn't already have the salary range. It most likely didn't justify the amount of work they asked of you.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article