Widow refuses to let her 17 and 22-year-old sons call their stepdad of 15 years their 'dad': 'My late husband's worst fear was they would grow up without him and forget him.'

Advertisement
  • Two men standing next to each other in front of a fence
  • Am I the bad guy for never letting my kids call or refer to their stepdad as dad, even after 15 years?

    I was widowed 18 years ago after my 1st husband's long illness. We had two small children, and his worst fear was they would grow up without him and forget him.
  • I swore this would never happen. I remarried my now husband and he knew the promise I had made.
  • He never interfered until recently, when our "ours" baby started asking why her brothers don't call him dad.
  • He told her that " mom says no". She's eight, so I had to explain that their real daddy is in heaven and her daddy is here.
  • Later, my husband expressed to me that it hurt him that I always had corrected the boys and anyone else who ever called him my boys father.
  • He says it makes him feel like I don't really care about him. I told him he knew the deal when we got married.
  • He says he feels like an outsider and our daughter does too. I asked my boys about it today and the youngest said he used to think it was weird but " it is what it is".
  • My oldest said he is glad I kept my promise to his dad. My sister, however, thinks I was selfish and that's why my boys are "cold" to their half sister.
  • AITAH? ETA my son's are 19 and 22. I was 17 when I had the oldest.
  • I've been married to the second husband for 15 years. ETA: well I suppose I'm the ah_le and better do some counseling if this marriage is going to work.
  • I can't make the boys have a closer relationship with their sister but I guess I should get her some too.
  • ComprehensiveAd2037 Sorry but YTA.... it's shouldn't be your pressure to make them call or not call him "dad" it should've been their choices that you took from them. You are the reason why many guys don't want to be step dads..
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply He didn't have to marry me if it was an issue, and he went into it knowingly.
  • FloMoJoeBlow YTA for gatekeeping the "Dad" name. Who cares (besides you) whether the boys call him Dad? Actually, that would have been an awesome sign of respect to him for stepping into the role. But... also want to clarify that the decision as to what the boys call him should be between them and your husband. Not yours.
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply Their dad's parents and the rest of the family would care.
  • An older couple sitting on a bench in a park
  • No_Age_4267 Saying "he didn't have to marry me if it was an issue" sounds like a convenient excuse to ignore his feelings. Sure, he knew your history -but marriage isn't a contract to silently endure feeling like an outsider. Expecting him to just accept being pushed aside? That's selfish, not strong. Brushing off his pain because he "knew what he was getting into" shuts down any chance for real connection and only breeds resentment. If you want a partner, you have to meet him halfway not throw
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply I don't see how I pushed him aside. He is their stepdad, and they love him as their stepdad. He just is not their dad.
  • [deleted] He's been a father figure to these kids for 15 years and it seems like you don't want him to be a father figure in their life. If you didn't want him to be a father figure to your kids, why did you marry him?
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply Because I loved him and he seemed to be fine with being a stepfather, and said he understood that my boys had a father and would not overstep. He asked me three times before I said ves btw.
  • [deleted] So he intentionally purposefully set your sons ups for failure? Like what an awful hill to di on. Genuinely asking- your current husband has clothed, fed, nourished, supported, raised these kids as his own. Has loved them as his own. And they willinging could call the man who has been their father for all intents and purposes who has been their dad. But you have ingrained in them he is not their father despite all the evidence otherwise. Wow what a parent and partner. I mean how many R
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply If you really are asking, you can read my comments and see that I never asked him to financially contribute or even babysit my boys. Our daughter, yes he pays for. ETA: my first husband loved those boys more than anything in this world. He did not want them to fail.
  • mayfeelthis Info: do you understand the difference between teaching the kids about their bio Dad/your first husband and appreciating their stepdad the way they want to and do? The word dad has nothing to do with the first part, I do think you're being shortsighted to think calling their stepdad dad is the same as teaching them about their father and keeping his memory alive. It's not, you're dismissing your kids and under appreciating their stepdad instead - that's not at all keeping the first d
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply My first husband specifically did not want his kids to forget him and call someone else dad. In my mind, my husband gets to see his daughter grow up and had a good relationship with my sons. My first husband didn't get any of that, so I honor what I can. I couldn't give him more years, I couldn't fix his health, but I can keep my word to him.
  • mayfeelthis lol yet you're the mother of your kids...funny you care more about everyone else but them and your husband. Honestly YTA - I tried being kind but reading your replies (after I'd commented), you're truly self righteous and justify yourself on top of being wrong. Why even ask peoples opinions? You only care about yours.
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply Yes, and like I said, I'm keeping promise.
  • [deleted] Info: do you tell your kids they're not allowed to call your husband 'dad'?
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply When they were little, they asked why they didn't call "Steve", let's call him, dad, a few times that I remember. Stuff like that. I basically always said because Steve is Steve, your dad is in heaven. Steve is my husband.
  • [deleted] Did your late husband prohibit you from marrying again or finding love within another relationship? Was this also a part of his wishes?
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply Nope. He said I was "young and beautiful and smart, and should move on" and then he said "don't let my boys forget me, I don't want them to call anyone else daddy ". I promised that would never happen.
  • A woman sitting at a coffin with her hands on her head
  • Derwin0 BFD This is between the kids and him. You are keeping a wall of separation between them that makes no sense. Their relationship with him in no way diminishes the one they had with their father. Or are you really afraid they'll choose him over you?
  • Hot-Bed-8194 Original Poster's Reply According to my oldest, he thinks of him as like a close Uncle. My youngest and him are a bit closer. My oldest is out of the house at college, so the ball is in his court if he wants a more fatherly bond. My youngest doesn't really seem to want to call him dad at this point either.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article