Woman devastated after 7-month search for dog lost in house fire ends with rescuer refusing to give her back, rescuer says: 'I've adopted her and she's mine'

Legally, this rescuer is in the right. But more importantly, are they morally wrong?

A bond between a human and doggo is unlike any other. Your dog loves you more than anything in the world (except for maybe peanut butter, or chicken), and they are always by your side when you need them. They keep you company while you cry. They make you smile every day when you come home from work to see their wagging tails and smiling faces. You experience countless sunrises and sunsets with them. But what would you do if you found out the dog you loved wasn't actually yours?

Our dog lover below found a lonely pupper, underweight and with dirty fur, 7 months ago. They called animal control, checked for a microchip, but nothing. With nowhere else for the dog to go, they decided to adopt them. Over the course of those 7 months, they developed an incredibly deep bond with this doggo… until they got tagged in a picture on Facebook and a message from a dog owner across the country.

The dog that they had rescued was hers. The dog had run away after her house caught fire and she spent 7 tireless months looking for her. What did the rescuer do? They refused to give the dog back because of the relationship they had built with the pupper they saved and nursed back to health.

Dog ownership, at least in the United States, treats dogs like property. If you have documentation proving that the dog is yours (i.e. - a microchip, or vet bills), then you can legally claim the dog as yours. However, should we really be nitpicking the legality of ownership when it comes to something so personal? The previous owner spent 5 years loving her dog, training her, she even won championship titles. She has 5 years of memories with her, only for the dog to be taken away, dare we say "stolen", after a terrible disaster.

If you care about stories like this, and don't ever want your dog to end up in somebody else's hands because of a legal technicality, call your representatives and ask them to change the laws around pet ownership. There is strength in numbers, and if enough of us speak up, then change will happen, and stories like this will be a thing of the past.

01
[Am I wrong] for refusing to return a lost dog that was clearly well loved?

via Diana from Pexels

Dog Walking Alone on a Dirt Road
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
02

via whosedogisitanyway
03

via whosedogisitanyway
04

via whosedogisitanyway
05

via whosedogisitanyway
06

via whosedogisitanyway
07

via Østby Simonsen

Human–canine bonding between dog and owner
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
08

via whosedogisitanyway
09

via whosedogisitanyway
10

via whosedogisitanyway
11

via whosedogisitanyway
12

via Nevena1987

Man hugging his dog at sunset
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
13

via whosedogisitanyway
14

via whosedogisitanyway
15

via whosedogisitanyway
16

via IPretendIMatter
17

via reddit
18

via Alternative_Answer
19

via Alternative_Answer
20

via Jaedeite
21

via laurenhunt_88
22

via laurenhunt_88
23

via arieljoc
24

via arieljoc
25

via arieljoc
26

via arieljoc
27

via arieljoc
28

via arieljoc
29

via arieljoc
30

via arieljoc
31

via arieljoc
32

via arieljoc
33

via arieljoc
34

via arieljoc
35

via arieljoc