Man refuses to give his sentimental PS4 to his cousin, who found it in his room, and gets called a freeloader by his aunt

• 
  via Oleg Ivanov

  Man smiling while playing video games with a controller, sitting on a couch next to another player.

  ^{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• AITJ for not handing down/gifting my console

  
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via Nik

  Person holding a wired game controller while sitting cross-legged on a carpeted floor.

  ^{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01

• The aunt is the engine of this whole disaster. Her son wandered into someone else's room without permission, grabbed a console that was not his, and her response was not to correct him but to immediately start working the room for support. Well you got him all excited so you have to give it now is not a parenting philosophy, it is a hostage negotiation conducted through a crying child. The tears in the corner are doing exactly the job they were deployed to do, and she is the one who deployed them.

• 
  via FellowTarnished01

• The freeloader comment is where things shifted, and it’s worth sitting with that for a second. 

  When a reasonable request meets a firm no, and the adult on the other side has nothing left, they go personal. Man-child freeloader is not a spontaneous observation, it is a weapon grabbed off the shelf because the actual argument had already been lost. Someone who pays rent, contributes to groceries and utilities, and simply does not want to give away a sentimental possession is not a freeloader. She just needed a word that would sting enough to end the conversation in her favor.

• 
  via FellowTarnished01

• The bad wife comment was the line that cleared the room, and like one would expect, it landed below the belt. But it also arrived after being insulted in front of a room full of family for the crime of not surrendering property that was never up for grabs in the first place. People who throw personal attacks tend to act surprised when they get one back.

• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01

• The console was a gift from his father. It was kept in good condition. It was sitting in his own room. The only misunderstanding here is that some people heard the word no and decided it was optional.

• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01
• 
  via FellowTarnished01

Tags