-
01
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
-
"Three years ago my boss gave me 15% equity in our agency instead of a raise. Now I owe $14k in estimated taxes next week for profits I’m not allowed to touch."
I’ve been the creative director at a boutique marketing agency for five years. Three years ago, instead of a salary bump, the founder offered me a 15% ownership stake in the LLC. At the time, it felt like a huge win.
Fast forward to this year: in January, we landed two massive enterprise clients. The agency’s revenue has absolutely skyrocketed this spring. It should be a great thing, but the founder is choosing to keep 100% of the cash inside the business to hire more staff and sign a lease on a much larger office space. He hasn't paid out any profit dividends to the owners.
-
02
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
-
A creative director at a boutique marketing agency was offered something that sounded a lot more exciting than a traditional raise: a 15% ownership stake in the company. At the time, it felt like recognition for years of hard work and loyalty. Ownership sounds impressive. Ownership sounds like a seat at the table. Ownership sounds like the kind of opportunity people spend their careers chasing. Fast forward a few years and the agency is thriving. Two major clients came on board, revenue exploded, and the business is growing faster than ever. On paper, this should be a success story. Instead, it's turned into a tax nightmare.
Because the agency operates as a pass-through entity, the creative director recently learned that he's personally responsible for paying taxes on his share of the company's profits, even though he hasn't actually received any of those profits. The founder has chosen to keep all of the money inside the business to fund expansion plans, hire new employees, and secure a larger office space. Meanwhile, one of the minority owners is staring down a $14,000 tax bill and wondering how he's supposed to pay it. And let's just say that the boss's response wasn't exactly comforting. "That's the reality of being a business owner."
Technically, there may be some truth to that statement. Being a business owner isn't always glamorous. There are risks involved. There are taxes, obligations, and financial responsibilities that don't exist when you're simply collecting a paycheck. Plenty of entrepreneurs have stories about draining savings accounts, taking personal risks, and making sacrifices to keep a business alive. The problem is that most business owners accept those risks because they're also sharing in the rewards.
-
03
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
-
"Yesterday, the company’s accountant sent me an email reminding me that Q2 estimated taxes are due on June 15th. They attached a worksheet showing that because the LLC is a "pass-through entity," I am personally responsible for the taxes on my 15% share of the massive Q1/Q2 paper profit. My estimated tax voucher for next week is roughly $14,000.
I literally do not have $14,000 in my personal savings. I am paying taxes out of my standard W-2 salary on money the company earned, but that the founder is hoarding to fund his own expansion plans."
-
04
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
-
It's hard to feel like an owner when you're being handed the bill without being handed any of the money. Ownership is supposed to mean participating in the upside, not just the downside. While the founder is making decisions about how to use company profits, one of his partners is apparently being asked to fund those decisions with his own personal bank account.
The situation highlights something that often gets overlooked when companies offer equity instead of raises. Equity sounds valuable, and sometimes it absolutely is. But ownership structures come with complexities that employees don't always fully understand when they're signing the paperwork. The word "owner" can mean very different things depending on who controls the cash flow and who gets to make the decisions.
At the end of the day, most people wouldn't object to paying taxes on profits they actually received. Paying thousands of dollars in taxes on money you've never touched is a much harder pill to swallow. That's why so many readers came away from this story with the same reaction: if you're expected to act like an owner when the tax bill arrives, maybe you should be treated like one when the profits do too.
-
05
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
-
"When I brought this up to my boss, he just shrugged and said, "That's the reality of being a business owner."
Is this actually how equity works? Am I legally forced to drain my personal bank account to pay the IRS for company profits I haven't received a single dime of? Do I have any right to demand he releases enough cash to at least cover the tax bill?"
-
06
Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.
-
ok i have some direct experience here, ran an llc with multiple employee owners. The way it is normally handled (and they way we handled it) was to distribute enough $$ to offset the tax liability for the owners. So if we had zero $ distribution in a year despite the company making a profit THEN we would pay the owners an amount equal to the tax burden for their share of the profit (usually about 33% for our situation). This is how it is meant to work. You are being scammed by your majority owner. Check the llc articles of organization, they often mention this scenario. If they do not then you should check the members voting right and meeting requirements. Better yet, talk directly to your boss/ owner and let him know this is not going to fly, is not normal and is burdensome for you.
-
A key takeaway from all of us should be if you have a 15% of a thriving business you need to have your own counsel. Not only should you have a lawyer but also your own CPA.
-
See an attorney. Sounds like you may be in a very tenuous situation. I have questions like, what type of paperwork was done at the time you were given 15% ownership? Are you receiving full financial statements from the company (as an owner shouldn’t you get that information)? Do you really understand the legal ownership and obligations you have? Are you actually a 15% owner of the company (ie do you have legal standing)? What are your rights here?
-
Fine if he does not want to pay out to cover the taxes, then ask him for the latest 3rd party independent valuation (One of those can cost $$$$) of the company as you may need to sell your share to cover the cost. If they don’t have one, look at your partnership agreement, you may be able to request one.
Most likely they will change their tune as the possibility of a 3rd party or even a competitor buying into the company. They may have a right of 1st refusal, but that means that to buy you out they have to at least match the best offer.
-
I guarantee the majority owner took a distribution for his tax liability. You are getting screwed. Request a full profit and loss statement as well as all payments out
-
Someone smarter than me please correct me if I'm wrong, but to my knowledge, you cannot simultaneously be a W2 employee and an equity stakeholder in an LLC. If the LLC is taxed as a standard partnership or proprietorship, I think any equity member MUST be a partner, and thus not a W2 employee. I believe this is different for S/C-Corps. Now, I'm sure there are some weird loopholes that I'm not aware of; maybe there is some "shadow equity" at play here?
-
The business (or in this case, passthrough owners) is taxed on profits, not gross revenue. If the business is expanding, its expenses are also going up. Why is the profit going up that much?
-
What the boss is doing is legal or could be done legally. How this typically works is parties are reasonable and distribute enough to cover tax liabilities. If you haven’t already check you have rights to all financials and should be checking over distribution and salary’s paid to boss.
-
"No cash, have a piece of the company instead"
"No bonus, have to retain cash - have a tax bill instead"
You're getting played. See the other comments for remedies, but this person could skate with the till and leave you holding the bag for all the debt and tax liability when they can't be found.
Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.