Weirdest Sandwiches That Sandwich Shop Workers Had To Make

Author image for mattstaff
mattstaff
Nov 10, 2021 10:00 AM EST

Sandwich shop workers are on the frontlines of having to field some truly far fetched sandwich requests. If you've ever given yourself over to imagining the grossest possible sandwich combinations that you can imagine, just rest assured that there's definitely someone out there who is eating that very sandwich. Some people just have remarkably strange tastes. 

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • 01
    Font - ZombieloverBrandon • 1d Worked at a Subway for a year. This couple comes in, the lady orders a chicken bacon ranch. When we get to the dressing, she says "Oh, and lots of spicy buffalo sauce." The man says "Oh man, here we go again..." | chuckle as I put a very generous amount across her footlong. Her eyes hold for a moment on the sandwich, as if somehow already disappointed by the buffalo- soaked bread and sternly says "More." I put another layer on, almost the same amount as the first.
    via r/AskReddit
  • 02
    Product - This is a friend of mine who I went to subway with, and if you question our friendship after reading this know I did, too. He ordered a foot long on white bread, black olives, and mayo. That's it. Just a bread gutter stuffed with olives and mayo. O 6 Reply 4 435 3
    via r/AskReddit
  • 03
    Font - Junior_Cress2828 · 1d e 2 Awards My mom has worked at subway for a lot of years! This one was fairly recent. My mom got a delivery order (from grubhub or doordash) and the note was (extra extra extra pickles, extra extra extra vinegar, I'm pregnant please add more than you think is enough) So my mom put regular extra pickles, regular extra vinegar on her sandwich, and then filled a soup cup with pickles, put a lid on it, filled a soup cup with vinegar, put a lid on it, and put them in the
    via r/AskReddit
  • 04
    Rectangle - psanchez_1 · 1d Worked at a deli for a bit and one time a woman came and in asked for the rarest cut of roast we had then asked me to cut out all the brown and put it on multigrain bread with lettuce and tomato G Reply 4 63 3 ...
    via r/AskReddit
  • 05
    Font - stantheman1976 · 1d I worked at subway for 3 years out of high school, MANY moons ago. Probably the most disgusting I remember was this woman who always ordered a footlong seafood and wanted the top drenched in mayo. We'd use almost the entire squeeze bottle of mayo. It was literally oozing off the sides. We called her Dragon Lady. One of the girls gave her the nickname. O 6 Reply ↑ 63 3
    via r/AskReddit
  • 06
    Font - PineappleAnkle · 1d 1 Award Mayonnaise and jam G Reply 1 139 3 +
    via r/AskReddit
  • 07
    Font - urbanlulu · 1d it wasn't a sandwich shop, but we sold sub sandwiches in our deli and we'd make them for customers. this one lunch rush i was working, this man comes in with his wife to get sandwiches and she gives her order and he goes to give his. this dude literally asked me to drown his sandwich in mayo. i thought he was joking so i asked again and he was like "no seriously, i love mayo. put as much on there as you can." so i did, i put so much mayo on that sandwich i could barley slic
    via r/AskReddit
  • 08
    Rectangle - WynterSkies · 1d I worked at a grocery store deli and this guy got an Italian, then had me put almost all the banana peppers i had in my little dish on it then the entire squirter bottle of vinegar. It was a soggy awful mess to wrap G Reply 1 41 3 ...
    via r/AskReddit
  • 09
    Font - _Nick_2711_ · 1d Not a sandwich shop but a pizza place. Every week this lady would order ham and sweetcorn with no cheese. Another dude would order ham and cheese with no sauce. I really considered setting them up together. G Reply 159 3 ...
    via r/AskReddit
  • 10
    Font - ChildofChaos • 1d Peanut butter, Onion + Ketchup G Reply 38 3
    via r/AskReddit
  • 11
    Font - AverageStormTrooper1 · 1d Working at Wendys for the past 4 years I have plenty of these stories. Among my favorites is the tale of Ranch Guy. He would come through and order two spicy chicken sandwiches with ranch instead of mayo. This was fine, except he would come in the next time and say, "Y'all didn't put enough ranch on last time." This continued for about two weeks. Eventually I got fed up with his nonsense and literally dunked the fillets in the ranch sauce. Ranch actually squirted
    via r/AskReddit
  • 12
    Font - sloppyjoesandwich · 1d Not a sandwich shop but I worked at a Pizza Hut when we had a special where you could have any pizza with unlimited toppings for one price. We would advise people against more than 5 toppings as the pizza wouldn't cook thoroughly. People didn't care, they would order 10+ toppings and l'd cut it and it would be raw in the middle. You run it through the oven again and it's still raw but now the outside is burnt. Surprisingly only a handful of those people called to co
    via r/AskReddit
  • 13
    Rectangle - Billbaporno · 1d Calzone (imagine a big stuffed pizza pocket) - guy wanted it filled with ketchup, and only ketchup. We only had pizza sauce, and told him that, so he brought his own bottle of Heinz. G Reply 1 399
    via r/AskReddit
  • 14
    Font - Shilokki • 1d Not a sandwich maker, but a barista that made food. I had a customer ask if I could make the bagel 'healthier' by removing the bread inside and stuffing the carcass of the bagel with cream cheese. Not necessarily abominable – certainly stupid.
    via r/AskReddit
  • 15
    Font - car-nut00 · 1d Subway. Customer ordered a tuna and meatball sub. Yes, you read that right. Tuna on the bottom, topped with meatballs and sauce. Charged him for the extra meat and he sat in the dining room and ate the whole thing. G Reply 1 61 ...
    via r/AskReddit
  • 16
    Rectangle - dd28064212· 1d I'm not a sandwich shop worker, but I have a coworker who routinely orders a cinnamon raisin bagel with herb and garlic cream cheese and a slice of tomato. G Reply ...
    via r/AskReddit
  • 17
    Font - ReasonablySizedOwl • 1d I work at subway, its gotta be a tie between toasted tuna with marinara sauce and an untoasted steak sandwich, I'm convinced that the second one was ordered by a psychopath G Reply 4 16
    via r/AskReddit
  • 18
    Font - SmoochTalk · 1d I worked at the campus center cafe in college. When you signed up for a meal plan at my school, you got a certain number of "college bucks" that could be spent at the cafe. They didn't roll over to the next year, so towards the end of one semester these guys I knew came in and ordered a sandwich with basically everything on it in order to try to spend as much as possible. I think it was a burger with tuna, roast beef, turkey, probably every other lunch meat we had, plus a
    via r/AskReddit
  • 19
    Rectangle - bobo76565657 • 1d Olives and mustard. Just olives and a LOT of mustard (subway). G Reply * 10 3 ..
    via r/AskReddit
  • 20
    Rectangle - 7437ru744ur75 · 1d Nova lox on a cinnamon raisin bagel with vanilla cream cheese. G Reply 4 10 3 ...
    via r/AskReddit

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

customer service wtf gross cringe bizarre askreddit Reddit weird
Scroll Down For The Next Article