Woman has different upbringing than much younger sister, tells sister when she's old enough that she had no choice but to move out, mom gets mad: 'I don’t resent her for it, but it does make it hard for her to understand my perspective sometimes'

Author image for Baiz Hoen
Baiz Hoen
Feb 21, 2025 6:00 PM EST

Growing up with siblings gives you a unique perspective on fairness. If you and your sibling are very different people, you're going to bear witness to some very different parenting styles. Often, older siblings are subjected to rules and regulations, while younger siblings get much more leniency. Older siblings can have more pressure to perform, to carry out the family's legacy, and to live up to the family name. Sometimes, it can be frustrating to watch your sibling receive gifts and privileges that you were never awarded as a kid. Especially if you are far apart in age, you may have had a completely different upbringing entirely than your sibling. This can sometimes lead to resentment and hurt, but, for the most part, it's just the way the cookie crumbles.

One woman experienced this divide in parenting with her sister, who is ten years younger than her. This woman grew up with a lot fewer privileges than her sister and was expected to move out when she was 18 and put her way through school. When her sister asked her why she moved out so soon, this woman told her the truth, which caused her mother to accuse her of guilting her sister. Read on to see how it all plays out.

Advertisement
  • 01
    Cheezburger Image 10468053504
    via kylebroad
  • 02

    "AITA for Telling My Sister the Truth About Why I Moved Out So Young?"

    I (27F) have a younger half-sister, Emma (17F). We share the same mom but have different dads. Our mom had me at 19, and my early years were... rough. She did her best, but we struggled. I spent a lot of time with my grandma while my mom worked long hours. Money was always tight, and stability was a luxury we didn't have.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 03
    By the time Emma was born, things had changed a lot. My mom had married Emma's dad, and they had a house, a good income, and a completely different life. Emma grew up with things I never had-piano lessons, vacations, a stable home, and two parents who were there for her. And that's great-l never resented her for it. But it did mean that by the time I was a teenager, I felt like an outsider in my own home.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 04
    When I turned 18, it was pretty much unspoken but understood- I was expected to move out and figure things out on my own.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 05
    There wasn't a conversation about staying. No offer of help with college. Just... "You're an adult now." So I left. I worked my way through school, took on multiple jobs, and built my life from scratch while Emma got to just be a kid.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 06
    Fast forward to last weekend. I was over for dinner, and Emma casually asked, "Why did you move out so early?" I gave a vague answer about wanting to be independent, but she kept pushing. She said something like, "Mom told me you just wanted to do your own thing, that you were always stubborn and didn't like following rules."
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 07
    That stung. That wasn't the truth at all. So, I told her, as gently as I could, that it wasn't exactly a choice. That by the time I turned 18, there really wasn't a place for me in the house anymore. That
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 08
    me in the house anymore. That our mom and her husband were focused on their life with her, and I had to figure things out on my own. I reassured her that I don't blame her for any of it, and I'm happy she had a stable childhood --but that our experiences were just different.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 09
    She got really quiet and didn't say much for the rest of the night. Later, my mom called me, angry, saying I made Emma feel guilty and "painted her childhood as something she should feel bad about." She said I should've let it go instead of "bringing up old wounds that don't matter anymore."
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 10
    That wasn't my intention at all. I wasn't trying to make Emma feel bad, just help her understand why I'm not as close to the family as she is. But now I feel guilty- should I have just stuck to the easy answer instead of telling the truth? AITA?
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 11

    People in the comments consoled this woman and told her what she said was okay.

    chen Kitchen
    via allysphotos
  • 12
    NTA. The a h le is the mother who failed you. If she didn't want you to tell your sister what really happened your mother should have found something else to tell her that didn't involve lies about you.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 13
    Don't sugarcoat your childhood in some misconception that you're protecting your sister. You're merely giving an excuse to the parental unit to hide what they did to you. In fact, I would broadcast it to your relatives. You did nothing wrong and if you're LC with them, you won't be losing family you never truly had. So sorry to hear this.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 14
    NTA. Good for you not letting your parents get away with a lie. You were very gentle and made it very obvious that you dont feel deprived and don't resent your sister who you love and who clearly loves you and it will probably ensure that she is compassionate to those less fortunate than herself and grateful for the privilege she had.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 15
    Maybe have a follow up check in with her without mom interceding and just let her know mom said that and you were worried and didn't want her to feel guilty about her upbringing at all, that
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 16
    Nta, she asked and you answered truthfully. Your mother's feelings are not your problem just like yours were not hers when you were 18.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 17
    NTA. You had a rough childhood and you don't owe anyone silence about that fact.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 18
    In addition, your mom was married with a husband and a child by the time you left so, no, her being young is no excuse for continuing to be a bad mother to you. By the time you left Emma was 8 years old. Is your mom's argument that she was still a "young mom" then? Nope.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 19
    The truth is she made no effort to be there for you and she's still leaning on the excuses she had when you were born.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 20
    And lastly, you did nothing to make Emma feel guilty. It's just that she cares more about you and empathizes with you more than your mom ever will. Look at the evidence, even now she's trying to protect Emma rather than addressing how she's failed you.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 21

    This too shall pass.

    Let this woman and her opinions pass right past you. Match her energy.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 22
    That's cute, your mother was young and struggling so she put her child in the same position, and now wants to lie to her other child about it. She's not sorry about how she treated you, she's upset about her reputation. NTA
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 23
    NTA - your upbringing was wildly different than hers, and she needed to realize that not everyone got the same perks.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 24
    She was only about 8 when you left, so she didn't see how you grew up and probably doesn't remember much from her early childhood and your teen years. But she is old enough. to understand now.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 25
    It may be worth while to let her know you're not blaming her or have a conversation about why she might feel bad. She just had a different upbringing because your mom was in a better situation when Emma came along.
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 26
    You didn't do anything wrong Emma deserved an honest answer and it's not your fault if the truth makes your mom uncomfortable...
    via MagnoliaMystice
  • 27
    This was your truth and your mom cannot change that no matter how she tries. Your sister asked and you responded honestly. It's not your fault if she internalized your words and felt bad. Your sister had more advantages than you and that is not a lie. NTA
    via MagnoliaMystice

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

family drama aita reddit story parenting family sister reddit thread Reddit moving out
Scroll Down For The Next Article